"But it’s awfully hard for me to stay in love with someone when I only see them every three months and when the only contact I have with them is through letters."
An interesting, early — 1947 — use of "them" for "him," from Jacqueline Lee Bouvier, writing, when she was 16, to a beau who was not JFK.
८ एप्रिल, २०११
याची सदस्यत्व घ्या:
टिप्पणी पोस्ट करा (Atom)
पोस्ट्स
१८ टिप्पण्या:
Wow. Who knew that Jackie O was the inspiration for "Love the One You're With"?
Jackie was self expressive and ready for adventure at 16. She found her match in JFK.
The use of the singular "they/them" is a major point of contention between the English and Linguistics departments of most universities.
Not very early. The Wikipedia article on this suggests that this usage goes back at least to the 1300's.
Rather than gender, in this context, perhaps she was subtly communicating that "he" was still only one of "them" in a group of suitors she had to choose from.
I was never very impressed with Jackie.
Now I know why.
Sixty Grit said...
Camelot will never die, will it?
It drowned at Chappaquiddick (sp?).
So whatever happened to Mr. Corbin?
So whatever happened to Mr. Corbin?
He's coaching the Utah Jazz.
use of "them" for "him,"
Not necessarily. She might have wanted to leave the door open for a ménage à trois.
Use of they or them instead of he, especially prior to the lack of recognition of the universal, neutral "he" or "him", was often used by people who were trying to cast a veil of vagueness out of fear of being direct--even though the sentence was fairly direct. Sort of like saying, "You don't do it for me. Nothing personal"
I knew young women who reverted to "they" when trying to figure out how to avoid the confrontational tone the more direct "he" would put into the tone of what they said.
She was trying to hide from the directness of substituting "you" for "someone" and "them".
"I do think I’m in love with you when I’m with you."
"But it’s awfully hard for me to stay in love with someone when I only see them every three months and when the only contact I have with them is through letters."
Because, she continued, words such as "love" or "loyalty" or "devotion" are but wisps in the wind,...when you're shallow.
She got the man she deserved, if you ask me. One who also found it difficult to be faithful as long as she wasn't around.
Jesus, people give me the creeps.
Girls just wanna have fun.
I thought her humor cute for a 16-17 year old.
"Him" would have been grammatically correct, but "you" would have worked as well.
I suspect that Jackie wanted to avoid the directness of using "you."
Using "him," however, might have seemed (to her ear) to imply that she was writing about some other guy.
Jackie would not have made a good war bride.
"I thought her humor cute for a 16-17 year old."
It's criticism.
Siamese twins?
टिप्पणी पोस्ट करा