March 16, 2026

"Ben sold out to get richer... that's it, end of!"/"These two bozos have made their fortune from Cookie Dough Icecream. And they think they have the ethical high ground?"

"He sold the company to get very very rich but he still wants control...."/"Mr Cohen you sold out, move on, use the money to campaign for your beliefs in other ways"/"They are bores. If they wanted to keep their progressive policies above the need for maximum profitability they should have retained ownership and never sold their business...."

The commenters are pretty much unanimous on the London Times article titled "Ben & Jerry’s founder attacks Peltz fund influence over Magnum/Ben Cohen steps up his feud with the ice-cream brand’s owner as a partner from the Trian hedge fund joins the Magnum board."

The legal dispute is the opposite of ice cream: "Magnum... has been accused of ousting directors on Ben & Jerry’s independent board, which was established to control its social mission when Cohen and Greenfield sold the business to Unilever for $326 million in 2000.... Cohen.... described the recent Ben & Jerry’s board changes as 'a blatant violation of the legally binding agreement put in place over 25 years ago to ensure the brand’s values would always be protected.'"

75 comments:

Peachypeachy said...

Crappy tasting mass made ice cream. The sell out occurred a long time ago.

Aggie said...

It's the standard Progressive playbook: If bullying doesn't work, throw a tantrum. If tantrums don't work, mobilize the mob. If the mob doesn't work, deploy the violent actors salted into the mob, and rely on the sympathetic press for additional cover.

narciso said...

nelson is just not willing to tolerate guff,

rehajm said...

Those two Vermont gas station dooshbags are still at it? Their expiration date is from the previous century. For once the comment section in the newspaper have it right. Spot on…

Marcus Bressler said...

They're boring and inconsequential

Bob Boyd said...

LOL. What's a gas station dooshbag?

Big Mike said...

@Bob Boyd, if you don’t know, then count your blessings and don’t ask.

n.n said...

Ethics is the theory of moral relativity. Very Pro-Choice.

Big Mike said...

For myself, wife and I have not bought Ben & Jerry’s in decades. I wasn’t aware it was still being sold.

rehajm said...

LOL. What's a gas station dooshbag?

…those two schmendricks started their ice cream grift in an old gas station. A few of the early Ben and Jerry’s shops copied the idea. It was part of their common man shtick…

n.n said...

Ben transitions, again.

Josephbleau said...

Never met a New Englander who did not believe it was his God given duty to tell everyone how to run their lives. Not attractive. If you have a contract then sue, don’t bother everyone else with it.

Paul Zrimsek said...

Let be be finale of seem, Ben.

Paddy O said...

Seems like if it was in the contract there is a problem. But the main reason they have to speak out is to maintain their social score among their peers.

ChrisC said...

Mainly it is not very good ice cream. I am not sure how the brand survives. Hagen Das and Blue Bell are vastly superior. My memory of B&J is that it is way too sweet and doesn't taste "creamy".

Iman said...

Try our new Chicken Fat Ripple or Lasagna Chip flavors!

rehajm said...

If I get a box Graeter’s Black Raspberry shipped to the house I usually get lucky…

R C Belaire said...

We toured the B&J "plant" some years ago (Waterbury VT I believe) and observed that about 1/4 of the product coming off the line ended up on the floor or else overflowed its container. Quality control was not on the menu...

Iman said...

Straus Family Creamery Organic ice cream is among the best I’ve tasted.

Howard said...

I always thought Unilever sold Venetian Blinds.

PM said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Howard said...

Nothing's more progressive than mass marketing one of the most successful obesity and diabetes delivery systems to the masses.

Bob Boyd said...

A unilever is a one speed with a stick shift.

narciso said...

he offered to buy disney, but he knew it's beyond recovery

narciso said...

the Hamas Hazelnut was not a big winner,

Peachypeachy said...

There’s still a Ben and Jerry’s on the Pearl street mall in boulder. I never never ever go in there. As a matter of principle.
There is a local ice cream chain that makes superior tasting ice cream. One of their rotating flavors is amaretto.
I always skipped it., until one day I tried it. Pass out delicious.

lgv said...

This happens now and again. They sold out, but still think it is their company. They don't care if their politics drive customers away, it has no impact on their wealth. If they want the brand to project their personal political beliefs, it's a free market. They can just buy the company back. Else, they need to distance themselves from the brand name.

In my mid-life I was a turnaround guy. Founders need/want money. Another corporation buys controlling interest or even 100%. Founders remain in some capacity. They then don't like new management's direction and start acting like they still own the company. Instead they become counter-productive and make a mess. I was the guy that got hired to clean up the mess.

Howard said...

Bert Cooper quote from Mad Men: "We took their money, now we have to do what they say."

RCOCEAN II said...

Never could understand the success of their ice-cream which was marketed as some sort of scrappy, cutting edge ice cream as opposed to the corporate brands like B/R or Haggen Daz.

Ice cream for liberals. LOL.

RCOCEAN II said...

Anyway, their ice cream seems popular - but not with anyone I know. As for their progressive politics, weren't they involved in some weird squabble over Ice cream in Israel? They were banned, or they refused to sell their Ice Cream there, or something.

RCOCEAN II said...

Had some Haggen-Daaz "Rum Raisin" last night and it was delish.

Yancey Ward said...

He wanted to have his ice cream and eat it too.

Wince said...

Ben & Jerry's participation in the "financialization of everything" results in a fight over a tired old brand? Film at eleven.

Enigma said...

They use roughly the same ingredients as Haagen-Dazs (mock Danish) and Talenti (mock Italian), but serve it up with embedded politics.

Vote with you wallet. Per a Google Search, here are some 'political' flavors:

Justice ReMix'd (2019): Cinnamon and chocolate ice cream with cinnamon bun dough and spicy brownies, supporting criminal justice reform.

Change the Whirled (2021): Non-dairy sunflower butter-based flavor created with Colin Kaepernick to support racial justice.

Pecan Resist (2018): Released to "resist" the Trump administration's agenda, supporting organizations focused on inclusivity, gender equality, and civil rights.

Change is Brewing (2021/2022): Cold brew coffee flavor highlighting the importance of Black voters and supporting Black Voters Matter.

Empower Mint (2016): Peppermint ice cream with fudge brownies to advocate for voting rights and campaign finance reform.

Bernie’s Yearning (2015/2020): A custom flavor created to support Bernie Sanders' presidential campaigns, featuring a chocolate disk representing wealth inequality.

Yes Pecan! (2009): A nod to Barack Obama's "Yes We Can" campaign, with proceeds going to the Common Cause Education Fund.

Aggie said...

Second the 'Graeter's'. Kroger used to carry it nationwide (both are based in Cincinnati) but they've stopped doing it, now.

Peachypeachy said...

Circa early 1990s . A bf and I loved New York super fudge chunk. I think that was back when it was still good and not sold.
Over a decade later (?)… bought some. It was not the same.

More Trans Rage Communist Crunch.
Resist! Rage! Righteousness!

Jupiter said...

Seize the means of production!

mccullough said...

Champagne Socialists.

gilbar said...

surprisingly, yet Another Lazy Millionaire Socialist, that wants the benifits of capitalism while complaining about capitalism

Old and slow said...

Not a fan of the politics, but Cherry Garcia is one of the best flavors of ice cream I have ever had. I rarely eat ice cream these days, but I used to practically live on the stuff.

Scott M said...

Ice Cream Cohen?

narciso said...

oh yes Valenti, specially their caribbean coconut,

Eva Marie said...

Thrifty ice cream cone: 5 cents a scoop. Best ice cream ever. No politics.

Leon said...

You sold to Unilever. Try looking up what they did in Congo in the 1940s and then talk about moral high ground. Hint it wasn't good.

bagoh20 said...

I love ice cream, but I have always avoided this brand specifically because of the politics. I have alternatives. I usually buy cheaper brands and look for less sugar, but when I spend, I like Talenti. It's good, and I justify the expense to get the excellent reusable containers, which are clear and durable. I have that container obsession, which there isn't a word for yet, but I know others have it.

Iman said...

He’s a boomer, too, gilbar@11:34AM…

KILL!!!

MadisonMan said...

I will third Graeter's Black Raspberry. I used to get it in Madison, but Metcalfe's stopped carrying it.

I don't want to live someplace where B&J is the best option, that's for sure. I'll take UDF any day over B&J. Or any local ice cream in Madison. Hooray for Purple Door, too, in Milwaukee.

Another old lawyer said...

I still indulge in Pumpkin Cheesecake, limited edition at the end of the year, but I feel guilty about it for more than one reason.

tim maguire said...

Paddy O said...Seems like if it was in the contract there is a problem.

Given the amount of time that's gone by, I'd be surprised if it's a problem, even with a contract. And is Ben the right person to try to enforce that clause? He sold long ago; what's his standing argument?

Mary Beth said...

If it's in the contract, he's got a legal avenue to pursue. No need to try to make it everyone's business.

My ice cream of choice is Kroger's Private Selection English Toffee Caramel Ice Cream. I did buy some B&J's not too long ago because it was at a really good sale price. It's not as good as I remembered (or has gotten worse in the years since I've had it) and I won't buy it again.

There's a Graeter's ice cream parlor near me. Unfortunately (or fortunately for my waist) it's far enough away to make it unlikely for an impulse trip.

Steven Wilson said...

Never met a New Englander who did not believe it was his God given duty to tell everyone how to run their lives. Not attractive. If you have a contract then sue, don’t bother everyone else with it.

You can always tell the English,
You can always tell the Dutch,
You can always tell a Yankee
But you cannot tell him much.

Ann Althouse said...

I buy McConnell’s vanilla.

boatbuilder said...

Ben & Jerry's--crappy ice cream with a whole lot of candy mixed in. Plus really stupid politics.

Joe Bar said...

Cohen, Greenfield, and Peltz? And they're fighting with each other? Way to break stereotypes.

Charlie Eklund said...

Interesting. I was not allowed to comment unless I allowed cookies. On an ice cream post. Madness. Anyway.

I am a died in the wool Blue Bell man. When inviting obesity and diabetes, why not eat only the best? That being said, Tom Thumb ran a BOGO Free last week on Tilamook. I chose Salfy Caramel Pretzel and Pistachio Almond. That taste is great but the texture is most off-putting. Too creamy. WAY too creamy. Back to Blue Bell.

What was I thinking? Oh, as for Ben & Jerry’s, I decided to avoid them as soon as I hear Ben and Jerry speak, back in the ‘80s, i think. No, I thought. No money for them, ever.

Sydney said...

I had some Ben and Jerry's ice cream last week. It had been years since I had some. I was very disappointed. Terrible tasting. We usually have a brand called Edy's at our house, which tastes much better, but our favorite is from an ice cream stand called Handel's.

Indefinitely Extended Excursion™️ said...

Ben & Jerry should never have sold out. what were they expecting when they brought UL on board? When you bring outside shareholders it's no longer your company anymore by definition.

Jerry Greenfield has tried to have it both ways for years: Adults cannot have it both ways. Time has run out for Mr. Greenfield.

Can't have it both ways. Everyone knows the path multinational conglomerates must and/or do as a well-educated and sophisticated veteran businessman had to know that before he took the money.

He took the money.

Fred Drinkwater said...

My collection of Talenti jars is ... oddly extensive. That's the nice way to put it.

Fred Drinkwater said...

This kerfuffle is hilarious. A thing I used to hear about all the time, was how some conservative's targeted endowed fund had its goals mysteriously shifted leftward, sometimes extremely so, after the founder's death.
Kind of a shoe on the other foot story.

Fred Drinkwater said...

Lapperts, Mariannes, Caravaggio. Ice creams worth a trip.

Tim said...

Boards are never independent. They answer to the stockholders, or are supposed to, and if Ben and Jerry's had board members who put something other than the stockholders first, then they needed to be ousted, and fast.

RCOCEAN II said...

Talenti is good. Like their pistashio whatever. Noticed most ice cream brands are getting more and more "cookie like". Lots of chocolate and uber-sweet stuff. Like eating a frozen candy bar. Don't know whats going on with that. Maybe young people like it.

Oshbgosh said...

Imagine that! A contract did not survive a second change of corporate ownership. Nobody ever heard of the current owners, so good luck bullying them.

Howard said...

I remember when you could only get McConnell's Ice Cream from a tiny shop on upper Mission Street in Santa Barbara. They used to have a waxy texture issue because of the extremely high milk fat content. I haven't tried it since. I noticed it was selling in the big chain super mercados in New England about a year or so ago.

Oshbgosh said...

Cedar Crest (Manitowoc Wi) Midnight Dark Chocolate is my go to favorite.

Howard said...

Marianne's in Santa Cruz is not elite elite, but they have more flavors than Pantone has colors

TickTock1948 said...

Howard, I grew up in Santa Barbara and remember that McConnells Ice Cream store very well.

Aggie said...

I like Graeter's because it's full-fat ice cream. Some of the gelatos too, but in general, ice creams have been compromised by losing a good bit of their dairy fat, cranking up the sugar content way too high, and trying to sneak polymers into the mix. The polymers give the sensation similar to that of natural creaminess, but they are different to the tongue than dairy fat. They do the same thing with these polymers in salad dressings and sauces - they artificially thicken and help strengthen emulsions. Once you pinpoint it, it's something you can no longer 'not notice', it has a particular feel. Xanthan gum, guar gum, HC Polymer, Arrowroot, cornstarch, carrageenan - all of these things, once subjected to hydration and high shear, turn extremely thick. They're cheap, and so is sugar.

There was an outrageous example of this a few years ago with Walmart ice cream bars, chocolate covered vanilla 'ice cream' on a stick, that were so fake, they didn't melt when left out in the sun.

Hassayamper said...

our favorite is from an ice cream stand called Handel's.

We have a Handel's in Scottsdale. Very nice, but we also have Sweet Republic, which is even better and more adventuresome. You can get the usual flavors but you can also get ice cream made with blue cheese, peaberry, oregano, porcini, durian, taro root, or maple syrup and bacon, among dozens of others, depending on what they feel like making. I have very rarely been disappointed when trying some exotic new flavor of stuff that doesn't seem like it should be a dessert at all.

Hassayamper said...

Never met a New Englander who did not believe it was his God given duty to tell everyone how to run their lives.

There's a straight line that runs from Rev. Jonathan Edwards and the Puritan theocracy through the temperance crusaders, anti-nuclear fanatics, "Sandalistas", to today's purple-haired cancel-culture shriekers.

mongo said...

Charlie, I agree about Blue Bell but it’s not available where I live. We really like Tillamook because of the cream which is missing from so many other brands. It’s expensive but worth it for us.

Tom T. said...

"I wasn’t aware it was still being sold."

It is in fact the top-selling brand in the United States.

Iman said...

“Howard, I grew up in Santa Barbara and remember that McConnells Ice Cream store very well.”

I don’t know about their shops, but what McConnells markets in grocery stores has a number of ingredients most would rather not see in premium ice cream, IIRC.

Iman said...

Ann Althouse said...
“I buy McConnell’s vanilla.”

Straus Vanilla Bean is the closest to homemade (churned in salted ice) taste that I’ve come across.

Also, those Handel shops are spreading across SoCal like gangbusters. Excellent ice cream!

Fred Drinkwater said...

Just thought I'd mention it hit 85° F on the sun side deck today.

Post a Comment

Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 2 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith.