१ मे, २०११

Bin Laden is dead.

They say. And I'm not a deather.

UPDATE, 10:24 CT: Why is Obama taking so long? Very lame time-filling on CNN and Fox News.

UPDATE, 10:34 CT: CNN is showing crowds of people around the White House, chanting and celebrating.

UPDATE, 10:35 CT: Obama speaks, describing what happened on September 11, 2001. "The American people came together... We reaffirmed our ties to each other.... We were united as one American family."

UPDATE, 10:38 CT: Last August, there was a new lead about Bin Laden's whereabouts. Last week, there was enough information to launch an operation, Obama says. No Americans were harmed. A "firefight" took place, and we "took possession" of Bin Laden's body.

Obama reminds us that we "are not at war with Islam." He says Bin Laden was not a Muslim, but a terrorist murderer.

UPDATE, 10:41 CT: "Justice has been done." "Let us think back to the unity that prevailed on 9/11." "Tonight we are once again reminded that America can do whatever we set our minds to... not just because of our power but because of who we are, one nation, under God, with liberty and justice for all." A fine speech.

५६३ टिप्पण्या:

563 पैकी 1 – 200   नवीन›   नवीनतम»
Anga2010 म्हणाले...

The president just wants to interrupt the Donald's program.

Hoosier Daddy म्हणाले...

I want to see the death certificate.

Sprezzatura म्हणाले...

Thank God.

Chuck66 म्हणाले...

Adolph Hitler
Yasser Arafat
OBL

All sharing a burning tar pit in Hell right now.

Chuck66 म्हणाले...

But now I won't know how CSI Miama ended.

When I was a little boy, there were news break-ins all the time. With cable news and the internet, we don't get them anymore.

chickelit म्हणाले...

I want to see the death certificate.

Long form please.

I'm Full of Soup म्हणाले...

Kudos to our military & President Obama. This is great news and the country sure could use some of that!

Ignorance is Bliss म्हणाले...

Congrats to all involved. Well, all except for the people involved on the other side. Kinda sucks to be them right now. Good.

Alex म्हणाले...

Obama is a warmongering, fascist murderer.

I'm Full of Soup म्हणाले...

And chickelit adds a LOL! It's a great night all around.

chickelit म्हणाले...

Hoosier is a "deather" :)

Alex म्हणाले...

All that matters is how this will be spun to ensure Obama's re-election.

अनामित म्हणाले...

I'm surprised Obama didn't keep Osama on ice for the '12 October surprise, tsk, tis' a pity.

Peter Hoh म्हणाले...

C'mon, just make the announcement. Stop waiting for a redraft of the speech and just get on the tube and say it.

Patrick म्हणाले...

Awesome. I assume God will judge his soul according to OBL's life's work.

Live feed: http://www.whitehouse.gov/live

Almost Ali म्हणाले...

If true (bin Laden dead), isn't announcing tomorrow soon enough?

Another sign Obama is coming unglued. Or, running for president.

David म्हणाले...

CNN treating this as the equivalent of Pearl Harbor, VE Day and VJ Day.

Somehow it does not seem like a huge event to me.

Events have passed Bin Laden, he is getting his final 15 minutes, but he was already yesterday's news.

David म्हणाले...

Delay.

Teleprompter problems.

Sal म्हणाले...

All that matters is how this will be spun to ensure Obama's re-election.

Obama gets a bump in the polls, but he and Biden overplay it to an eyerolling level and it becomes a net negative.

The rule of Lemnity म्हणाले...

If you ask me.. Obama has failed to get his man Gaddafi even while knowing where he is.. while Bush has come back from the dead to get his man Osama.

OMG.... did Obama attack Gaddafi on the verge of the Osama announcement in oder to avert the political spin I have just given?

chickelit म्हणाले...

Teleprompter problems

Irony much?

BEK477 म्हणाले...

I hope this isn't another Tora Bora fiasco where Obama ends up interviewing with Larry King or Regis and Kelly.

I want his body or body parts. How when where and Who. Was this a tageted hit or a road accident Did the ISI serve him on a plate or did we find him ourselves

How many days weeks and years went bye before Obama gave the ok to whack this guy?


Its amazing how whenever Obama gets into political trouble he finds a 'fall guy' to take the heat for him?

Phand silver is down to 43.00 per oz. I guess Ben, Time and Jim want to send a message to the PM traders about commodities trading.

Sprezzatura म्हणाले...

Lem w/ the deja vu.

Peano म्हणाले...

So many cockroaches, so little time.

Sal म्हणाले...

CNN treating this as the equivalent of Pearl Harbor, VE Day and VJ Day.

CNN is taking a break from the birther issue?

shiloh म्हणाले...

So let the record show:

Osama bin Laden was killed on Barack Hussein Obama's watch, not when ...

cheney/bush were at the helm ...

Quoting Bush43 ~ I am truly not that concerned about him.

Bush Quotes about Bin Laden

November 13, 2002

For your amusement and future reference, here's what Bush has said about bin Laden at various points in time, depending on how he was trying to spin things:

"The most important thing is for us to find Osama bin Laden. It is our number one priority and we will not rest until we find him."
~ G.W. Bush, 9/13/01

"I want justice...There's an old poster out West, as I recall, that said, 'Wanted: Dead or Alive,'" ~ G.W. Bush, 9/17/01, UPI

"...Secondly, he is not escaping us. This is a guy, who, three months ago, was in control of a county [sic]. Now he's maybe in control of a cave. He's on the run. Listen, a while ago I said to the American people, our objective is more than bin Laden. But one of the things for certain is we're going to get him running and keep him running, and bring him to justice. And that's what's happening. He's on the run, if he's running at all. So we don't know whether he's in cave with the door shut, or a cave with the door open -- we just don't know...." ~ Bush, in remarks in a Press Availability with the Press Travel Pool, The Prairie Chapel Ranch, Crawford TX, 12/28/01, as reported on official White House site

"I don't know where bin Laden is. I have no idea and really don't care. It's not that important. It's not our priority." ~ G.W. Bush, 3/13/02

"I am truly not that concerned about him." ~ G.W. Bush, responding to a question about bin Laden's whereabouts, 3/13/02 (The New American, 4/8/02)

~~~~~


'nuf said!

The rule of Lemnity म्हणाले...

Lem w/ the deja vu.

This is a big fucking deal!

cahlmeeishmael म्हणाले...

Ding dong! Bin Laden's dead!
Which old Laden? The Bin Laden!
Ding dong, old Bin Laden's dead!

Christopher म्हणाले...

Our military deserves the highest praise for this.


That said I'm curious as to how quickly the talking heads opposed to action in Afghanistan forget their previous opposition.

Methadras म्हणाले...

May he rot in hell. Best decision Urkel has made since becoming president.

Alex म्हणाले...

hey shiloh - did Bush ever get a scenario when all he had to do was approve of a drone strike on OBL and refused to do so? Probably he had already given a standing order to do so without getting his confirm. WHat priority did Obama put on OBL anyways? Did he put boots on the ground in Pakistan to root him out? Nope.

Fred4Pres म्हणाले...

If true, Humdu'allah!

Methadras म्हणाले...

Actually, Bin Laden can't be dead until Titus shits on him. Then it's official.

Synova म्हणाले...

This isn't supposed to be recent or something is it?

I've been convinced that Osama has been dead for years, probably a good 12 months previous to the last time we got a supposed voice recording of him.

Now, I figure that it's probably been long enough that he won't be elevated to a martyr and a symbol, which I figure is why Bush never announced that we got him or at least that he died in his sleep of kidney failure.

Sprezzatura म्हणाले...

"That said I'm curious as to how quickly the talking heads opposed to action in Afghanistan forget their previous opposition."

My guess is that this will make more folks tire of continuing the Afghanistan war.

Methadras म्हणाले...

I wonder if Jeremy is already coining the term Deathbaggers by now? I also wonder if AlphaLiar is hacking out a screed about pro-muslim oppression of freedom fighters abroad.

chickelit म्हणाले...

Well bjAndp, so much for unity. Shilho is here.

Time for a cocktail: "A Flying Dutchman"

The rule of Lemnity म्हणाले...

Osama bin Laden was killed on Barack Hussein Obama's watch

Thank you for calling 911.. let the professionals handle it from here.

We will make sure to call you as an eyewitness.

Hoosier Daddy म्हणाले...

I guess a trial is out of the question then.

edutcher म्हणाले...

Agree with David.

Justice done, to be sure. Politically, not that high up on the radar.

Five years ago, before Al Qaeda had been gutted and discredited in Iraq, yes, it would have been a big deal.

Now, I don't think as much. If the trolls think there'll be a bounce from this, my guess is it will be the dead cat variety. Zawahiri had been speaking for the group, when it spoke at all, and bin Laden had been out of the picture. For all we know, he may have been helpless as Jim Bowie supposedly was at the Alamo, given he had kidney failure and other ailments.

Interesting this comes right after the birth cert.

Almost Ali म्हणाले...

Did the ISI serve him on a plate

That, or something very similar.

For one, the Paki's have been under tremendous domestic/internal pressure to stop the drone attacks.

Chuck66 म्हणाले...

Scott Walker elected governor of Wisconsin. OBL killed.

Co-incidence? Hmmmm.

TWM म्हणाले...

Congratulations to our Armed Forces and our intelligence community!!!

They can run and hide but not forever.

BTW, fuck the politics of it for at least a few days - this is huge - just sit back and celebrate the death of the most infamous Islamic terrorist. With beer, naked hookers, and pull-pork BBQ.

Sal म्हणाले...

Obama is going to speak to the nation about it as soon as he cleans his golf cleats.

Methadras म्हणाले...

Clearly Robert Cook is weeping crocodile tears at this news and cursing the name of Obama.

Sprezzatura म्हणाले...

"Time for a cocktail:"

Ha.

I got a nice bottle of scotch eight minutes ago.

अनामित म्हणाले...

I question the timing

Methadras म्हणाले...

Time for Al-Zawahiri next.

Christopher म्हणाले...

And Shiloh arrives right on time to prove just how big of a partisan douche he is.

pdug म्हणाले...

Give that predator drone $25 million!

Alex म्हणाले...

Forget about the politics for a moment? Sure if you're an idiot Republican who thinks Obama is going to give Bush any credit for this.

shiloh म्हणाले...

Too funny as Alex is still apologizing for cheney/bush!

Again, all I ask for is AA conservative consistency! :-P

Simon म्हणाले...

@Hoosier Daddy: Pope Stephen VI exhumed the corpse of Pope Formosus and tried "him"!

Synova म्हणाले...

"Osama bin Laden was killed on Barack Hussein Obama's watch, not when ..."

No details? When and where? I'm interested and if you have the info, Shiloh, I want the link.

Not that this will change the fact that Bush was right, absolutely right, to present Osama as unimportant. It made him unimportant and stole his power and potential power as a symbol.

I understand that in a world where nothing is related to anything else and it seems a good thing that Obama makes his decisions case-to-case, that Osama existed in abject isolation as a cause and nothing anyone says will change the opinion of some that Bush should have been railing against him with firey rhetoric, raising him up as the mother of all evil and the most important person in the whole wide world.

Hey, Obama does it all the time, every time he tries to be clever and elevates Rush, or Beck, or Palin, or Trump.

No doubt he'd have done so with Osama and proved that he was a powerful foe indeed.

Simon म्हणाले...

Apparently they cut into "The Apprentice" to announce: Osama: You're fired.

Christopher म्हणाले...

PBandJ,

Potentially, but the need to play politics with this is going to cause a great many people to suddenly become hawks for the next week or two.

Patrick म्हणाले...

As I understand it, when the army captured Hussein, Hussein said "I am SADDAM HUSSEIN!" like it was supposed to mean something. One of the soldiers quickly replied "George Bush sends his regards."

Here's hoping something similarly humiliating occurred right before the bastard met his maker.

WV Compli. Just awesome

अनामित म्हणाले...

NYT:

One of the officials said that American forces, acting on intelligence, launched a “targeted assault” that killed Mr. Bin Laden, whose ability to elude capture for so long deeply frustrated the Bush administration.

It "deeply frustrated" the Bush administration. But not, apparently, the Obama administration, who simply got done the job that the Bush people could not.

Alex म्हणाले...

shiloh - you failed to show a causal chain of OBL not being killed under the Bush/Cheney watch to some irrelevant public statements. You do realize that behind the scenes other things happen right? How many Al Queada goons did Bush kill? Lost count...

Christy म्हणाले...

NBC is framing this as the whatever anniversary of "Mission Accomplished!" Still finding ways to kick GWB.

They will have to go very very far to convince me this is recent. Guess that makes me a deather.

Peter Hoh म्हणाले...

Obama, August 1, 2007: "If we have actionable intelligence about high-value terrorist targets and President Musharraf won't act, we will."

Link.

Alex म्हणाले...

It "deeply frustrated" the Bush administration. But not, apparently, the Obama administration, who simply got done the job that the Bush people could not.

No, Pakistan was covering for OBL all these years. But since they are under pressure to stop the US drone attacks, they finally relented and gave up his position. But of course Obama gets the credit for doing.... what exactly? Oh yeah, just being around... Playing golf.

Crimso म्हणाले...

Rumor that it was up close and personal (shot) in a mansion near Islamabad.

Almost Ali म्हणाले...

Too bad FOX viewers are forced to watch cable TV's emotional basket case; Geraldo Rivera.

Meanwhile, Wolf Blitzer can hardly breathe.

While Andrea Mitchell is barely recognizable...

TWM म्हणाले...

"Forget about the politics for a moment? Sure if you're an idiot Republican who thinks Obama is going to give Bush any credit for this."

The only credit here is to the Armed Forces and intelligence types. Past that I don't give a shit who takes it politically because it is fleeting - it ain't gonna help Obama for more than a day or so and Bush is secure enough to not give shit.

It's party-time - enjoy the moment!

Hoosier Daddy म्हणाले...

It "deeply frustrated" the Bush administration. But not, apparently, the Obama administration, who simply got done the job that the Bush people could not.

lol

You're such a twat.

Crimso म्हणाले...

"It "deeply frustrated" the Bush administration. But not, apparently, the Obama administration, who simply got done the job that the Bush people could not."

And let the record show that Truman defeated Japan and not FDR.

Christopher म्हणाले...

Why do I get the feeling that Shiloh is the type of person who would negotiate with hostage takers?

LakeLevel म्हणाले...

Now let's drop the body into a volcano or maybe put him into a plasma toxic waste destroyer and reduce him to his component elements, or bury him in the middle of a mine field.

Peter Hoh म्हणाले...

FWIW, I will be disappointed in Obama if he doesn't give Bush some sort of credit. Of course, this might be why he and his speechwriters are having trouble finalizing the speech.

I'm Full of Soup म्हणाले...

The news said it happened 7 days ago and they were verifying his DNA.

Sprezzatura म्हणाले...

"It's party-time - enjoy the moment!"

Hell yes!

Now I'm a confessed troll, but even I think it'd be nice if a handful of folks could stop getting this thread off the party track.

Almost Ali म्हणाले...

Like I said, they shoulda waited till the morning.

Hoosier Daddy म्हणाले...

And let the record show that Truman defeated Japan and not FDR.

The Germans too.

David म्हणाले...

Obama an hour late for his big moment.

CNN broadcasting drunken college students singing the National Anthem.

They can not get a teleprompter to work on demand.

How will they run the high speed choo-choos.

Obama an hour late for his beg moment.

(Refrain)

Alex म्हणाले...

pbJ - if Obama wants to defuse this from being a pure partisan hackery, then he should strongly praise Bush for setting up the framework. Otherwise, pure partisan hack.

Sal म्हणाले...

Now let's drop the body into a volcano or maybe put him into a plasma toxic waste destroyer and reduce him to his component elements, or bury him in the middle of a mine field.

I've always thought these guys should be buried in an Alabama hog farm.

Synova म्हणाले...

"You do realize that behind the scenes other things happen right?"

Wow, Alex, that's a stupid question to ask Shiloh.

Chip S. म्हणाले...

To celebrate, the TSA is giving everyone a free crotch-caress tomorrow.

I'm Full of Soup म्हणाले...

Teleprompter is in a union and gets paid triple time for weekend work.

Irene म्हणाले...

Osama Bin Laden was only fifty-four years old?

Synova म्हणाले...

"The news said it happened 7 days ago and they were verifying his DNA."

To clone him! Bwa ha ha ha!

(Seriously, they have DNA to verify a match?)

(Oh, and... 7 days isn't long enough to write a speech?)

David म्हणाले...

Crimso said...
Rumor that it was up close and personal (shot) in a mansion near Islamabad.


You gotta hope that is true.

"Hi, Osama. Man, you ARE tall."

(Raises sights.)

Blam!

Christopher म्हणाले...

Given the conflicting reports (e.g. missile strike vs. special ops/afghanistan vs. pakistan) we may want to hold off on the party just yet.

That said I'm still going to grab a nice cold beer.

Ignorance is Bliss म्हणाले...

I wonder if we got any actionable intel from either the site or any of its occupants.

Might be time to break out the waterboard again.

Peter Hoh म्हणाले...

What the hell, blogger ate another comment.

Obama, August 1, 2007: "If we have actionable intelligence about high-value terrorist targets and President Musharraf won't act, we will," Obama said.

Irene म्हणाले...

The White House delayed so as not to interfere with the Royal Wedding. Diplomacy at work.

shiloh म्हणाले...

hmm, did I rain on Althouse's 24/7 partisan winger parade lol.

Quite a week for AA's flock! :D

take care, blessings

WineSlob म्हणाले...

Osama Got a Shot in the Head
Obama Got a Shot in the Arm
Me, I’ll Just Take a Shot of Whiskey
Singin' Ding Dong the Witch is Dead

Christopher म्हणाले...

Also it seems more likely that this may have been a play by the ISI to try and get the US to back off the drone strikes (which would go to PBandJ's point)

shiloh म्हणाले...

What the hell, blogger ate another comment.

copy/paste is your best friend just before you hit preview/publish ...

David म्हणाले...

Blitzer: "Obama was supposed to address the nation an hour ago."

Ha!

(Again) "It's almost an hour . . . "

Must be "fine tuning" the speech.

(For a week???!!!)

John King sounds like he's drunk. Slurring words slightly. More than slightly.

I'm Full of Soup म्हणाले...

Did the White House have 7 days to prepare for this news announcement?

अनामित म्हणाले...

This is great news. Great job USA.

अनामित म्हणाले...

"I guess a trial is out of the question then."

This just in Attorney General Eric Holder is demanding to try the Osama Bin Laden body or parts thereof.

Patrick म्हणाले...

I've been looking for a reason to go out and buy a nice bottle of scotch. I believe I need wait no more.

अनामित म्हणाले...

copy/paste is your best friend just before you hit preview/publish

I always do this for any intensive post I write.

David म्हणाले...

Hey, good for Obama. Glad the job is done.

Blitzer: "The President getting ready."

(Shot of lecturn and empty hallway.)

Alex म्हणाले...

shiloh has best explain why he gives Bush no credit for this. Is he that big of a moron not to realize who put the military framework together? I guess he thinks Truman won WW2.

Sprezzatura म्हणाले...

"Did the White House have 7 days to prepare for this news announcement?"

The news folks were saying that the Hill didn't know about this before the announcement that BHO would be speaking (hence no leaks for a week). So, I'd guess that the WH is calling all the prima donas on the Hill before speaking to the nation.

Simon म्हणाले...

May 1 2011: The day the Vatican announced John Paul II was in heaven and the White House announced Osama bin Laden was in hell.

David म्हणाले...

Obama is stealing his own thunder.

Hard to do but he's pulling it off.

(More drunk students on CNN.)

Sabinal म्हणाले...

my side (libs) might be insufferable for a while, but if the economy continues to sputter out, no one will care. It's like the Reaganites who boast about how Reagan singlehandedly stopped the USSR; people knew better than that.

The best thing to do is to see what happens during the week. It will amplify the "bush took his eye off the ball" but O balanced that with our involvement in Libya (plus all O did was continue what W did,he was given a free pass from criticism from a sycophantic press wanting the first black president to be a savior.)

He is also still an arrogant %%%% and if the fiscal situation does not improve it will be no better than last week. But in a sense I would love for O to get a 2nd term. He should be held completely responsible for the 50% rise in the deficit and the results.

Big Mike म्हणाले...

Julius, taking his cue from the Times, seems to be suggesting that the Obama administration has demonstrated significant competence when contrasted with the predecessor administration.

If true, this would be the first instance of that in two years.

अनामित म्हणाले...

I guess we'll have to wait for President Jeb Bush to get Gaddafi.

Unknown म्हणाले...

I heard neighbors behind me cheer when the news came up.

Thank you, US military. We sure needed this.

David म्हणाले...

Blitzer: "It's now past 11:30."

EnigmatiCore म्हणाले...

you just go and lay your hands on a Pittsburgh Steelers fan, and I think you're going to finally understand...

Obama, good job.

Mick म्हणाले...

Major diversion from news of Obama's stolen SSN tomorrow, and naybe more...

Simon Kenton म्हणाले...

I suppose it is too much to hope for that the corpse will be annointed with pig fat before burial?

Sabinal म्हणाले...

And let the record show that Truman defeated Japan and not FDR.

good one, Crimso...exactly

अनामित म्हणाले...

1 minute...

Irene म्हणाले...

Osama was killed on Easter Sunday?

Peter Hoh म्हणाले...

Now

David म्हणाले...

Live drunk college students on CNN! "Wolf, it's so dramatic."

Secret Service on the job.

Students: "The best day ever in American history.")

Bush had a plan on what to do if Obama killed.

(Obama, it seems, did not.)

Palladian म्हणाले...

Who cares whose "watch" it happened under? It happened, thank God.

Synova म्हणाले...

No, you didn't rain on a parade, Shiloh.

Just because you said something stupid about Bush and you get called on it, doesn't mean you really said something brilliant and relevant about Bush but people are knee-jerking defense.

Alex asked you a stupid question.

It's a question we all know the answer to.

shiloh म्हणाले...

OK, let's get this thread over (1,000) posts post-haste! :D

I yield back the balance of my time ...

अनामित म्हणाले...

Wait! This is huge, Mick. You mean the birthers haven't given up? With every new fact, the conspiracy just gets deeper, huh?

Also, non-birther related, I doubt that Obama cares about Trump here. He wants this to dominate the week's news cycle. This is the opposite of releasing news on Friday. However, if Obama even thought about Trump here, sad. Trump is not going to be a factor in the Republican nomination battle.

Palladian म्हणाले...

I wonder if there were a few sullen losers standing around, acting like douche-bags when the news broke that Hitler was dead?

TWM म्हणाले...

This is the first time I have ever watched Barry talk when it didn't make me sick to my stomach.

Peter Hoh म्हणाले...

C'mon, give Bush some credit already.

अनामित म्हणाले...

Hitler's not dead. Ask Mick.

अनामित म्हणाले...

I'm here to announce that Osama Bin Laden has been killed.

It was a dark and stormy night.....


Fire the speech writer.

The rule of Lemnity म्हणाले...

I called my mother and she tells me that the al qaeda's #2 at Guantanamo said that if and when Osama was killed that they would attack the US with a WMD.

I'm listening to Obama and he sounds like hes giving a political speech.

Palladian म्हणाले...

"C'mon, give Bush some credit already."

LOL. Keep dreaming, Peter! To Obama, this is yet another "I won" moment.

shiloh म्हणाले...

So many AA conservative deflections/red herrings, non sequiturs ~ so little time ...

अनामित म्हणाले...

I have not watched a presidential speech since Clinton, with the exception of Bush at the World Trade Center ruins. I sure won't start now. You people please be accurate.

Mark म्हणाले...

Shiloh: "Bush/Cheney pursuit of bin Laden bad bad bad!"

Shiloh: "Obama got bin Laden! Eat it, Rethugs!"

The ultimate team player.

अनामित म्हणाले...
ही टिप्पणी लेखकाना हलविली आहे.
Peter Hoh म्हणाले...

At least mention that you personally called GWB.

Sprezzatura म्हणाले...

"C'mon, give Bush some credit already."

Bush said he didn't matter.

BHO told the CIA he was the most important goal.

अनामित म्हणाले...

They didn't read him his rights first?

Patrick म्हणाले...

"At my direction."
"I ordered.."
"My administration.."

ME ME ME

shiloh म्हणाले...

Repeating:

Bush43 ~ "I am truly not that concerned about him."

carry on

The rule of Lemnity म्हणाले...

Yes.. he said .. just as president Bush.

अनामित म्हणाले...

The important thing for Shiloh is that everything make Obama and Democrats look good and everything make Republicans and Bush (still) look bad. It's not about right and wrong with these people.

अनामित म्हणाले...

BHO told the CIA he was the most important goal.


That's why the CIA didn't know anything about the Arab Spring.

अनामित म्हणाले...

Shiloh will still be talking about George W. Bush in 2020. I say yes and I am taking bets now.

Palladian म्हणाले...

"Bush said he didn't matter.

BHO told the CIA he was the most important goal."

Accurate on both counts. For Bush, Osama's death didn't really matter because after a time it really didn't matter in a strategic sense.

For Obama, it was the most important goal, because it's all optics and politics with Obama.

David म्हणाले...

"Worst attack on the American people in our history."

????????????

Pearl Fucking Harbor?

Pathos.

Why pathos? "A gaping hole in our hearts."

Trite.

United. We were United!

Vicious attack!

Now, a little history lesson. "War" against AQ. ("War?")

Pak-kiss-stan. )

He "directed" making killing Osama the top priority.

(This was new?)

The killing was today--done by American boots on the ground. "Took custody" of his body.

Now at war with Islam--neither was "Bush."

Obama said "Bush!"

Pakis helped us find Osama.

But our troops did the killing.

Man, these troops had a hell of a mission.

The rule of Lemnity म्हणाले...

I got that swelled up my spine.. despite the messenger.

TWM म्हणाले...

American forces attacked on the ground and killed the fucker dead - with no American casualties.

Sweet.

Also, it's better to have done it this way than to kill him with a Predator. Up-close and personal.

Christy म्हणाले...

Leon Panetta succeeded in the mission BHO gave him. Is this why he got Defense last week?

अनामित म्हणाले...

Is tonight the night that Peter Hoh finally just admits that he's a moderate Republican?

Peter Hoh म्हणाले...

Shiloh is a troll, and I hardly feel his remarks worthy of mention, but if I failed to recognize it then, I have since come to believe that Bush did the right thing by minimizing bin Laden's importance.

Sprezzatura म्हणाले...

Seven,

I have no idea how you maintain the stamina keep fighting the birther battle.

Palladian म्हणाले...

"Shiloh will still be talking about George W. Bush in 2020."

Does anyone read "Shiloh's" comments now? I sure don't. I can't imagine anything changing that by 2020.

Sal म्हणाले...

You would never have heard a speech like this from Obama <= 2008.

Peter Hoh म्हणाले...

Well done, Mr. President.

Martin L. Shoemaker म्हणाले...

Be fair, Alex. If this is correct...

No, Pakistan was covering for OBL all these years. But since they are under pressure to stop the US drone attacks, they finally relented and gave up his position.

...then this is answered...

But of course Obama gets the credit for doing.... what exactly?

If there is one concrete difference in President Obama's Afghanistan tactics, it's an increase in drone attacks, especially inside Afghanistan. If the drone attacks truly led the Pakistanis to give up Bin Laden, then I think President Obama actually deserves some credit here.

I don't know if the premise is true or not. I think President Obama will get the credit simply because that's generally the way it works: the guy on watch at the time of the event gets the credit (or the blame). Partisans may try to shift the timeframe to their advantage; but the general public will credit this to President Obama.

Peter Hoh म्हणाले...

And well done, U.S. military.

The rule of Lemnity म्हणाले...

In a way he seems to be reaching out beyond politics..

As president.

I loved it!

अनामित म्हणाले...

The important thing for Shiloh is for somebody.... ANYBODY to pay some little bit of attention to him.

blessings, take care

Synova म्हणाले...

"Repeating:"

Yeah, what Alex said.

You aren't a stupid person, Shiloh. I know you're not. But you would rather Bush had puffed Osama up as a symbol. What you feel is so cutting, so wonderful, so harsh that it must be repeated proves nothing at all about the effort Bush directed toward the search for Osama and you know it. Because you're not stupid.

Ignorance is Bliss म्हणाले...

...and justice for all

Including, tonight, Osama Bin Laden

अनामित म्हणाले...

Agree with Palladian 1000% as usual (except gay marriage).

What's changed? Tomorrow, you'll still pay out the ass for gasoline. The economy is a wreck. If anything, the world is more dangerous given the perception by terrorist thug fuck sticks that a reprisal is in order.

This is great and all. Way to go. Woo hoo. Good job. But it's a ribbon-cutting ceremony and nothing more.

Sprezzatura म्हणाले...

Palladian,

Please.

Bush was obsessed w/ Iraq. End of story.

Not exactly the right call.

P.S.
What are you drinking?

अनामित म्हणाले...

Obama is coming off as egotistical and cold. He mentions himself way too much. And he signs letters to the families of dead servicemen-- oh, the strain on his hand!

All this harking back to 9/11 and "unity" is really annoying. It represents America as weak and pathetic. He should have been strongly issuing a warning to other would-be terrorists that this is what will happen to them too. Hang bin-Laden's head on the rostra like they did in the old days.

Did he just end with the fucking Pledge of Allegiance? Oy vey!

अनामित म्हणाले...

Habeamus corpus.

Original Mike म्हणाले...

Good. Fucking. Riddance.

I hope he tried to surrender before they shot him.

Palladian म्हणाले...

" Shiloh is a troll, and I hardly feel his remarks worthy of mention, but if I failed to recognize it then, I have since come to believe that Bush did the right thing by minimizing bin Laden's importance."

Bush made a lot of mistakes in the prosecution of the "War on Terror". His early understanding that killing OBL wasn't the most important goal was not one of those mistakes.

The rule of Lemnity म्हणाले...

Obama called Bush.. decency?

I say yes!

Christopher म्हणाले...

pbAndj,

Come on you were doing so well with the non-partisan talk.

Claiming that Bush didn't consider Osama important is retarded and you know it. The fact of the matter is that he had to say that so as to not make Bin Laden into some sort of icon constantly thumbing his nose at the mighty US (think Che).

If you treat him as some sort of replaceable cog the fact that he's out there is not a propaganda tool for the enemy. On the other hand if you make him into the primary focus of the war then every moment he lives is PR victory.

The best analogy I can use is a prison warden. It is common practice in prison to not recognize any gang lest you give them a form of legitimacy. That doesn't mean they don't exist and that prison officials are not concerned, it just means that they are trying to prevent them from growing in popularity.

Automatic_Wing म्हणाले...

The most relieved man on the planet - Eric Holder.

Simon म्हणाले...

I thought it was a great speech by Obama. The only thing I'd add:

"I'd also like to speak directly to those who would like to emulate bin Laden, who have designs to attack this country. The lesson you should learn today is this: It doesn't matter how long it takes, or how far you run. We will hunt you. We will find you. And we will kill you."

Palladian म्हणाले...

"P.S. What are you drinking?"

Bombay Dry Gin on the rocks.

AlphaLiberal म्हणाले...

It's a great day and a great accomplishment. Good job to the troops. Good job, Mr President.

Now that is a Mission Accomplished.

अनामित म्हणाले...

Taking credit for an obvious decision that any man or woman in the office would have taken.

But if killing OBL was top priority, then I expect that all the Islamic violence against us will stop now, right?

Otherwise why was he so important?

The rule of Lemnity म्हणाले...

If I had to vote tonight.. my republican brethrens would be in trouble.

अनामित म्हणाले...

It was repealing DADT that did it. Yessiree!

Tibore म्हणाले...

Yes. The got the fucker.

The only thing I'm sorry about is that it was probably a clean death in a gunfight. I would've been more glad to see the bastard stuck in a fire-laden skyscraper and forced to ride it down when it collapsed.

Sprezzatura म्हणाले...

That this thread is anything but celebratory says something about us (including me).

And, it isn't good.

The blather can go on tomorrow.

David म्हणाले...

Good speech at the end.

Pathetic crap at the beginning.

They killed him today.

God bless the troops, making the world safe for drunken college students to chant USA at the White House.

Nice job, Obama.

Bush: "no matter how long it takes . . . "

Sal म्हणाले...

Bush was obsessed w/ Iraq. End of story.

Bush fucked this up. No doubt about it.

Unknown म्हणाले...

I'm thrilled that he's dead and that Obama said we are one nation "under God". All of a sudden we can say that again without offending anyone?

Harry Phartz म्हणाले...

Righteous kill!

The rule of Lemnity म्हणाले...

Tonight.. I'm a AlphaLiberal.

Palladian म्हणाले...

"Good job, Mr President."

Of course a sorry-ass douchebag like you would take this opportunity to kiss a politician's ass.

The thanks belong to those who completed the mission, and it wasn't the fucking Chief Executive, no matter who that fucking Chief Executive happens to be.

अनामित म्हणाले...

Well, people, ask yourselves: was Bush right? Did Bin Laden matter? After we attacked Afghanistan and Iraq and got serious about terrorist finance, and fascist about airport security?

Because he's dead now. When you wake up tomorrow, what will be different?

Not one goddamn thing. So did Bin Laden matter?

अनामित म्हणाले...

So right now I imagine OBL is having a hell of a time picking which virgin he wants.

And all we get is a a lousy speech from BHO.

The world is unfair.

I'm Full of Soup म्हणाले...

Like TWM said,let's put aside politics for a few days. Maybe put your flag out tomorrow!

Freeman Hunt म्हणाले...

You skipped the part where he talked about how Obama Columbo cracked the case.

Alex म्हणाले...

Obama made it clear from day 1 that he was in constant campaign mode. Why should I give him a break?

अनामित म्हणाले...

Obama organized the hell out of UBL's community.

Peter Hoh म्हणाले...

Simon, I think that point is understood by those who would emulate bin Laden.

And I agree with TWM that this is better because it was not done with a drone.

kimsch म्हणाले...

So called "Mission Accomplished" speech: May 1, 2003

wv: baling - osama is furiously baling out the ferry across the River Styx, but he will sink

David म्हणाले...

A hell of a military operation.

Beware, ye leaders of Iran,

We can find you if we want to.

Perhaps we could send this group to bring out the body of Daffy.

shiloh म्हणाले...

"Shiloh will still be talking about George W. Bush in 2020."

Again, oh the irony, as conservatives will be deflecting w/but, but, but Carter/Clinton beyond eternity lol.

Heck, if they were dead, AA's flock would try to dig them up ..

अनामित म्हणाले...

Osama bin Laden Dead

gas will still be expensive tomorrow
your house will still be worth less
millions of americans will not suddenly find a job tomorrow

TWM म्हणाले...

"That this thread is anything but celebratory says something about us (including me)."

Not me, I'm having a drink and just shot off a few left-over bottle rockets from my front porch. Why the rest of you aren't doing back-flips is beyond me.

Palladian म्हणाले...

"I'm thrilled that he's dead and that Obama said we are one nation "under God". All of a sudden we can say that again without offending anyone?"

It's just politics. I'm sick to fucking death of politics. I never listen to politicians blather. The only thing I needed to hear was that Osama is room-fucking-temperature. Thanks to the military who carried it out and the intelligence who made it possible. Everybody else can fuck off.

Palladian म्हणाले...

I hope they show the body.

Alex म्हणाले...

Why the rest of you aren't doing back-flips is beyond me.

Excuse me if I'm not overly enthused by something that bumps Obama's poll # by 8 points.

अनामित म्हणाले...

I loved Bill Clinton and still do. As for Carter, people didn't talk much about him ever until they started seeing eerie parallels between Obama and Carter.

Do you see eerie parallels between Obama and Bush, Shiloh? Because Althouse has an Obama is like Bush tag. So welcome to the club.

The rule of Lemnity म्हणाले...

Palla I know what you mean and I love you.. but this should be beyond politics..

This is a victory for the nation as a whole.

Palladian म्हणाले...

Oh Alex, do fuck off.

Palladian म्हणाले...

I hope Michelle is proud of her country, tonight.

shiloh म्हणाले...

Conservatives again I beseech you ~ stop whining! :-P

Alex म्हणाले...

Also explain me the strategic relevance of killing OBL in 2011. Yeah you can't. It's a political win for Obama and not much else.

«सर्वात जुने ‹थोडे जुने   563 पैकी 1 – 200   नवीन› नवीनतम»