31 జులై, 2026

"In the 1800s, a secretary was part aide-de-camp, part executive-in-training — someone who handled the boss’s correspondence and bookkeeping, but also learned the business..."

"... and would eventually ascend to a senior job. With the rise of the modern corporation around the turn of the 20th century, however, the secretary became more like a noncommissioned officer — a worker with real responsibility but little upward mobility. It was at this point that the position became mostly female. Companies then broke up and degraded the job further over the decades, replacing the secretary with pools of typists, receptionists and data entry personnel, almost all of them women, too. The final step, amid pressure from the feminist movement in the 1970s, was to allow a small number of college-educated women to ascend from these clerical jobs to the ranks of middle management. But even this came with a loss of status, as managers would have to do more of their own grunt work. 'They’re now being promoted, but the clerical tasks are promoted with them,' said Jason Resnikoff, a labor historian. 'The middle manager would do more typing, correspondence, more of their own filing.' These days, almost no one has an assistant...."

From "In Trump’s Economy, Job Gains Go to Women. That’s Not an Entirely Good Thing. Despite the administration’s best attempts, the diminishing status of many American jobs is driving a spike in women’s employment" (NYT gift link).

47 కామెంట్‌లు:

Mason G చెప్పారు...

"In Trump’s Economy, Job Gains Go to Women- Women Hardest Hit"

Quaestor చెప్పారు...

The problem with "labor expertise" is dearth of personal experience with anything outside the ivory tower. Show me one who has actually risen to command a Fortune 500 corporation...

Quaestor చెప్పారు...

In the 1800s, a secretary was more often a piece of office furniture than a person.

RideSpaceMountain చెప్పారు...

"We wanted more responsibility and pay! Not more accountability and work!?!" - 1970s feminists

RideSpaceMountain చెప్పారు...

+1 Mason G

Quaestor చెప్పారు...

When the word appeared in English, secretary referred to the monarch's handler of encrypted communications, Sir Francis Walsingham, for example. This is why secretary contains secret.

CJinPA చెప్పారు...

Amazing. No matter the issue, or how it evolves, the takeaway message is one that endorses the left's agenda. Always.

Seems like the big story is "Progressive Ideas Declared Victorious/All Policy Debates End"

Balfegor చెప్పారు...

As a midlevel associate in a lawfirm, I spent quite a bit of time preparing correspondence to go out under the senior partner's name. And reviewing and preparing bills. Scheduling meetings. That wasn't all I did, of course, but a lot of those clerical tasks were offloaded onto professionals rather than clerical staff. In my own case, I had to do most if not all my own clerical work, including a lot of basic in-office stuff like assembling binders and making scans, because I could not rely on my own secretary to do them timely or correctly. My secretary also could not add hours and minutes.

This is a long way of saying that I think a lot of secretarial work is still performed by the same sort of people with the same career prospects as in the past. We just don't call them secretaries anymore. Maybe they exercise real responsibility in some institutions, but my own experience was that they couldn't really be trusted with anything, and junior professionals or paralegals handled most important secretarial tasks.

stlcdr చెప్పారు...

Good grief, it's like conspiracies everywhere - to what lengths will society (men!) go to ensure women don't succeed?

Original Mike చెప్పారు...

"'The middle manager would do more typing, correspondence, more of their own filing.'"

I think a lot of that has to do with the advent of the personal computer and especially the word processor. My first grant application in the mid-80s as a new faculty member was written out long hand and given to a secretary to type (I recently ran across one of my drafts from that proposal). Ditto all the ancillary forms. By the mid-90s I was doing it all myself. Which actually was less work for me.

Anthony చెప్పారు...

The typewriter had a massive influence on getting women into the office space. For whatever reason, women tended to excel at it.

hombre చెప్పారు...

Of course it’s “Not an Entirely Good Thing.” It’s about Trump. Right? How could even “job gains” be good?

Bill R చెప్పారు...

"These days, almost no one has an assistant...."

The horror. The horror!

Bill R చెప్పారు...

"These days, almost no one has an assistant...."

The horror. The horror!

Leland చెప్పారు...

That’s quite a narrative voice and perspective. Alas, my company’s CEO is a woman and 7 years ago, most (90%) of the administrative assistants (we didn’t call them secretaries) were laid off for cost reduction reasons. Not all of the assistants were women and none were destined for leadership positions. Their job was to off-take menial administrative work from the leaders they assisted, thus the job title. That was during a Trump Administration, but not this one. The currently remaining assistants are like warehouse managers that make sure office supplies, office equipment, and conference rooms are available as needed. When they leave, their jobs are not likely to be backfilled.

Levi Starks చెప్పారు...

Women finally succeed and find out they're worse off.

Aught Severn చెప్పారు...

Don't forget that women are also doing all of the housework, all of the child care, and carrying all of the emotional labor at home, as well. Surely it is not fair that female junior middle management can not enjoy the perks of the C-suite contingent!

Oh, and don't forget that these days they are also carrying the burden of earning the majority of college degrees *and* keeping campus life alive as, what, 60% or so of the student population. Truly, women have it rough these days...

Known Unknown చెప్పారు...

If our creative department had two 'secretaries' we would be vastly more productive as we do too much clerical and non-creative work.

n.n చెప్పారు...

Maybe a fetus... feature of urbane planning and prejudice. Abort.

RideSpaceMountain చెప్పారు...

It's taken a lot of propaganda to get women to believe that working hard for the love of their families and children was oppression manifest, but slaving for a faceless and indifferent corporation was stunning, brave, and liberating.

rhhardin చెప్పారు...

You'd start as a subbookkeeper, which has even more doubled letters.

R C Belaire చెప్పారు...

I think we need to dial-back the usefulness of women in the workplace -- way too much whining. We could begin with suffrage...

Dagwood చెప్పారు...

Under Biden's economy the NYT would be raving about job gains going to women.

Iman చెప్పారు...

More negative framing from the YNT… unfit for the birdcage.

bagoh20 చెప్పారు...

This is about who runs the steam engine at the buggy whip factory?

Temujin చెప్పారు...

"These days, almost no one has an assistant...."
Wait til they see what AI does to the levels of corporate management. I look forward to the article about men creating AI to filter out women from the marketplace.

Rabel చెప్పారు...

The subhead is absurd:

"Despite the administration’s best attempts, the diminishing status of many American jobs is driving a spike in women’s employment."

Smilin' Jack చెప్పారు...

“ With the rise of the modern corporation around the turn of the 20th century, however, the secretary became more like a noncommissioned officer — a worker with real responsibility but little upward mobility.”

A secretary with ambition could go far:

“ Under Stalin, the office of general secretary became the most powerful position in the Communist Party. Since the party had a monopoly on political power, the general secretary de facto had executive control of the Soviet government.”

The Middle Coast చెప్పారు...

What Original Mike said. Based upon my own experience, the rise of email in particular meant that traditional secretaries would not be preparing correspondence. Admins today are for the very senior, handling snail mail, ordering stuff for the break room, scheduling meetings for the more-seniors visiting from the mothership, and generally keeping the senior from having to deal with rote issues.

Esteban చెప్పారు...

What the Middle Coast said. I've been a C-Suite executive and I currently work in Big Law. Never had my own dedicated assistant and climbed the later doing most of the "secretarial" work myself. It's more about the advancements in technology than anything. I don't need a secretary to coordinate a meeting when I can pop open a meeting planner and see when everyone is available. Within what, 30 seconds, the meeting is scheduled.

RCOCEAN II చెప్పారు...

What happened was the computer came along. And since every manager had to have a computer for other reasons, it made sense to make him type his own damn letters and reports. And he could do it, because unless typing, where every mistake must be painfully corrected on paper, a mistake on computer can redone with pushing another key.

All this happened because paper got replaced. No more file cabinets. No more mailings. And advances in phone technology meant you no longer needed someone "answering the phones". The big bosses needed someone to screen their calles. Everyone else just answered their own phones.

BTW, unsaid in the article was that zillions of bank clerks lost their jobs. ATMs and Credit cards replaced checks and the need to "go to the bank" and deposit your checks and get cash.

When I first stated in the 80s, our head Admin had to go around every two weeks on friday and hand out the payroll checks!

Known Unknown చెప్పారు...

" I don't need a secretary to coordinate a meeting when I can pop open a meeting planner and see when everyone is available. Within what, 30 seconds, the meeting is scheduled."

30 seconds? Finding time when everyone is available takes me at least 5 minutes of trial and error.

RCOCEAN II చెప్పారు...

Feminism didn't lead to women going into middle management. Did "Feminism" show up with a gun?

Big Business wanted to promote women. It was a way to expand the labor pool and keep down wages. And a way for Middle and upper management to get that cutie an office next to them, instead some guy who might be competition.

RCOCEAN II చెప్పారు...

And a lot of old white guys in upper management loved the idea of "Pulling up the ladder" and promoting some young woman who reminded them of their daughter.

boatbuilder చెప్పారు...

Oh fer chrissakes! Anybody who thinks that calling typist/receptionists "secretaries" was some massive campaign of deception probably thinks that calling garbagemen "sanitation engineers" is somehow unfair to garbagemen who were misled into believing they'd be working with slide rules and clipboards.

boatbuilder చెప్పారు...

What sort of people do the feminists/socialists think will be the childcare providers that every woman who is a mother is entitled to?

Here's a hint: Not men.

What do they think these child care providers should be paid?

Here's a hint: Less than the "working women" whose children they are taking care of.

How does this work, exactly?

gilbar చెప్పారు...

a college degree used to be (seen as) a golden ticket to ride..
NOW, the MAJORITY of degrees go to women..
so NOW,
businesses are no longer concerned with crap like college degrees

Tell your sons to learn to weld.
(mobile welding repair is almost IMPOSSIBLE to automate)
Tell your daughters to learn to cook and be supportive.
and watch the grandkids roll in..

OR!
tell your children to be queer! and study genderstudies!
and watch the world pass you all by

The Future BELONGS to Those Who Show Up

gilbar చెప్పారు...

note: this is gilbar agreeing when
RCOCEAN II said...
"..a way for Middle and upper management to get that cutie an office next to them, instead some guy who might be competition..
..And a lot of old white guys in upper management loved the idea of "Pulling up the ladder" and promoting some young woman who reminded them of their daughter.."

here's a FUN THOUGHT!
mentors..
ever notice how the mentor was ALWAYS an older guy?
and the the mentoree was ALWAYS an attractive young girl?

has ANY ONE EVER heard of a female mentor? or a male mentoree?
i'm seriously asking? there MUST have Some.. but i NEVER saw them

n.n చెప్పారు...

RAAT is a forward-looking backward doctrine.

Lem Vibe Bandit చెప్పారు...

Secretaria — Mocedades

Secretaria
La que no habla
Siempre atenta
Diciendo nada

Te firmé mis veinte años
Te ayudé a subir peldaños
Y entre copa y copa me hice necesaria
Y al negarme a ser amable
Me ignoraste y sólo fuí tu secretaria

Big hit song released in 1975.

ai answers : Sí, 1975 fue el Año Internacional de la Mujer, proclamado oficialmente por la Asamblea General de las Naciones Unidas.

tcrosse చెప్పారు...

A secretary is not a toy. Her pad is to write in and not to spend the night in.

Ambrose చెప్పారు...

The media’s constant need to spin everything into an anti-Trump screed is exhausting

Christopher B చెప్పారు...

Glad to several comments about the lack of admin assistants being mostly a technology thing. It's been noted for at least two decades that Outlook turned most middle managers into glorified secretaries

Iman చెప్పారు...

“The media’s constant need to spin everything into an anti-Trump screed is exhausting”

It’s an unacceptable and irresponsible shirking of duty… a real disservice to the American people.

Lance చెప్పారు...

@Quaestor

"When the word appeared in English, secretary referred to the monarch's handler of encrypted communications"

Nope. https://talesoftimesforgotten.com/2020/03/21/no-secretary-does-not-mean-secret-keeper/

Oso Negro చెప్పారు...

Ride Space Mountain @ 10:43 - well said!!!

n.n చెప్పారు...

secretary(n.)

late 14c., secretarie, "person entrusted with secrets or private and confidential matters" (a sense now obsolete), from Medieval Latin secretarius "clerk, notary, scribe; confidential officer, confidant," a title applied to various confidential officers, noun use of an adjective meaning "private, secret, pertaining to private or secret matters" (compare Late Latin secretarium "a council-chamber, conclave, consistory"), from Latin secretum "a secret, a hidden thing" (see secret (n.)).
- etymonline.com

కామెంట్‌ను పోస్ట్ చేయండి

Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 4 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith. Also: No italics, even briefly. Use asterisks for emphasis. And don't play with the format by changing fonts or using boldface or all caps. Never include more than one extra line break between paragraphs.