Althouse: "I've been saying that for years. Also, the author of that article once called me a peeing intellectual nobility."

५ एप्रिल, २०१२

"I've been saying that for years. Also, the author of that article once called me a peeing intellectual nobility."

My response to email from someone who sent me a link to this article.

(Here's the above-referenced urinary link.)

२३ टिप्पण्या:

TMink म्हणाले...: Apeasing? Appetizing? I don't think that word means what he thinks it means.

Trey; ५/४/१२, ८:११ AM
LarryK म्हणाले...: This is hardly cutting edge commentary, everyone know s that this has been true since 1999, at least, when The Sopranos premiered and American Beauty won the Best Picture Oscar. Since then TV has become much, much better, and movies even worse. Wolcott is behind the curve again, he should go back to reminiscing about his days hanging out at CBGBs.; ५/४/१२, ८:१२ AM
Icepick म्हणाले...: Does he know of intellectuals that don't pee? OR anyone else? Shouldn't they seek medical attention for that condition?; ५/४/१२, ८:१५ AM
rhhardin म्हणाले...: Wolcott is a famous name, some author or other. I wonder where I heard it. I think it was something to do with Thurber.

Perhaps Wolcott Gibbs, or even Alexander Woolcott ("the worst writer ever").; ५/४/१२, ८:२१ AM
rhhardin म्हणाले...: Peeing has to do with pee review, the process of assuring that published articles are correct.; ५/४/१२, ८:२३ AM
KJE म्हणाले...: TL; DR; ५/४/१२, ८:४४ AM
Lyssa म्हणाले...: That article was really terribly written - or maybe some people like that sort of thing for some reason.

That said, I've always said that a television series has the potential to be a lot better than any movies or books. When you make a movie or write a book, you craft it all at the same time - what happens in the beginning and what happens in the end all flow together - if you decide you want to change something in the end, you can tweak the beginning or middle to make them match.

A TV series can't necessarily do that. What happened in the first season lasts forever; most of the time, TV writers have no idea what will happen in the next 2-3 seasons. (I understand that the writers of 24 rarely had any idea what would happen more than 5-7 episodes in the future.) They're inherently constrained by what's already happened, and they have to work with that, grow and develop their characters, and this pushes them to be more creative and better.

Doesn't always work, of course. A lot of TV is terrible and some film and books are great. But a long-running series has more potential.; ५/४/१२, ८:५२ AM
Ann Althouse म्हणाले...: "A TV series can't necessarily do that. What happened in the first season lasts forever; most of the time, TV writers have no idea what will happen in the next 2-3 seasons. (I understand that the writers of 24 rarely had any idea what would happen more than 5-7 episodes in the future.) They're inherently constrained by what's already happened, and they have to work with that, grow and develop their characters, and this pushes them to be more creative and better."

It's like courts writing opinions where there are precedents. Doesn't necessarily make the writing better, but it certainly does require creativity to make it come out the way you want.; ५/४/१२, ९:०४ AM
F म्हणाले...: Agree with DJE: TL;DR. I will comment on Downton Abbey, though, as I see it is mentioned.

My wife and I watched several hours of Downton Abbey and were moderately caught up in it. Then one evening she turned to me and said: "this is just 'As the World Turns' with a British accent."

That did it for me. Back to listening to music.; ५/४/१२, ९:२४ AM
rhhardin म्हणाले...: I liken legal decisions to maintaining an old, large and widely used program.

Adding a new feature has to avoid queering the whole existing structure, because nobody can go back and read and understand all the code put in years ago to check for perverse consequences.

One trick for a new feature, is to first convert it to things that the program already knows about and let it go through the machinery to the point you want to change something; then do the change, converting it all back to something that the machinery knows about already, and then letting the machinery finish the job.

It's a way to guarantee zero interactions with things that already work.

The point of precedent is not tradition but avoidance of unseen interactions.; ५/४/१२, ९:३१ AM
bagoh20 म्हणाले...: "Peeing intellectual nobility"

Is that a bad thing, good or just accurate. I seriously don't know. No real insults in the phrase. Equals: Normal smart lucky. I'll take it as a compliment.; ५/४/१२, ९:३१ AM
edutcher म्हणाले...: ही टिप्पणी लेखकाना हलविली आहे.; ५/४/१२, ९:५४ AM
edutcher म्हणाले...: The guy suffers from delusions of adequacy.

Pay him no mind, Ann.; ५/४/१२, १०:०८ AM
rcommal म्हणाले...: Revisiting that old link reminds me that sometimes Wolcott is little more than a pisseur de copie.

Rarely is he cutting edge: more a follow-the-crowd type, he.

---

Hey, welcome back to the "email followup comments" feature! (Just noticed that last night and was so hoping I wouldn't discover it was a mere fluke this morning.) You've been missed!

/OT; ५/४/१२, १०:१४ AM
Paddy O म्हणाले...: One reason movies struggles is that the market has bifurcated between enjoyable crowd-pleasers and pseudo-intellectual highbrow artsy movies.

Television tends to have to involve the former in order to maintain the latter. It's a constraint of sorts that pushes writers to do better.

But, of course, this really one works when we compare the worst of movies with the best of television. The Lord of the Rings trilogy holds up pretty well against Game of Thrones--both dependent on books, which is what real intellectuals talk about in order to really impress people with their intellectualizing. Reminds me of something Zizek once said, ".....

zzzzzz; ५/४/१२, १०:२७ AM
Paddy O म्हणाले...: It is worth noting the top 25 shows for last week:

1 CBS NCAA BSKBL CHAMP
2 American IdolX
3 Big Bang Theory, THE
4 VOICE
5 CBS NCAA BSKBL-
6 American Idol
7 NCIS
8 Person Of Interest
9 Dancing with the Stars
10 ACM AWARDS(S)
11 DANCING W/STARS
12 NCIS: LOS ANGELES
13 SURVIVOR:ONE WORLD
14 Once Upon A Time
15 Rules of Engagement
16 TOUCH
17 Mentalist,
18 New Girl
19 Desperate Housewives
20 Family Guy
21 CASTLE
22 Two and a Half Men
23 20/20-FRI
24 Unforgettable
25 2 Broke Girls
-; ५/४/१२, १०:३२ AM
wyo sis म्हणाले...: ही टिप्पणी लेखकाना हलविली आहे.; ५/४/१२, १०:४६ AM
wyo sis म्हणाले...: I watched three if the top 25. I'm in danger of becoming one of those annoying people who say I never watch popular TV.; ५/४/१२, १०:४९ AM
edutcher म्हणाले...: I don't even know half of them.

TV was never as good once everything was in color.; ५/४/१२, ११:१४ AM
Paddy O म्हणाले...: If anyone wants to talk about New Girl or Castle, I can join in.; ५/४/१२, ११:३७ AM
ErnieG म्हणाले...: As soon as I saw the by-line, I quit reading. I will never forget the day when I was sitting through a hurricane, with huge destruction in my neighborhood, and I turned my computer to read that this son of a bitch wrote that he "roots for hurricanes."; ५/४/१२, २:१६ PM
William म्हणाले...: I watched about six or seven episodes of Lost. I thought at first that it was some kind of complicated metaphor for the blurred lines between reality, memory and fantasy. No such luck. It wasn't Prospero's island. Whoever was writing it was making it up as he went along, and the series was an elaborate metaphor for television's need to sell advertising.....I've got high hopes for Game of Thrones. It seems to mix and match Arthurian legends, Tolkien, Mongol Hordes, and Shakespeare's histories in a satisfying way. The first show this season lacked arterial bleeding and nudity, but I'm hooked.; ५/४/१२, ३:३७ PM
Darrell म्हणाले...: The first show this season lacked arterial bleeding and nudity, but I'm hooked.

You didn't watch long enough for the nudity--it's in the last couple of minutes. And the killing of the baby should have sated your other interest.; ५/४/१२, ५:०० PM