August 12, 2021

"Miss Ann (sometimes Miss Anne) was [Karen's] forerunner, coming from Southern Black vernacular of the 19th century — the mistress of the plantation, the boss lady..."

"... (and proto-girlboss), with a mandatory honorific. While she was subordinate to the white man (Mr. Charlie), she still held a higher status in the hierarchy than Black people and exploited this for all she was worth, alternately imperious and dainty, belligerent and helpless, depending on context. The moniker has persisted: The writer Zora Neale Hurston listed it in a glossary appended to her 1942 short fiction 'Story in Harlem Slang,' the memoirist and civil rights activist Maya Angelou deployed it in her poem 'Sepia Fashion Show' in 1969 ('I’d remind them please, look at those knees, / you got at Miss Ann’s scrubbing') and as late as 2016, when CNN exit polls for the presidential election indicated that more than 40 percent of white women had voted for Donald Trump, the journalist Amy Alexander, writing on The Root, explained the results as the 'Miss Ann effect.' But as Carla Kaplan, a professor of American literature, notes in 'Miss Anne in Harlem' (2013), by the time of the Harlem Renaissance in the 1920s, a more subtle white woman had come to earn the name — one who intentionally entered Black spaces at a time when other white people denounced such an act 'as either degeneracy or lunacy.' Some of these women were activists, others mere thrill-seekers or provocateurs, their motives and desires ranging 'from dreadful to honorable,' Kaplan writes, and they were greeted in the Black community with caution."

From "The March of the Karens/The name has come to represent an entitled and belligerent white woman. But what does this narrative say — and elide — about racism and sexism today?" by Ligaya Mishan (NYT).

10 comments:

Lem the artificially intelligent said...

It turns out there was more to the Central Park 'Karen' story left out because... it didn't help the narrative along?

From Matt Taibbi TK Newsletter via Substack complaining about how news coverage has devolved into a infantile 'good people' vs 'bad people.' He uses the book Lolita as a background.

"The infamous Central Park dog-walker became the poster child for cosmopolitan racism when video of her calling police on a black man, coincidentally named Christian Cooper, went viral in the middle of America’s post-George Floyd meltdown. Reporting by Kmele Foster has since uncovered that important background to the Cooper story may have been left out, perhaps even intentionally, by news media hot for a fitting villain during a national furor. Among other things, there appears to have been testimony from other dog-walkers, including a 30 year-old black man, that Christian Cooper was a self-appointed leash police oddball who threatened to pick up other people’s dogs."

"It’s bad enough that in the Internet age the presence of a functioning cell phone camera during 15-30 seconds of lamentable judgment can consign one person to a life of infamy while someone who traffics in genuinely evil choices on a daily basis, dumping deadly toxins or doing PR for dictators or governing the State of New York by tribute, can still win Man of the Year or a key to a city with a donation or two. Worse than that, we don’t even fact-check our pass/fail reactions to those 15-second outbursts, and when information surfaces suggesting a mistake, we tend to double-down instead, with headlines like, “Central Park ‘Karen,’ Amy Cooper, Remains Unrepentant About Central Park Karen-ing.” Not only are we totally uninterested as a society in concepts like redemption, we revel in the careless, emotional quality of our judgments. People are just Bad or Good, and the Bad are all Bad."

rcocean said...

"while she was subordinate to her husband" Did anyone ask Mr. Charlie if that was true?

tim maguire said...

I like when words have specific meanings. When “Karen” first came out, it referred to a woman who was irrationally attached to petty rules (“I’d like to speak to your manager!”). A key to the Karen was that the person she was complaining about actually was doing something wrong. Now it just means “woman I don’t like.”

Marcus said...

Karens are those women (and some men) who think they can get a different answer to their demand if they go higher up. I rarely see or hear of situations where the staff was doing something wrong. My daughter, who works as a manager at a Fresh Market, encounters these entitled people who believe that is anything is wrong, they are supposed to get something for free to compensate them for that.

theoldman

Enlighten-NewJersey said...

Are there names for bossy or obnoxious women from other races or is it only white women who are known to exhibit this type of behavior? The people promoting the white women “Karen” narrative are clearly racist and should be called out as such.

BarrySanders20 said...

"But as Carla Kaplan, a professor of American literature, notes in 'Miss Anne in Harlem' (2013), by the time of the Harlem Renaissance in the 1920s, a more subtle white woman had come to earn the name — one who intentionally entered Black spaces at a time when other white people denounced such an act 'as either degeneracy or lunacy.' Some of these women were activists, others mere thrill-seekers or provocateurs, their motives and desires ranging 'from dreadful to honorable,' Kaplan writes, and they were greeted in the Black community with caution."

Greeted with caution? Whatever for?

Per Wiki: "In 1921, Margaret Sanger founded the American Birth Control League, which later became the Planned Parenthood Federation of America. In New York City, she organized the first birth control clinic to be staffed by all-female doctors, as well as a clinic in Harlem which had an all African-American advisory council, where African-American staff were later added."

So were Sanger's motives and desires dreadful or honorable?

mikee said...

The opposite of a Miss Ann, and of a Karen, might be the Neighborhood LOL - Little Old Lady. I've met many in my life, the widows who keep living in the house where they raised their families, who decades later are all alone and have nothing better to do than watch the neighborhood activity through their front windows. They are the ones who know everyone on the street by name, and use the neighbor's kids for lawnwork, landscaping, snow shoveling, and large purchases of Girl Scout cookies. They are the ones who call you about the $300 bike your kid forgot on the neighbor's lawn when he went there to play. They are the ones who call police on the strangers in a van, scoping out the street for a burglary. They are the ones who go to City Council meetings to prevent the woods by the creek from being destroyed for a new strip mall. They are the ones who pull their dead husband's old revolver out of the sock drawer and face down a daytime burglar. The Neighborhood LOL can be any race, and not even that old. Find one near you, and cherish her!

William said...

Ponder the case of Scarlet O'Hara. Scarlet seems not to have taken much of an interest in the plight or advancement of recently freed darkies, but she was at the very forefront of the Peace Now movement when it came to Sherman's Army. It is instructive to note how some Karens are celebrated and others are vilified. Some are Madame Lafarge and others are Marianne leading the troops. From the supine to the meticulous is but a step.

Charlie said...

Little Richard has a song.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UIo493gIVqk

Skippy Tisdale said...

" CNN exit polls for the presidential election indicated that more than 40 percent of white women had voted for Donald Trump"

To less than half.