Althouse: "Please tell me you're not putting 'That's the Way I Like it' over this song!!!"

११ ऑगस्ट, २०११

"Please tell me you're not putting 'That's the Way I Like it' over this song!!!"

Did List-a-Beefy stumble at #66 in the list of the 200 best #1 songs of all time?

३१ टिप्पण्या:

Paddy O म्हणाले...: un huh; ११/८/११, १०:१३ AM
DADvocate म्हणाले...: "That's the Way I Like It" shouldn't be on the list, period. Not even if the list was the top 500.; ११/८/११, १०:१३ AM
Carol_Herman म्हणाले...: To each his own list.

And, then? In #1 would be Happy Birthday.; ११/८/११, १०:१९ AM
ndspinelli म्हणाले...: "That's the Way I Like It" should only be played in porn movies.; ११/८/११, १०:२१ AM
Original Mike म्हणाले...: ही टिप्पणी लेखकाना हलविली आहे.; ११/८/११, १०:२१ AM
Original Mike म्हणाले...: Paddy beat me to it.

My compliments, sir.; ११/८/११, १०:२२ AM
Fred4Pres म्हणाले...: Please tell me you are not putting up a post listing the greatest songs of all time!!!; ११/८/११, १०:२९ AM
madAsHell म्हणाले...: Who's posting this crap, and what have you done with Ann??; ११/८/११, १०:२९ AM
Pastafarian म्हणाले...: Commenters, my advice is: Don't bother with this link. This list isn't available in list-form, you have to click through to each page.

And all that time and effort to see the opinion of an idiot who puts "We Are the World", that godawful Rhianna earworm "Umbrella", and the Bee Gees ahead of Rod Stewart, the Rolling Stones, Bill Withers, and Simon and Garfunkel.; ११/८/११, १०:४६ AM
edutcher म्हणाले...: Please tell me you aren't seriously considering either of these songs worthy of consideration on ANY "Best of" list.; ११/८/११, १०:५७ AM
Russ म्हणाले...: The list is available in 'list' format.

http://jumbledpileofperson.typepad.com/list/

That doesn't excuse their general poor taste, though.

So many craptastic R&B/hip hop like recent tunes in the list, while ignoring quite a bit of history and songs with staying power.; ११/८/११, ११:११ AM
The Crack Emcee म्हणाले...: "Good Vibrations" is a masterpiece.

"That's the way I like it" is a good song - anyone who doesn't like it is a prude who doesn't understand Pop or Disco. It's a classic of the form.

I don't get the beef, but "Good Vibrations" wins.; ११/८/११, ११:२५ AM
Salamandyr म्हणाले...: Honestly, I've never understood the critical appreciation of the Beach Boys. Perhaps I am too young to have discovered them when they were edgy, and only encountered them as tired middle agers, struggling through a set of yesterday's hits at the local Six Flags.

They always sounded like a has-been novelty act.; ११/८/११, ११:२७ AM
अनामित म्हणाले...: If not for the fact that his URL suggests a liking for They Might Be Giants, I would have written this guy off as a philistine long ago.; ११/८/११, ११:३५ AM
Amartel म्हणाले...: I like it. KC's music. Pure pop, no pretense. Not so much the Beach Boys.; ११/८/११, ११:३६ AM
Phil 314 म्हणाले...: "Good Vibrations" good

"That's the way I like it" not so good

"200 best #1 songs of all time" ???

(PS Is the a list of the #100 best lists of the #100 best songs? Then I could judge better.); ११/८/११, ११:३९ AM
Joe म्हणाले...: Gwen Stefani is #64?

This is yet another list of songs the author (or groups of authors) like and are trying to justify. Bore me.; ११/८/११, १२:१३ PM
Wally Kalbacken म्हणाले...: Inextricably linked to that song are memories of The Stone Hearth (a/k/a "The Stone Bone") on Park Street, just south of the railroad tracks. So, no, it should not be on the list.; ११/८/११, १२:२९ PM
victoria म्हणाले...: Oh, Ann, we are the same age. I remember this song in Junior High. Ah,
the first concert I ever saw was the Beach Boys and Paul Revere and the Raiders, Sacramento Civic Auditorium, in 1965. I was 13 years old and took 2 friends. How different was it then? My parents dropped us off in front of the auditorium and said, "We'll be back in 3 hours." Wow, how times have changed. When my daughter was 13 (25 now) there is no way I would have dropped her off in front of a venue. Too many preditors.She went to Lollapalooza with her older brother and her uncle when she was 15 and, even with all those masculine men with her, the pervs still tried to pick her up.

Ah, things were so simple back then.

Vicki from Pasadena; ११/८/११, १२:४० PM
sorepaw म्हणाले...: Yawn.; ११/८/११, १:०३ PM
Shanna म्हणाले...: If not for the fact that his URL suggests a liking for They Might Be Giants, I would have written this guy off as a philistine long ago.

They Might Be Giants is making pretty entertaining kids music now.; ११/८/११, १:०५ PM
अनामित म्हणाले...: OT -

Is Drudge right now suggesting that Rick Perry is gay?; ११/८/११, १:२९ PM
Ipso Fatso म्हणाले...: Everybody will have their own favorites and bitch about who is left off. As far as I am concern any list that does not include THIS!!! is just not worth it.; ११/८/११, १:३६ PM
traditionalguy म्हणाले...: Good vibrations celebrated the free wheeling California youth culture before the Great Drugs Tsunami washed it all away by the late 60s.

For further insight, see American Graffiti.; ११/८/११, १:४७ PM
Lauderdale Vet म्हणाले...: My wife and I saw KC perform that live recently at the South Beach Food and Wine festival. The crowd really got into it. Was actually really nice.; ११/८/११, २:३३ PM
jamboree म्हणाले...: @Salamandyr

Brian Wilson. End of reason.; ११/८/११, २:३६ PM
Lucius म्हणाले...: Brian Wilson, along with Axl Rose and that dude from Boston (not the late vocalist, but the one who wrote/produced everything) is the great visionary of American popular music.; ११/८/११, २:४० PM
Triangle Man म्हणाले...: Man, nowhere to discuss the positive economic news and surging stock market. Bummer.; ११/८/११, २:४१ PM
Ann Althouse म्हणाले...: "(PS Is the a list of the #100 best lists of the #100 best songs? Then I could judge better.)"

He's using the Billboard top 100 lists going back to -- I think -- 1955. Only songs that got to #1 on those weekly lists are eligible.; ११/८/११, ४:४१ PM
Phil 314 म्हणाले...: He's using the Billboard top 100 lists going back to -- I think -- 1955. Only songs that got to #1 on those weekly lists are eligible

What's the total # of songs to choose from?; ११/८/११, ५:१९ PM
themightypuck म्हणाले...: The real shocker is Hollaback Girl above them both at 64.; ११/८/११, ५:१९ PM