September 2, 2020

"On a plot designated by officials for the open-air school, builders installed a pavilion, gardens, activity areas and open sheds, some fitted with tables and benches for lessons."

"The school grounds also included a larger shed for meals, an enclosed shelter for rainy days and rest periods, a teacher’s room, a kitchen, toilets and a 'cure gallery,' a special structure designed to maximize sun exposure. In a departure from prevailing norms and in keeping with the goals of progressive educators, boys and girls were never separated. Whereas the average school in Prussia—Germany’s largest and most populous state—counted two square meters per pupil, students at Charlottenburg’s forest school enjoyed 40.... The forest school ensured a steady supply of fresh air to the children of workers. Half the school’s teachers were former patients at sanatoria, where they had already recovered from tuberculosis....  By 1908... the first outdoor school opened in the United States, in Providence, Rhode Island, in the dead of winter no less....
"[T]he Providence Open-Air School was housed in an old school building, where a brick wall had been removed and replaced with large windows that always remained open. To protect the school’s 25 'delicate children' from the cold, wool mittens, hats, overshoes and 'sitting-out bags,' the equivalent of today’s sleeping bags, were provided.... For American educators scrambling to meet the challenges of skyrocketing enrollments—the result of rapid urbanization, immigration and the enforcement of compulsory schooling laws—the outdoor schools promised some relief. At least it would remove at-risk children 'from what many health experts considered the overheated and noxious atmosphere of the typical school room,' writes Richard Meckel, a professor of American Studies at Brown University, in an article on the early history of the schools, 'and provide them with sustained exposure to cold air, which was widely believed to promote strength and vigor by stimulating the appetite and increasing respiratory and vascular activity.' It was this line of thinking that drew support from the eugenics movement. 'Eugenicists prioritized the wider society and future generations,' says Weindling, 'and many thought that promoting fitness could prevent infections, which justified open-air schools.'"

From "When Tuberculosis Struck the World, Schools Went Outside/A century ago, a deadly disease sparked a novel concept: teaching in the great outdoors to keep kids safe" (Smithsonian).

17 comments:

MadisonMan said...

I can't see any Teachers' Union okaying this. All their members would get cold.

mikee said...

Outdoor schools, to avoid infection! What a great idea! Or, one can use childhood vaccinations to prevent tuberculosis, until it becomes so rare in a nation (like the US) that the vaccination is discontinued, with antibiotic treatment for the few remaining cases that crop up.

Why reorganize all of society to solve a problem, when the problem can be eliminated so much more easily?

Are you listening, Antifa, BLM, and Democrats?

rehajm said...

Funny they bring this up- TB sanatariums were the face masks of their time, based in part on the bad/no science that suggested cold air was a treatment. You can argue how much of that recommendation was to convince people into isolation from family and society...

Follow the science- The covid spikes are over, deaths from covid without comorbidity were a rare occurrence, treatment is saving lives, vaccines are here in two quarters. That not a need to reorder society...

Fernandinande said...

Smithsonian: "As more white Americans reckon with a long history of racial injustice," link says "Per the Alabama-based Equal Justice Initiative, more than 4,400 lynchings—mob killings undertaken without legal authority—took place in the U.S. between the end of Reconstruction and World War II." without bothering to mention that about 30% of those lynched were white.

It's good to know that smithsonianmag.com dispenses dishonest anti-white racist propaganda.

rehajm said...

Put in person voting locations in hair salons since our betters believe they are covid-free safe spaces...

rcocean said...

If you've even been in an very old urban school building, you'll see why this movement got started. These old school buildings have very small rooms with slide up windows, small cramped hallways, and small, usually paved over, playgrounds. Crowded. And with those old timey radiators, overheated. Stuffy is the word that comes to mind.

During this same time, TR was telling young men to get out the city, and go rough it out in the wilds for a week or two. So, it just wasn't about TB or avoiding disease.

rcocean said...

Didn't a similar movement happen after WW 2 when people were scared about Polio?

Michael K said...

In China schools are being built with translucent walls in an effort to reduce myopia.

In Australia, ethnic Chinese children have half to incidence of myopia and it is thought due to more play time outside.

MayBee said...

They can try whatever they want as long as the people who come up with the idea either participate in in themselves, or enroll their children in it.

Wince said...

"Ahh, look at that, man, the great outdoors! Huh?"

Nonapod said...

“Both physicians and the public were very concerned about tuberculosis,” says Paul Weindling, the Wellcome Trust research professor in the history of medicine at England’s Oxford Brookes University. “There were many social distancing guidelines in diverse social contexts, as well as efforts to regulate personal behavior.”

I'm pretty sure the term "social distancing" didn't exist back then, although I'm willing to be proven wrong.

Evindently TB has an R0 of less than 1 (meaning it's less infectious than things like influenza and Covid-19).

mockturtle said...

Obviously meant for places with little or no wind.

Jupiter said...

If your children aren't criminals, don't send them to prisons. Home-school!

wild chicken said...

"Didn't a similar movement happen after WW 2 when people were scared about Polio?"

No, quite the opposite. They closed the public swimming pools.

Fernandinande said...

4,400 lynchings...between the end of Reconstruction and World War II."

Which works out to about 50 blacks murdered in each of those years, compared with current rate of about 6,775 blacks murdered by other blacks each year. (2018 data: 15500(total murders)*.47(black fraction)*.93(fraction of black victims killed by other blacks))

Jersey Fled said...

Somehow I get a picture of the schools in East Africa that I've seen.

But the quality of instruction is much better,in the African schools.

gerry said...

I love Shorpy.