22 మార్చి, 2026

"A defibrillator delivers up to 1,000 volts to a patient’s heart; inmates executed by electric chair typically receive about 2,000."

"A typical lightning strike, by contrast, transmits 100 million volts or more. But lightning races through the body in milliseconds, and therefore often spares it. Some people... recall the moment vividly.... the flash of light whiting out all vision; the sound, which many survivors say is the loudest they’ve ever heard. The pain, for some, is excruciating, yet others feel no pain at all. 'It felt like adrenaline, but stronger,' one survivor reported. 'I felt an incredible pulsing,' another said, 'a burning sensation from head to toe.'... [Afterwards, f]orgetfulness, sleep problems, sexual dysfunction, and headaches that manifest as intense pressure—like 'my eyeballs are just popping out,” one person told me—are common. Some people become hypersensitive to noise; others lose their hearing entirely. A few, almost miraculously, are freed of a prior ailment: a bad leg healed; vision, once impaired, restored.... Some have to relearn simple things, things they’ve done their whole life—how to read, how to sing, how to ride a bike.... One woman told me she often feels as though water is running down her limbs.... Inexplicable odors can emerge; food can taste like cardboard or glue...."

From "What 100 Million Volts Do to the Body and Mind/The odds of being struck by lightning in America in a given year are one in 1.2 million. How does the experience reorient a person’s sense of chance, of fate?" (The Atlantic)(gift link).

45 కామెంట్‌లు:

Tom T. చెప్పారు...

I'm not an engineer, so I may have this totally wrong, but I thought it was current that killed you, not voltage.

Zavier Onasses చెప్పారు...

That is what my Daddy, who was an electrical engineer, used to tell us. So, yes.

Zavier Onasses చెప్పారు...

Another interesting fact, alternating current tends to travel predominantly on the surface of a conductor.

Dave Begley చెప్పారు...

Lee Trevino got hit by lightning on a golf course.

Dave Begley చెప్పారు...

Diane Arbus-like photos.

Dave Begley చెప్పారు...

What are the odds?

“Golf Hall of Famer Lee Trevino was struck by lightning three times in his life, most notably at the 1975 Western Open, where he suffered severe spinal injuries requiring multiple surgeries. Despite his career nearly ending and facing long rehabilitation, he returned to win the 1984 PGA Championship, often joking about the incidents.”

RCOCEAN II చెప్పారు...

Like Mr. Begley my immediate thought was Lee Trevino, one of the most famous survivors of being hit by lightning. Trevino took years to recover, and finally came back and won Golf tournements, but y'gotta wonder what he would've done if he hadn't been hit.

I remember when I first went to Memphis I got varying advice on thunderstorms. Get under a tree. No avoid trees, they attract lightning. Stay in your car. No get out of your car, its metal is a conductor. Somehow I stayed alive.

imTay చెప్పారు...

Had a high school friend who got struck by lightning during marching band practice. He said that everything tasted burnt, and he grew five inches over a few weeks.

Wilbur చెప్పారు...

I reside in South Florida, the lightning capital of the world.

Oops, my BFF Gemini tells me Florida is not the lightning capital of the world:
"While somewhere in Florida is often the lightning capital of the United States, it is not the most struck place in the world.

Lake Maracaibo, Venezuela is considered the lightning capital of the world, with an average of 233 lightning strikes per square kilometer per year, according to NASA."

Gerda Sprinchorn చెప్పారు...

Tom T called this.

Volts hurt, but amps kill. You need a significant amount of actual electrons flowing through you to kill you.

This writer is being dishonest by comparing the voltage of a defibrillator to the electric chair. The writer probably knows this, so it is probably intentional dishonesty. I've seen this dishonesty before.

https://letstalkscience.ca/educational-resources/stem-in-context/do-amps-or-volts-kill-you

Gerda Sprinchorn చెప్పారు...

"Household static shocks, for example, are very high frequency and have a very short duration. According to LiveScience.com, it’s possible to generate up to 25,000 volts by dragging your feet across a carpet, though the voltage of a typical carpet shock between a few hundred to a few thousand volts. People can typically feel static at 2000 volts. Either way, household static shocks are almost always harmless. Most of the shocks that electrocute people are at a much lower frequency, a much longer duration, and have more energy creating a much more significant driving force."

https://transforming-technologies.com/esd-q-a/are-static-shocks-a-health-risk/

Christopher B చెప్పారు...

There's a blogger, Laughing Wolf IIRC, who was struck by lightning as well.. Years ago and he still has health issues that he posts about from time to time

Bob Boyd చెప్పారు...

Sounds terrible, but not as bad as the Covid Vaccine.

Aggie చెప్పారు...

Wasn't Lee Trevino the guy that joked about holding his club up during a lightning storm, proclaiming that 'even God can't hit a 1 iron' ?

There was a forest ranger that was hit more than a half-dozen times during his career, one of them welded up the zipper on his pants. I've never been hit, but I've been close enough to feel that last second static charge buildup on my face, tingling, then POW !, close. Scary.

Ampersand చెప్పారు...

The photos heighten the feeling of strangeness, the sense that victims are other.
Fun facts: Ninety percent of lightning strike victims survive. Eighty percent of the victims are male.
Thanks for the gift link. It's nice that The Atlantic still occasionally prints something unrelated to politics.

Heartless Aztec చెప్పారు...
ఈ కామెంట్‌ను రచయిత తీసివేశారు.
Heartless Aztec చెప్పారు...

On a manual labor job site in 1972-ish my best buddy Richard grabbed a long metal lever to close a flue on an outside chimney that burned - pre EPA - industrial solid waste. At that exact moment a lightning strike hit the top of the brick chimney traveled down and through his body and then blowing him about 10'-15' away where he landed in a heap all awhoo. We rushed expecting to find a cooked dead person. Instead of dead he hopped right up completely unharmed and we all went "Sheeeit" and finished out our work day - no fuss no muss. We still laugh about it in awe and wonder.

FredSays చెప్పారు...

Aggie, “one of them welded up the zipper on his pants”. The ultimate cringe.

Bob Boyd చెప్పారు...

My cousin got struck by lightening. It hurt like hell, but cured him of a stubborn tape worm. The critter didn't die, but left in a hurry to seek its fortune elsewhere.

Lawnerd చెప్పారు...

My father in law worked as a mail carrier. He had been struck by lightning three times. When I was dating my wife and before a one week long camping trip she and I were going on my father in law to be told me that before you get hit by lightning all the hairs on your arm stand up. During the camping trip we encountered one of the strongest thunder storms I ever experienced. Of course I felt all of my hairs standing up as I lay awake. My wife to be tried to snuggle in because of the storm and I suddenly got the idea that maybe being hit by lightning was genetic, some having a genetic basis for making them more likely to attract lightning. So as she started squirming closer I started squirming away. I think we did five circuits of the tent floor before I relented to her advances.

David53 చెప్పారు...

Lee Trevino is still alive at 86. What a life that guy has lived.

Ann Althouse చెప్పారు...

"What are the odds? 'Golf Hall of Famer Lee Trevino was struck by lightning three times in his life....'"

It's ridiculous to talk of the odds of people in general when speaking of the odds of a golfer. A golfer is exposing himself in the open landscape. His odds are different.

I think a pro golfer is more likely to go out even if there are predictions of thunderstorms... and yet I know they get SUVs out there quickly to pick them up if there really is a thunderstorm. The spectators must walk all the way off the course and back to their car to take shelter. I know this from personal experience.

Bob Boyd చెప్పారు...

Conspiracy theorists are more likely to be struck by lightening. It's because of the hats.

James K చెప్పారు...

I remember reading that if you are literally struck by lightning, you're a goner. The survivors are the near misses.

Gerda Sprinchorn చెప్పారు...

Golfers are a dedicated lot and play the odds. The odds of getting struck by lightning if you stay on the course in an electrical storm are maybe 1 in 10 ... 1 in 5 tops if the course is treeless. They figure its worth it.

RCOCEAN II చెప్పారు...

1991 U.S. Open (Hazeltine): A spectator was killed and others were injured while seeking shelter under a tree, notes The Globe and Mail.
1991 PGA Championship (Crooked Stick): A spectator died after being struck while walking to their car, as reported by The Globe and Mail.

Lucien చెప్పారు...

By way of comparison, the odds of a black American being shot dead by the cops while unarmed are about one in two million (according to the WaPo data set).

john mosby చెప్పారు...

It's frightening. Better knock on wood!

https://youtu.be/XKuJUxGntRI?si=mk6rWOZTE8oTAg39

CC, JSM

Fred Drinkwater చెప్పారు...

Gerda, worth it ... If and only if you're 2 under par, or better.

Fred Drinkwater చెప్పారు...

"Ordinary" static sparks can be painful and damaging, if the air is dry enough. NASA missions in arctic areas, where the air is dry, and even dryer once warmed to livable temps, had to take all sorts of precautions.

Gerda Sprinchorn చెప్పారు...

Fred:

I was in a foursome when one player was struck by lightning. Luckily, he didn't die, but it messed up the rest of the round for us. He was struck on the 12th fairway, and he kept falling out of the cart whenever we were on a green.

Quayle చెప్పారు...

Gerda, you were lucky. I had the same experience, but we were walking, not in carts. We had to take turns dragging our friend Jim for the remaining 12 holes. .

Vonnegan చెప్పారు...

My first real job I worked for a man who had been struck by lightning and hit by a bus. Either a very lucky or unlucky man, depending on your perspective.

Joe Bar చెప్పారు...

My wife was hit, or a near miss, about 30 years ago. It really messed up her head for a while, and almost cost us the marriage. Menopause cured her.

Enigma చెప్పారు...

Amateurs talk about strategy while pros talk about logistics.

Amateurs talk about 'bullets' when they mean 'cartridges.'

Amateurs talk about volts while pros talk about current.

Earnest Prole చెప్పారు...

Man Killed by Bolt From Clear Blue Sky
ABC News, July 1, 2001
Island Beach State Park, New Jersey

A bolt of lightning came out of a blue sky Saturday, striking two beachgoers who were tossing around a football.

One of the young men was killed in what meteorologists said was a rare but not unprecedented weather event. Steven McCarthy, 22, of East Windsor, N.J., could not be revived with CPR or a defibrillator. He was pronounced dead at 2:15 p.m. His friend Daryl Kobeski, 23, of Princeton, was also struck but not severely injured.

The two were enjoying the hot, sunny day when the lightning hit. It was a wild bolt thrown out by a storm a few miles off shore. Anthony Gigi, a National Weather Service meteorologist in Mount Holly, said lightning can strike even when skies are clear. "If you're close enough to hear thunder, then you're close enough to be struck by lightning," Gigi told The Sunday Asbury Park Press of Neptune. "That's pretty much the rule of thumb we follow."

At the time of the lightning strike, the park administrator was nearby in a patrol vehicle. "I thought it was an explosion. It sounded like a bomb" said park superintendent William Vibbert. "Then I saw Steven on the ground." National Weather Service meteorologist Dean Iovino told The Sunday Star-Ledger of Newark that there was nothing either the lightning strike victims or park officials could have done. The swimming area of the park was closed for the day after the fatality. Bob Marshall, who has worked at the park since the beach there opened in 1959, said this was the first time he's heard of lightning striking a person there. Lightning continued sporadically for the rest of the afternoon at the beach.

Megaera3 చెప్పారు...

Gerda, Quayle: that old joke, "Yeah, the whole way back to the clubhouse it was just Hit and drag Harry, Hit and drag Harry"...

Anthony చెప్పారు...

Oddly/interestingly, the electric chair used to be used with two shocks, thinking they'd make sure they'd finished the job. Unfortunately, it often happened that the first shock would stop the heart, but the second shock, analogous to a defibrillator, would start it up again.

Amexpat చెప్పారు...

The brother of a girl I knew in High School got killed by lightning while golfing, which as pointed out in a previous comment shortens the odds.

I was in a thunder storm in the woods at night. It was raining heavy and the sound and light were simultaneous. There was an ozone smell after each strike. I was scared but thought that my chances would be better if the lightening hit me off the ground, so that I wouldn't be grounded. So I was skipping back to my tent. I found out later that being mid-air doesn't help.

boatbuilder చెప్పారు...

Well it is estimated that Lee Trevino has made 30 to 40 holes in one over the course of his career. So he was 10 times more likely to make a hole in one than to be struck by lighting.
So the way I figure it the odds of my making a hole in one are a lot higher than my getting struck by lighting.
Thus, my odds of getting struck by lightning are damn near zero.
(yeah, yeah--if I was a logical person I would have quit golfing a long time ago).

boatbuilder చెప్పారు...

I did play golf a couple of years ago riding a cart with a guy who survived a lightning strike (on the ninth hole). He was pretty messed up and smoked weed (prescription weed!) throughout the round, and had only limited use of one leg. I only met him the day we played, but his buddies joked that he was worse before he got struck.

boatbuilder చెప్పారు...

I should clarify that the guy was struck on the ninth hole several years previously, not while he was playing with me.

Jim at చెప్పారు...

Oh ... rat farts!!!!

gilbar చెప్పారు...

i walk (a LOT, up and down hills to try to keep losing weight)
at a county park near me. I walk there a couple of times a week (and other parks other days).
One day, i'm walking along the path; and there are charred pieces of wood all along the trail.. which keep getting bigger and bigger until i get to the remains of a tree that got hit.
It looked like a Bomb had gone off inside the tree.
ALL that was left, was about 10 feet of jagged trunk.
The rest of the (formerly big) tree was either Gone, or sprayed along the trail.
It was clear that IF i'd been walking when it hit, i WOULDN'T have been hit by the lightning (the tree was 20 feet or so from the trail),
BUT; the shrapnel from the pieces of tree would have killed me dead.
i'm not sure which would be a worse way to die?
Lightning strike? or exploding tree?

Aggie చెప్పారు...

There's an area partly on my property, extending back into the woods that is, what the Old Timers call, a 'lightning road'. I suspect it's because the gravelly soil has a high iron content, judging from the materials. In any case, along this path - more or less a straight line - there is an inordinate number of old lightning-struck white oaks. Nearly all of them exhibit 10 - 20 ft trunks, of what were once quite large trees, ranging from 10" to 3ft diameter. There's at least a dozen of them, along a line probably 2/10 of a mile long. The trunks have all survived and sprouted new growth. The age of the strikes varies, by eye, but some of them are quite old, some within a couple of years. I have one trunk that bore a strike that pretty much killed everything but a circumference of bark 1/2 way 'round the trunk. The rest of the tree's core has slowly rotted over the years, propping up this stray bit of bark and a couple of medium sized limbs, all with vigorous growth. Nature is amazing.

కామెంట్‌ను పోస్ట్ చేయండి

Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 2 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith.