5 दिसंबर 2025

"Once a week, his maternal grandmother would come home from the market with a live carp... 'We’d put it in the bathtub... and I’d play with this fish for a day until she killed it and made gefilte fish.'"

From "Frank O. Gehry, Titan of Architecture, Is Dead at 96/He burst onto the scene with an attention-getting renovation of his Southern California home before going on to design some of the world’s most recognizable buildings" (NYT).
Like many Angelenos, he was drawn to the laid-back, anything-goes atmosphere of the city, whose mix of garish mansions, flimsy bungalows, vacant lots, Googie coffee shops and colorful billboards was the antithesis of East Coast architectural academicism. And he became close to a generation of Los Angeles artists... whose surfboard-inspired aesthetic and raw work spaces suggested an alternative to the chilly austerity of late Modernism and the reactionary tendencies of postmodernism.... “I was trying to use the dumb, normal materials of the neighborhood,” Mr. Gehry said years later. “There must have been half a dozen cars in various states of deconstruction sitting around on the lawns; there was chain link in people’s backyards. They thought that was normal.”

For more about the fish, see "Frank Gehry, Fish Lamps/Paul Goldberger traces the history of the fish form throughout Frank Gehry’s career" (Gagosian.com).

So Gehry turned to the fish, at least in part as a way of solving the dilemma that postmodernism presented for him. He may have been making jokes when he said that the fish—which he called “the perfect form”—represented the return to history that the postmodernists advocated, but he was absolutely serious about seeing it as an inspiration for a new way of making modern architecture that would be both more sensual and more geometrically complex than the conventional modernist box. The double curves of the fish form fascinated him. So did its delicate skeleton, light and graceful in itself. The fish, he said, offered “a complete vocabulary that I can draw from.” He had plenty of other inspirations for his work, of course, but nothing else seemed so cogent a summary of his aesthetic. And it gave Gehry, an architect who generally shied away from conventional forms, the opportunity to use one of the most familiar shapes there is, and make it his own. If the fish allowed Gehry to thumb his nose at historicism, it allowed him to do the same to critics who found his work too abstract, too unusual, or too distant from forms they recognized. No one could fail to recognize a fish....

26 टिप्‍पणियां:

Achilles ने कहा…

Reminds me of the time I had a young nephew in the car with us and we saw a bunch of hispanics driving the same way with a goat tied up in the back.

The nephew said "Oh look they got a new pet goat!"

Maynard ने कहा…

I used to eat Gefilte fish, growing up in a largely Jewish environment. I don't think it is made with carp, buy who nows.

It is great with a little horseradish.

I have not had it in decades. I will make a note to pick some up at the grocery store.

Maynard ने कहा…

I really hate autocorrect.

tcrosse ने कहा…

I recall some very large carp in Lake Mendota. Some anglers would use canned corn as chum for them. My dog liked to roll in their rotten corpses on the near east side beaches.

tommyesq ने कहा…

He designed a lot of buildings that look like a cubist painting, all weird angles and melty-looking structures, generally interesting for a few moments but not much longer. I would note that (a) the dorm he designed for MIT has had significant problems, enough that MIT sued him in 2007; and (b) the home that he designed for his own use is much more standard, meaning that he didn't want to live in the weird designs he foisted on others.

gspencer ने कहा…

Gehry has passed on?

Whew! No more of his hideous structures.

mccullough ने कहा…

Much of his work looks cartoonish. I don’t think public spaces should appeal to the warped wealthy

RCOCEAN II ने कहा…

IOW, instead of being good, he was different

Not Illinois Resident ने कहा…

The man did serious harm to the architectural profession, along with Michael Graves, Peter Eisenman, and the Darth Vader himself, Philip Johnson. If you think contemporary institutional architecture is ugly, you can thank these guys.

chuck ने कहा…

Gehry's buildings are fun to look at, but leaky. They are toys, not functional living spaces.

Political Junkie ने कहा…

Test

Political Junkie ने कहा…

I see my "test" comment posted. I had been unable to post for over a week. Was weird.

effinayright ने कहा…

Speaking of California, Diane Feinstein sleeps with the gefilte fish.

exhelodrvr1 ने कहा…

I was never allowed to take carps in the bathtub

RCOCEAN II ने कहा…

Go look at his design of the Walt Disney Concert Hall in LA. It may be a good design for the inside, but from the outside its a freakish monstronsity.

john ने कहा…

Visited Bilbao several times when our daughter lived there. We loved the Gugenheim, it is a beautiful structure from any angle (except perhaps from the inside, it's a modern art museum after all). As the centerpiece of Bilbao's redevelopment it accomplished amazing things for the city.

We have also attended concerts at the Walt Disney Hall, and in this case the inside is the best part. Acoustics and seating are fabulous.

john mosby ने कहा…

I went through ROTC at MIT Building 20, which was replaced by Gehry's work. Bldg 20 would probably still be standing today, even though it was a temporary ww2 construction. CC, JSM

KellyM ने कहा…

I worked at the MIT Media Lab (Building E19) from 2004 – 07, and would often find myself over at the Stata Center (the Gehry designed building) for meetings or other events. Within the Media Lab it was unaffectionately known as “The House That Jack Built”, given the way the thing curved and listed. And yes, it was drafty, leaky, and otherwise a thoroughly unpleasant building to spend time in.

In winter, water dammed up along the building edge above the underground parking garage so that if you were trying enter or exit you had to contend with large black ice patches on the ramps which were very dangerous. You slid down the ramp when entering, and when leaving you had to gun it to get over the ice to the point that you risked launching yourself into standing traffic in Vassar Street. It’s not surprising that a lawsuit was filed.

Readering ने कहा…

I work down the street from Disney concert hall and combined Conrad hotel and grand residences. Always enjoy stopping to take them in. Tourists likewise. He also designed a building for the Colburn music school going up a block away.

Kakistocracy ने कहा…

Legend.

Worth more than all the finance guys in a single pen stroke with a legacy that will outlast them to eternity.

I still remember crossing the bridge into Bilbao, and being suddenly overtaken by the magnificence of the Guggenheim shimmering in front of me. R.I.P Frank Gehry.

Lazarus ने कहा…

That fish story will go down in architectural history, whether or not it's actually true.

baghdadbob ने कहा…
इस टिप्पणी को लेखक द्वारा हटा दिया गया है.
baghdadbob ने कहा…

Style over function, not unlike Frank Lloyd Wright's aesthetically pleasing but impractical leaky flat roofs.

Anthony ने कहा…

Whew! No more of his hideous structures.

Ditto x 1000

PigHelmet ने कहा…

Sounds a lot like the Barbara Cohen story “The Carp in the Bathtub”—written as an illustrated children’s story, but I first encountered it in an anthology with the likes of Malamud, Isaac Bashevis Singer, and Saul Bellow. Strongly recommend.

Ampersand ने कहा…

I agree with Readering. Some of Gehry's structures, including the Disney Concert Hall, are quite beautiful.

एक टिप्पणी भेजें

Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 2 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith.