“I am surprised because I hadn’t imagined how guilty nonreaders feel,” [Pierre] Bayard, 52, said in an interview. “With this book, they can shake off their guilt without psychoanalysis, so it’s much cheaper.”How bloggerly!
Mr. Bayard reassures them that there is no obligation to read, and confesses to lecturing students on books that he has either not read or has merely skimmed. And he recalls passionate exchanges with people who also have not read the book under discussion.
He further cites writers like Montaigne, who could not remember what he read, and Paul Valéry, who found ways of praising authors whose books he had never opened. Mr. Bayard finds characters in novels by Graham Greene, David Lodge and others who cheerfully question the need to read at all. And he refuses to be intimidated by Proust or Joyce.
Having demonstrated that non-readers are in good company, Mr. Bayard then offers tips on how to cover up ignorance of a “must-read” book....
... Mr. Bayard’s most daring suggestion is that nonreaders should talk about themselves, using the pretext of the book without dwelling on its contents. In this way, he said, they are forced to tap their imagination and, in effect, invent their own book.
Well... hmmm... I haven't read Bayard's book, so let me say that this makes me think about devising a set of tips for teaching law school without reading the cases. (Me, I feel compelled to reread the cases I teach right before each class, so that there are some cases that I've read closely more than 40 times. Did you know that it's emphatically the province and duty of the judicial department to say what the law is?)
I know one lawprof who's proud of the time -- like, the one time -- that he got to the end of the cases he'd prepared and used the Socratic method to teach the next case, which he'd never read. It went quite well, he says.
Theoretically, it could work especially well, because your actual need to figure out what happened in the case and why it's in the book would drive your questions. But the guilt!
पोस्ट्स
१५ टिप्पण्या:
I loved an old National Lampoon story: Cliff Notes of the Cliff Notes. When you can't even read the Cliff Notes! Old Testament: "God creates man, and everything man does makes God angry!"
Someday all lit courses will just be podcasts...
If I ever meet Professor Bayard I’ll have to ask him if he ever hung around with Elvis Costello.
Now he's telling her every little thing he's done.
Once he glanced at the jackets of some paperbacks
Now he's read every one.
He's such a drag (He's such a drag).
He's not insane (He's not insane).
It's just that everybody has to feel his pain.
There's gonna be no dancing when they get home.
I hope things have turned out better for him in the relationship department.
Not reading a book is the only way to come to a truly objective opinion about it. Besides, nowadays, it's not about the book anymore. It's all about Oprah.
If anything proves folks can argue about something they've never read, or don't understand, it's the comment sections on blogs.
Notwithstanding this one, of course... :-)
Ah! I wonder if he's a cheelah of Willis Barnstone, whose contribution to the world of translation is the theory that you don't have to be able to read the language you're translating from, or even understand what you're translating -- you just put your hands over the text and feel it!
Good lord, such rampant fraud.
"How to Talk About Books You Haven’t Read."
Isn't that what the NYT Review of Books is for? :)
How to talk about books you haven't read....doh- wait that is what we are doing now.
Methinks this may be why they say life (on the blog) imitates art?
I'd rather read than discuss this topic.
; )
Ann - Commendations for your repeatedly reading the dissent of Mr. Justice Harlan in Plessey - a straightforward approach to the Constitution and racial discrimination, (both direct and reverse).
Books are obsolete. Index cards are in: Build a better graph or diagram, and the world will beat a path to your door. Jessica Hagy’s blog, Indexed: As Emerson might have said, but didn’t: "Build a better mousetrap, and you can forget about being part of the long tail."
You know how you talk about books you haven't read?
Get yourself a brainyish daughter, who is a bluestocking and consequently has a twin tower of books near her bed.
Then, just before you go off to a dinner party, you pump her for knowledge about that book everyone is reading, and then you go off to dazzle your dinner partner.
Has worked like a CHARM for years with my mother.
Cheers,
Victoria
Victoria:
What the hell is a bluestocking ? I thought you were a redcoat.
And don't tell me I have to buy your book and read it to find out.
AJ, baby, you look up the word bluestocking in the Merriam-Webster and you'll find a picture of me.
An pale archive rat bent over a book, 5 hours of every day.
At least I shave my legs.
Cheers,
Victoria
टिप्पणी पोस्ट करा