As long as it has a Wicker Man like ending, as all Nic Cage films are contractually obligated to have, I'm in.
— Nick Gillespie (@nickgillespie) November 20, 2026
"a mind is not really a house, but's a close alternative, sort of an alt-house"
As long as it has a Wicker Man like ending, as all Nic Cage films are contractually obligated to have, I'm in.
— Nick Gillespie (@nickgillespie) November 20, 2026
38 comments:
The word "overkill" can never be more aptly applied than to that unrated DVD version ending.
I hope no bees were harmed filming the end.
My daughter likes these sort of horror films. I don't. Wait, the old Frankenstein or Dracula movies were OK. Bela logosi and Christopher Lee. But then I don't like movies about serial killers either.
Do you recommend the film, Althouse?
I've seen most of Cage's films and enjoyed them, or at least appreciated them. But I skipped Wicker due to spoilers from friends and figured I would find it too disturbing for the payoff. (I tend to get very unsettled at certain types of violence.)
Is worth a revisit?
Watch Madden and see what you think of Cage. It is literally the worst movie I have ever seen. The acting is bad (note just Cage - Christian Bale is pretty awful too), the mysterious accent that sounds nothing like Madden is bad, the script sucks, the plotting is confusing (and this is a biopic where i knew much of what was/should have been taking place).
I thought "Straw Dogs," "A Clockwork Orange," and "Cries and Whispers" were brilliant in a whole number of ways, but I could never rewatch them (and I'm a rewatcher by nature). They were so disturbing and I felt deeply unsettled, mentally and even physically, after watching them. I didn't regret seeing them and I could recognize their greatness, but following seeing all of those, I began to steer away from films that might cause me to repeat the experience. "Wicker" was one of those.
But I might be in a different place now than decades ago; I don't really know. This is why I asked for recommendation.
I got a kick out of Madden in real life. But I've heard a lot of negative things about the biopic, so I intend to give it a pass, unless convinced otherwise.
Have you guys who didn't like "Madden" tried watching it backwards?
tommyesq,
Yep.
Nic Cage's "Wicker Man" sucked, largely because of Cage's inability to project the dread and terror his character needs to feel, because of Cage's standard, typical overacting.
If you want Wicker Man, watch the real "The Wicker Man."
It looks really bad, so it's probably really good.
Jomboy is like Madden.
tommyesq said...
“Watch Madden and see what you think of Cage. It is literally the worst movie I have ever seen.”
You’re definitely in line with most viewers/reviewers.
I enjoyed it.
Maybe because I’m not a sports fan.
Maybe because I only had time to watch it in half an hour segments,
Maybe because I loved the portrayal of Al Green and his wife.
Maybe because I liked their version of heaven - “The Afterlife Football Hall of Fame.”
Their friendship, their manic devotion to football came through in the movie. Just a fun ride.
lol Al Davis notvAl Green!
It is literally the worst movie I have ever seen.
If I was a hanging judge, I would sentence you to watching four episodes of Teletubbies, followed by The Star Wars Holiday Special and Pauly Shore is Dead. And while you are screaming at your attorney, I bang my gavel and say, "Handcuff him to the couch! And start him off with Irreversible, in the original French. Backwards!"
Madden is a comic biopic, so it's possible some members of the NFL cult are unhappy about that. I don't want to say Theater Kids Revenge, but that's a possibility. It's a fun movie, heartfelt, actually, and it makes me like the Raiders a lot more than I did.
…yes, Madden was terrible. I tapped out after 5min watching it alone but the wife wanted to watch so I hung in. You know what it reminded me of? Watching one of those 60s/70s kung fu epic where the voices are dubbed in a way to try and disguise the mouths moving so there’s superfluous and incoherent dialogue…and did you catch John Krasinski’s role? I bet you didn’t the first time…
I don’t think John Krasinski is in Madden.
If you like Wicker Man, try Iron Maiden's version.
https://youtu.be/9PKBI-n06gM?si=RnQUUTDgNuo7rtxN
CC, JSM
It's a solid A-. Stylistically it's quite similar to Joy or The Silver Linings Playbook or American Hustle. It's a very typical David O. Russell movie. If you like his art, you'll like this one, too.
I enjoyed it. It's a comical, expressionist take on Madden's football career and family life. The acting is entertaining.
I can understand people not liking it though. You have to be in the right mood for Madden, I think.
Madden, the movie, reminded me of Bubba Ho-Tep, which I loved.
I also loved Al’s wife Carol. Those kinds of women are so much fun to be around - glamorous, a little larger than life, loyal, and up for anything.
If it's worse than The Babe Ruth Story, it's in Plan 9 territory.
The unimaginable miscasting of William Bendix as Ruth, the almost completely fictional portrayal of his life, the terrible writing and acting ... well it can be entertaining watching it on The Bad Movie Level, like MST3000.
I can understand people not liking it though. You have to be in the right mood for Madden, I think.
It undercuts the drama of football, no doubt. Almost all the football is off camera. Maybe 15 minutes of actual football play in the movie. They covered Super Bowl XI early in the movie. I was like, "where is it going from here?"
rcommal, I learned back in 1980 that I needn't subject myself and my limited memory to certain images or dialogue, merely because some "artists" had recorded them. I now have no hesitation in abandoning a film or book if I feel like I am a psychological play-toy of the creators.
Baskets or furniture?
St Croix, most of those are not movies. Also, I have seen Madden described as a comedy, but i didn't see any attempts to get laughs.
“I don’t think John Krasinski is in Madden”
…at about 6:30 run time wife and I both went ‘Hey! wait a minute!!’ Guess we were the only ones..:
But is "Madden" a "sports bio" of the usual sort? How can you make the usual sports pic dramatic arc when so much of Madden's life was in broadcasting? My friend AI says, it's more of an "eccentric, heavily dramatized biographical comedy-drama rather than a traditional, strictly factual sports biopic."
The Wicker Man was originally a British film. Was it better? Possibly. More authentic maybe. One can hate the big budget version, but low-budget British projects can also be quirky and off-putting. British movies from the 30s and TV Britdrams of the 60s make me a bit suspicious and hostile.
There was some controversy a few years back about the Critical Drinker's panning "Midsommar," a film with a somewhat similar background and premise. File it under "Everything nowadays is worse."
Gross. I would never watch that. Wild Horses Nine was great.
“ But I don't know what he means by "a Wicker Man like ending." There are 2 possible endings. The unrated DVD version or the version that was released in theaters and that is now playing on The Criterion Channel.”
Didn’t matter to me. I bailed about halfway through.
St Croix, most of those are not movies.
Huh?
Silver Linings Playbook
Joy
American Hustle
Also, I have seen Madden described as a comedy, but i didn't see any attempts to get laughs..
Yeah, it's a tweener. Definitely not a drama (no bad guy!). And it's not actually going for laughter. (Although I did bark out a few). So if you're not going for drama or comedy, you're already in an audience hole. But the non-dramatic, non-laughing comedy is a David O. Russell speciality.
My current theory is that people who really like the Raiders (the immediate audience to see this movie) are people who are really not going to like the movie. I mean, if he did this to Dean Smith or Tom Landry, I'd be kind of mad.
But if you just kinda like the Raiders, or don't like the Raiders, or you don't even know who the Raiders are, this movie is a lot of fun. I think the non-emotionally invested audience is out there, they just have to find it.
Also, to be fair, Silver Linings and American Hustle both have a stronger dramatic spine than this movie. Bio-pics are notoriously non-dramatic.
Madden is poking a lot of fun at men, by the way, and our obsessions. But in a nice way. Madden is a sweetheart in this movie. This film actually got me liking Al Davis for the first time in my life.
The David O. Russell blow-up with Lily Tomlin is pretty famous in Hollywood. He was cancelled for a while and came back.
"Do you recommend the film, Althouse?"
If you saw the movie, you'd know how funny the question is. I'd need to know a lot more about the prospective viewer before I could answer and even then, I don't want to be responsible. You're not going to be going to the theater to watch it, so you don't need it to be recommended. You can get it to play on a television, and you'd have to have be in the right mood. I would say if you don't like seeing women sucker-punched by men dressed in a bear suit, you ought to forget about it.
And I didn't watch the unrated DVD version, so I didn't even see the "not the bees" scene.
Post a Comment
Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 4 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith. Also: No italics, even briefly. Use asterisks for emphasis. And don't play with the format by changing fonts or using boldface or all caps. Never include more than one extra line break between paragraphs.