October 31, 2021

This is, perhaps, the freakiest coincidence in all my years of blogging.

1. This morning, before going out for my sunrise run, where I planned to continue listening to the audiobook of Jonathan Franzen's new novel "Crossroads," I opened up the NYT review, "Jonathan Franzen’s ‘Crossroads,’ a Mellow, ’70s-Era Heartbreaker That Starts a Trilogy." I wanted to read a review, and I selected that one, just because it's in the NYT (and written by Dwight Garner, a reviewer I like).

2. After the sunrise, with that tab sitting open on my browser, I sat down for my usual morning blogging session, and what caught my eye and set the tone for the morning was Donald Trump's participation in the tomahawk chop at the World Series game in Atlanta last night.

3. As I wrote in the previous post, that "jogged my thinking about gestures and chants that mimic the real or imagined traditions of indigenous people and I thought, remember drum circles?" That led me into a 1991 WaPo article about the men's movement 30 years ago, which entailed drumming and other "Native American" inspired rituals, much of which came from the musings of the poet Robert Bly. 

4. I click various windows out of my way and uncover that "Crossroads" review. It begins:
Jonathan Franzen’s new novel, “Crossroads,” is the first in a projected trilogy, which is reason to be wary. Good trilogies rarely announce themselves as such at the start. And the overarching title for the series, “A Key to All Mythologies,” may be a nod to “Middlemarch,” but it also sounds as if Franzen were channeling Joseph Campbell, or Robert Bly, or Tolkien, or Yes.

5. And don't even get me started on Joseph Campbell. That was so last week.

15 comments:

Temujin said...

You are in synch with like minds. Any trilogies planned?

ndspinelli said...

Fascinating!!!!

Linda said...

Ha Ha! I just saw a Facebook post from a friend of a friend - with video from a drum circle with chanting and dancing that occurred (I think yesterday) at Olbrich park along Lake Monona. I could be wrong - but none of the individuals appeared to be Native American. Dancers included, dreadlocks, bare chests, purple tights and a devil with a hula hoop. Most of the drummers looked like white, middle aged, men and women -- but they might identify as something else.

Typical day on the east side of Madison.

Assistant Village Idiot said...

I haven't thought of Robert Bly in years. I think that qualifies as an odd coincidence.

Tim said...

I read the blurb for Crossroads, which unlike a review is supposed to make you want to read the book, and it sounded like it was about a bunch of people I would not like very much. I can't imagine the review would make me more likely to want to read it.

Tina Trent said...

Poor Bly. He wrote lovely poems
About pain being prehistoric
And then he started the Men’s Movement.
Sigh.

cubanbob said...

Trump! Is there anything he can't be somehow related too? A tag labeled Trump Universe ( like the Marvel Universe) needs to be created for all things that can somehow attributed too or be associated with Trump. May the Trump be with you!

Jamie said...

I once watched a drum circle on Venice Beach for a while. Most entertaining part: when one guy kept trying to hijack the rhythm. He never succeeded, but man, he was persistent.

I wasn't close enough to see faces clearly, but I could imagine all those supportive, free-spirited, socially constructive people (this wasn't a men's-only drum circle) rolling their eyes and resolutely sticking with the rhythm established by whoever the unknown drum major was. They all did a wonderful job of doing as they were told, without any instructions perceptible from the outside.

Hmm.

MayBee said...

I'm listening to Crossroads and really enjoying it. Nobody does self-loathing like Jonathan Franzen.

Michelle Dulak Thomson said...

I have literally not heard one word about Bly since Iron John came out and then Susan Faludi had lots of nasty fun at his expense in Backlash. Late 80s?

BD in Akron said...

Another coincidence? The previous post quotes Ed Honnold. Is Ed related to Alex Honnold, whose mother just scaled El Capitan at age 70? Climbing El Capitan at any age trumps(!) a drum circle ceremony.

madAsHell said...

There's a Monday morning drum circle in a nearby park.

Why do they all wear tie-dye, wool socks, and Birkenstocks?

Lurker21 said...

Was it this blog that brought up My Dinner With André last month?

If you find yourself falling into an André Gregory spiral, calm down, take a deep breath, and turn off your computer.

Otherwise, you don't know where you will end up and what condition you'll be in when you get there.

Louie the Looper said...

A further coincidence: the review was written by Dwight Garner.

PM said...

Bob Caro scoffs at trilogies.