The 6-foot 3-inch Smith, tanned and muscular from hours on a John Deere tractor, has the look of a strapping farmboy, a sardonic sense of humor, and a need for more than a simply Sunday-go-to-meeting faith. Raised as a Baptist, he says he was drawn to Shaker life by the way he saw it being lived out. "The religious life was a part of our day all the time, as opposed to something that was encapsulated on Sunday morning," he says. "Your religion wasn't something you were proclaiming but, rather, it was something that you were living." Smith's family, though, initially had trouble with his decision. "My mother used to say for years, when I first came here, 'Well, don't you think you're going to go to college someday? Or get married?'" he says. "After all these years, I think she'd be surprised now if I left."
Tanned, muscular, strapping... I'll bet "mother" was not surprised.
But back to Sister June Carpenter. From the new obituary:
When Ms. Carpenter first visited the village in the summer of 1988, she was 49; a friend took her to the dedication of its new library. In college, she had been drawn to stories of people who had religious vocations, and she felt that she, too, wanted to give her life to God. When she learned that the community needed help cataloging its archive for the new library, she volunteered to help, and felt so at home that she asked to be considered for membership....
As Sister June told [the author of a book about Shakers], “I am the last and the least of the community at the moment, and I’m very happy in that position. If I get into a position where I’m head of something, like when I was head cataloger at the library where I used to work, I feel uncomfortable and insecure. But I can cope with being little and low. It helps with the humility that we are striving for.”
When she was young, she had a spiritual experience. Looking at a crowd of people — in Boston — "I could see that God was within each of them. I’ve always remembered that — that God must be inside everyone in some way, whether they realize it or not.”

३४ टिप्पण्या:
I guess it's like a Catholic religious order, but for Protestants. I suppose the Catholic ones survive for centuries because they all have ties to one organized religion, but Protestant sects, like the Shakers, are their own religion in themselves.
Making Shaker furniture -- or close approximations thereof -- is a real pleasure. Nothing too fancy, just basic functionality. IMO that will be their legacy.
Yes, the beauty and simplicity of Shaker furniture design is a lasting legacy, and it will endure. Still, though.... that whole celibacy thing. New England surely does come up with some crazy people. My grandad had a couple of first cousins that were followers of Mary Baker Eddy. They had me shaking my head before I was even 10.
The demise of the Shakers is a failure of sales and marketing.
The maxim of the Shakers is "Hands to work, hearts to God."
They should have added, "Always be closing."
Harold Bloom probably in _The American Religion_ mentioned that that set of beliefs was not calculated well to preserve the religion.
It's surprising that more aging Boomers haven't taken up Shakerism. There are a lot of singles and divorcé(e)s, and surely the flames of desire have died down by now. Maybe the remaining two or three Shakers are concerned that physical proximity might rekindle something in the newbies.
They should've made some exciting recruiting videos... dudes fast roping out of a hayloft...worm's eye views of them passing dangerously close on gnarly looking farm machines...emerging from a duck pond with a bible in their teeth.
A preferred lifestyle compared to the "ooo you're so cute" black dress sorority/vapid influencer culture.
so, let's say there were two groups..
both from out east.
one group said; "no sex! no marriage!! no kids!!!"
the other group said; "marry as many wives as you can afford!"
in a couple of hundred years, Which group will have more missonaries?
sorry, i can't type any more; there are two clean cut guys in white shirts at my door giving away books
"I could see that God was within each of them. I’ve always remembered that — that God must be inside everyone in some way, whether they realize it or not.”
A nice message for a Sunday morning.
In the UK - Muslim immigrants have 3 wives and many children with each wife, and the State welfare system pays for it all.
Ironically perhaps, Bill Cosby had a major boner for Shaker furniture. It just sits there. You don't have to slip anything in a drink.
There was a movie last year about Mother Ann Lee, the founder of Shakerism. She was played by Amanda Seyfried. Unless Seyfried's looks have drastically changed lately, it's not likely she could have founded a celibate sect. But then Hollywood always does that, didn't they?
A whole lotta shakin' goin' on - not.
As someone upthread said, 19th Century Protestant New England and Upstate new York (which had a lot of New England Pioneers) was the home of the religious crazies. Mormonism for one. Mary Baker Eddy for another. And New England was the home of Unitarianism.
Weirdly, Texas and the South is the home of Christian Zionism and hagee, having missed all the weird "isms" of the 19th century.
I've known several mormon co-workers over the years, and they were great people. Several had stay-at-home wives and 3 kids even on their single relatively low-level salaries. I don't know how they managed it. Most of us at that time were interested in bars and having fun.
They would recruit more GenX members if they would allow people who merely self-identify as celibate.
The Catholic discese (sic) in my area has shut down 2 institutes or orders in my area and sold off the land to developers. According to Grok the number of american nuns has dropped from 180 thousand in 1965 to 35 thousand in 2025. And almost all the 35 thousand are over 65.
"Harold Bloom probably in _The American Religion_ mentioned that that set of beliefs was not calculated well to preserve the religion."
It was not that long ago (late 60s and 70s) when the consensus was that we were headed for a population explosion. The opposite turned out to be true.
the Most Important Words, EVER said were:
The Future BELONGS, To Those Who SHOW UP
Unless they show up in the wrong place at the wrong time.
*eyeroll* Like the subscribers to the NYTs are doing their part to maintain the population.
I got dragged to "The Book of Mormon" last night. I have to admit that I hated it. It was mildly entertaining, but I felt like I was watching the most offensive minstrel show ever. It only really had a couple "jokes" that were repeated over and over, like "we are gay and Mormons are too" ,or Mormonism has some ridiculous history, and even they don't believe it". That was pretty much it. It was like watching mean girls pick on someone outside their clique who wasn't there to defend themselves. No mention of the good things Mormons do except to imply it never helped anyone. I'm not Mormon, and certainly know some of them have done some bad things like every group. I'm not even religious, but it just hit me as bullying, and I felt bad when people around me would laugh out loud at what seemed like egregious hatred to me. My date loved it though. The culture is walking away from me.
Shakin’ Shakin’ Shakes…
https://youtu.be/CHO5iwzM8pc
Extinction in popular, social viability... to match species extinction until "rediscovered".
Bagoh - huh. I'm not surprised. Mocking and bullying all the religions - is fine. Mormons are easy targets - because they are nice. Modern Mormonism isn't much different from most Christian denominations these days.
Just do not mock or criticize Islam.
Risk of silence, jail or death comes next.
Well, ya got the Shakers and then ya got these people:
Consider the Koreshan Unity, a utopian religious community founded by Cyrus Teed (who called himself "Koresh") and established in Estero, Florida, in the 1890s.
The group is famous for its belief in "Cellular Cosmogony," a version of the hollow-earth concept that held that humanity lives on the inside of a hollow sphere, with the sun, moon, and stars existing within that enclosed universe.
There was an early Christian sect that tried to bring on the Second Coming and the End Times by celibacy and not having children. It didn't last long, either.
The religion of the left shoots bullets from guns off rooftops.
America really did fill up early on with a lot of religious groups not considered mainstream. Pilgrims, Quakers, Shakers, Amish, Mennonites, etc. Today, Russian Orthodoxy seems to be in vogue among conservative Americans.
Amanda Seyfried hymns the Shaker founder in a musical biopic.
The Testament of Ann Lee
https://tinyurl.com/ykb542he
"I could see that God was within each of them. I’ve always remembered that — that God must be inside everyone in some way, whether they realize it or not.”
Thats a great sentiment. The problem is that many will never realize it.
Sydney said...
"I guess it's like a Catholic religious order, but for Protestants."
I think that the problem is that the Shakers actually required celibacy from both the members of its order and its entire congregation. (The Shakers didn't have what Catholics would call the Laity or lay people, who make up most of the Catholics in the world.) The Shakers don't allow marriages or biological reproduction for anyone who is a Shaker, which is why they're dying out.
Are they very evangelical? I've never heard. I mean, the Bible is very clear that reproducing is a primary calling for godly people (although that doctrine is implicitly modified to a degree in the Epistles to allow for people who may be called to a childless life). So actively seeking to convert people to what is, scripturally, a fringe set of behaviors that doesn't move God to any kind of stronger feeling toward you or to any action (such as immanentizing the eschaton or whatever) seems not much in line with Christian teaching.
*****
I've known several mormon co-workers over the years, and they were great people. Several had stay-at-home wives and 3 kids even on their single relatively low-level salaries. I don't know how they managed it.
*****
I have a lot of Mormon co-workers too, and have noticed the same phenomenon. Some of them have six or seven kids, and are bishops and other (unpaid) officials in the church hierarchy.
They tell me that their mandatory tithing forces them to engage in careful bookkeeping, and it spills over into all of one's other expenditures. They also have a massive work ethic and volunteer for overtime and extra shifts disproportionate to their numbers.
And the stay-at-home wives are not watching soaps and eating bonbons all day. The womens' groups in the church are constantly preaching economizing and saving for a rainy day. Mormon women spend a lot of time clipping coupons, buying basic foodstuffs rather than TV dinners, baking bread, making nutritious meals from scratch, and so on. They are required by their faith to keep a year's supply of food on hand, and carefully rotate their stocks so that they don't expire unused.
The wives often keep the books for the family too, and keep their husbands on a modest allowance. Turns out you don't need a great deal of money if you don't smoke or drink or go out to clubs, who knew?
*****
Today, Russian Orthodoxy seems to be in vogue among conservative Americans.
*****
Orthodoxy in general, I think. I know a right wing guy with no Greek ancestry who goes to a Greek Orthodox church and is a very devout believer and active participant there. There is a prominent monastery out in the desert here in Arizona, said to be the largest Orthodox monastery in the Western Hemisphere, and as he has long been divorced I wouldn't be surprised if he ended up as a monk there.
Each major country in the Orthodox world has its own Orthodox church hierarchy. I think all of them defer to the patriarch of Constantinople in Istanbul as the "primum inter pares", but they pretty much run the show in their own countries without a lot of interference or consultation with the others.
टिप्पणी पोस्ट करा
Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 4 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith. Also: No italics, even briefly. Use asterisks for emphasis. And don't play with the format by changing fonts or using boldface or all caps. Never include more than one extra line break between paragraphs.