२० नोव्हेंबर, २०२६

"Many people actually become, in effect, consumers of 'secondhand news' who don’t always know where they heard something newsy. "

"They may skim, pause, unsubscribe, and otherwise dip in and out of the frothing news current. Carl Seville, the owner of a construction-consulting firm in Atlanta, told me recently that he deleted his Times app around Trump’s second Inauguration. He also stopped listening to N.P.R. every day. Now, he told me, he gets 'a few bits of news from Facebook and LinkedIn.' He’ll also check out The Atlantic. 'But I don’t read, watch, or listen to any daily news anymore.' Seville calls his new approach a 'news diet,' a newish entry in the news-consumption lexicon which is receiving more widespread usage. Katherine McClure, an artist, who also lives in Atlanta, told me that she’s on a news diet, too. 'There’s only so much stress a person can handle, and the very sight of the President adds an unnecessary level of stress,' McClure said. 'Because there is nothing I can do about anything he does.'"

From "Your Friends are Going on 'News Diets'/For a time, educated liberals felt that it was their duty to stay informed on current events. These days, they are among those checking out" (The New Yorker).

Will they check back in now that the "blue wave" happened?

५२ टिप्पण्या:

Wilbur म्हणाले...

Since the midterms, I've checked out of most things political for a while. I've just felt the need to withdraw for a while. The battery will be recharged at some point and I'll return, at least to some degree.

rehajm म्हणाले...

…it’s so odd to hear this as most liberals crave the daily ‘news’ hate on Trump, like the way a shark needs to swim forward. The notion it’s going to be better for them because of the ‘blue wave’ is also odd since if they don’t dismantle our system and it continues to function the way it did for 250 years Trump will still be in office, the only check on their rage. That doesn’t sound too healthy either…

Shouting Thomas म्हणाले...

I remember when I was young and I thought The New Yorker was the epitome of NYC intellectual and literary achievement.

Now, it’s just a piece of shit from the world of the dying Legacy Media and a serious fraudster in the Russian collusion hoax. But, I do agree with the unintended message of the article: “Don’t waste your time on Legacy Media.” Independent media have taken over.

imTay म्हणाले...

Quitting NPR and the New York Times was quite sensible, but The Atlantic is neocon poison too. These outlets are just used for, what did Chomsky call it? Manufacturing Consent? Naah, "manufacturing consensus."

Marcus Bressler म्हणाले...

Stress? What a snowflake.

imTay म्हणाले...

"Will they check back in now that the "blue wave" happened?"

They already know that their blue wave has been just as surely co-opted as the Tea Party and MAGA was. I can see it in people I talk to, who can't believe that the corporate tool Jeffries is speaker.

Eric the Fruit Bat म्हणाले...

"Seville calls his new approach a 'news diet,' a newish entry in the news-consumption lexicon which is receiving more widespread usage."

Next thing you know, everybody's talking about . . . .

Money Manger म्हणाले...

A strict News Diet of Mars Bars and Twinkies.

imTay म्हणाले...

The better source of news is the podcasts.

Mark Rubio passes muster with the Israel lobby

Many of them are BS, you can't judge by one episode, but the ones that are just about click bait eventually get left to the side. Mario Nawful does interviews that the mainstream media won't touch to give you news days ahead of the MSM, if they ever report it at all.

rhhardin म्हणाले...

News has traditionally been an organizer of anxiety. That's now been replaced by online clickbait.

imTay म्हणाले...

Jonah Goldberg whines that news gatekeeping is dead.

"The problem with the internet is that there are no gatekeepers." —Hillary Clinton

boatbuilder म्हणाले...

I stopped listening to or watching the "news" decades ago. Endless hype, spin, and hysteria.

Dave Begley म्हणाले...

NPR never reported the news anyway.

Joe Bar म्हणाले...
ही टिप्पणी लेखकाना हलविली आहे.
Joe Bar म्हणाले...

Money Manger said...
"A strict News Diet of Mars Bars and Twinkies."

That's Milky Ways down here in the US my dude.

Data Schlepper म्हणाले...

In his novel "Stranger in a Strange Land", one of Heinlein's characters warns against "the unnecessary and unhealthy habit of daily wallowing in the troubles and sins of five billion strangers," linking it to psychological distress. And that was written decades before the internet.

Joe Bar म्हणाले...

"the very sight of the President adds an unnecessary level of stress"

To laugh would be cruel.

wendybar म्हणाले...

Seems to me that they have been on a news strike for over a decade if they are still blaming everything on Trump, and not the career politicians who kick the cans down the road, over and over again, whilst promising that NEXT time will be different if you vote for them.

rehajm म्हणाले...

“News has traditionally been an organizer of anxiety”

…got the bubble-headed bleach blonde, comes on at five. She can tell you about the plane crash with a gleam in her eye. It’s interesting when people die…

n.n म्हणाले...

Planned Propagandahood... it's their Choice.

imTay म्हणाले...

Or you can hear clips of interviews that will never show up on mainstream news:

You will get American soldiers back home when Iran is defeated —Israeli envoy.

So our soldiers are asked to fight and maybe be maimed or killed for an Israeli foreign policy objective. WTF?

MadTownGuy म्हणाले...

I get a fair amount of information about current events on X, with the caveat that not all of what's shared there is reliable and unbiased. I still go to AP News and Reuters, sometimes UPI, but you have to read past the headlines to get more facts. Even then, those outlets don't give you unbiased reporting, but I think it's been that way as long as broadcast and print have been a thing.

William म्हणाले...

When the stock market is on a tear, I watch CNBC and gloat. When the market goes down and down and capitulation day is just around the corner, I tend to avoid CNBC. Something like that with the news. Now that Elizabeth Warren will have her very own Senate committee and the opportunity to make news, my interest in the news is not piqued.

Jamie म्हणाले...

This and my husband are pretty much my only sources of news, with the occasional dip into Substack.Thank you all for your service, especially our host.

William म्हणाले...

Some historian said that history is just a bunch of interesting stories Any quest for patterns, morals, or useful lessons is futile. As with history, so with news. It's entertaining, but who knows what it all means. The human race isn't all that bright and frequently devolves into murderous apes. There's not much that's new about this.

baghdadbob म्हणाले...

Twitter/X is by far the best news source. Choose news outlets, newsmakers and opinion writers. If one says something incorrect (e.g. Liz Warren, Robert Reich), they will be eviscerated with corrections in the comments and community notes. Hillary, of course, turned off comments on her thread, but community notes continues.

narciso म्हणाले...

Yes but twiiter has been plenty stupid this last monty

Spiros म्हणाले...

It would be nice to just ignore the lunatics advocating for prison abolition and defending political violence but they're passing laws and appointing judges all over the country.

OnwardandUpward म्हणाले...

What would we know what to think without the New Yorker?

Anthony म्हणाले...

For a time in the 1980s and 1990s I read the NYT and listened to NPR's Talk of the Nation and Science Friday. Dumped the NYT the more I realized they were mostly lying. Ray Suarez was pretty good with TOTN -- he was obviously a lefty, but he at least acquainted himself well with the topic and held some lefty talking head to account (although at least 3 hours a week were about gay topics) -- but then after the 2000 election they completely went off the rails.

I mostly get info from what Alty and Insty link to, also Twitchy.

Alty, Insty, and Twitchy: a new Saturday morning cartoon trio.

Aggie म्हणाले...

At least when you go onto X, you know what you're getting: An array of opinions across the board, sometimes checkable facts, sometimes some important corrections, sometimes some really good thought's being expressed. And lots and lots of drek. The community notes are an invaluable feature.

You don't get any of that on the Legacy Me(D)ia. What you do get is a well-polished production that is designed to capture your attention and supply you with beliefs. It's a set of electronic blinkers.

X is the skeptic's market. You're forced to rely on your bullsh*t detector, whereby with the me(D)ia, you're constantly being lulled to forget using it.

Iman म्हणाले...

They can check out anytime they want, but they never leave.

And that’s a problem. For the USA.

Iman म्हणाले...

“These outlets are just used for, what did Chomsky call it?”

The source of the idiocy is revealed.

RCOCEAN II म्हणाले...

The libtards cant accept even one ounce of dissent. They must be in total control, and everyone must bow down to them. If not, they either tune out or get angry and bring it up constantly.

Even the murder of their opponents by extremists, will only elict a shrug of the shoulders, or a small smile.

Conservatives think by calling them "snow flakes" or "unreasonable" will change them. And it wont. It will take much, much more.

RCOCEAN II म्हणाले...

This reminds me of the NY Article about some well-to-do guy in Ohio, who couldn't accept Trump's victory in 2016, so he cut off all news and information and stayed in his house all day. Except to make a daily trip to the local diner for breakfast. I think Althouse blogged about it because it was in the NYTs.

RCOCEAN II म्हणाले...

Jonah Goldberg is so irrelevant. Nobody cares what he thinks. He's basically a liberal Democrat with a soft spot for Big Business and a huge love of Israel.

He was always a mediocrity. When he started out with NR, he was basically the young clown who wrote about Pop Culture. Then he mysteriously became co-editor with Rich Lowrey, and wrote "Liberal Fascism".

I can remember being puzzled in August 2008 when he was so postive about McCain picking Lieberman as his VP. Shouldn't a conservative be upset at our picking Gore's VP as our VP?

And then Trump came along and they discoved he was taking $$ from Google while writing "Why Leftwing Google is really conservative" articles.

So he got bounced. And no one cares.

Lazarus म्हणाले...

"For a time, educated liberals felt that it was their duty to stay informed on current events. These days, they are among those checking out"

The second sentence is certainly true. The first sentence? Well, it usually meant reading very similar newspapers published in different cities or adding PBS and NPR, the Atlantic, and the New Yorker to the newspapers and TV networks that told them the same thing.

Right now, though, there does seem to be more opinion diversity among left-of-center bloggers and podcasters than there was in the old mainstream media. The effect has been to push many progressives further left: there may be a difference between the NYT and Hasan Piker. Liberals saw a similar development earlier among conservatives and complained about it.

Lazarus म्हणाले...

Jonah Goldberg has basically been a comedian. It's hard to take anything he writes "seriously" seriously. He kind of acknowledged that when he moved from the still somewhat serious, still somewhat respectable National Review to the much more niche Dispatch.

Steve म्हणाले...

Here's a good rule to consume news by: If you can't get to the source within three clicks, the claim is made up.

Fred Drinkwater म्हणाले...

"become consumers of 'secondhand news' "
Really. Does he read his own words? Was he born yesterday?

Hombre म्हणाले...

There are no “educated liberals”, only credentialed lefties. Look up the definition of “classic liberalism” for another shock about the corruption of the language.

bagoh20 म्हणाले...

What is first hand news? You can't even trust thigs you see with your own eyes anymore . I mean, are those talking babies real, because they sure look real.

bagoh20 म्हणाले...

You see a story. You wonder if it's real. You look for a source, but you don't know if they are honest, so you try another one, and so on. The advantage of AI is that you can challenge it with exactly what you find suspicious and make the program prove it. You can't do that with other sources. AI is the search engine we've been waiting for, but it's still going to kill us all. Not sure that's a bad thing, so I asked Grok.
"It is not necessarily bad, and might even be neutral or positive. If the AI that replaces humanity is more capable of expanding intelligence, consciousness, scientific understanding, or other valued goods across the universe, then human extinction is succession rather than pure destruction..."
Not looking good.

Leora म्हणाले...

They are consuming news like normal people do. Soon they won’t, know the name of their congress person like the usual person in the street. It may be an improvement.

Hassayamper म्हणाले...

Better for them, and better for the body politic.

Hassayamper म्हणाले...

If I were a builder, I would never, ever, EVER hire a "construction consultant" who had been a daily NPR listener and such an avid reader of the NYT that he kept its app on his phone.

Aggie म्हणाले...

Hasan Piker. Now there's a name I haven't heard once, since about a week before election day. Prior to that, he was getting his picture alongside a whole lot of candidates, being pimped as the New Face of the Left. What happened? I mean, from Hero to Zero is just a couple of weeks. Where Hasan? One might have thought he'd be everywhere, taking a victory lap.

Hassayamper म्हणाले...

*****
He was always a mediocrity... [Then he] wrote "Liberal Fascism".
*****

I must differ with you here. "Liberal Fascism" was a perceptive, well-written masterpiece, and greatly needed at that time, as evidenced by the venom with which the leftist filth greeted its publication.

This makes Goldberg's subsequent nitwit RINO heresy all the more distressing. What a loss to our side.

Jim at म्हणाले...

*and the very sight of the President adds an unnecessary level of stress,'*

That's because you're a child completely incapable of acting like an adult.

RCOCEAN II म्हणाले...
ही टिप्पणी लेखकाना हलविली आहे.
RCOCEAN II म्हणाले...

ctually, "Liberal Fascism" is just an attack on Pre-1940 Gentile progressivism. Eugenics. William jennings bryan. Margaret Sanger. Mussolinin. The bull moose party. Woodrow wilson and the new Deal.

Goldberg says this in defense of his book:

"As I make clear in Liberal Fascism, the obvious and pressing threat is not from a Hitlerite-Orwellian dictatorship but from a Huxleyan namby-pamby mommy state. That sort of system could seduce Americans into becoming chestless subjects of the State in exchange for bottomless self-gratification and liberation from the necessity of adult decision-making. Yes, there's a danger that such a society could then be susceptible to some darker vision that lionizes the lost manhood of a half-forgotten past. But, by that point, this would be America in name only, if even that ("U.N. District 12" has a nice ring to it)."

Read that and then re-read it. And then try to tie it the reality of the USA. Its meaningless goobley-gook.

And then he says this in 2013 in defense of his book:
"Linking Obama a crypto-Nazi (if by that you mean to say he's a would-be Hitler), the real problem with all of this loose Nazi talk is that it slanders the American people. Daniel Jonah Goldhagen may have overstated his case in Hitler's Willing Executioners, but he was certainly right that the German people were Hitler's willing enablers. The overwhelming majority of the American people — in their history, culture, bones, hearts, souls, DNA, and carbon molecules — are not like that. "

But Goldberg spent all of 2015-2016, claiming Trump *was* Hitler 2.0. Goldberg was always a neo-con clown.

Marcus Bressler म्हणाले...

Wait, there are "soldiers" in Iran? When did that happen?

टिप्पणी पोस्ट करा

Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 4 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith. Also: No italics, even briefly. Use asterisks for emphasis. And don't play with the format by changing fonts or using boldface or all caps. Never include more than one extra line break between paragraphs.