August 29, 2025

"You hear the term 'slop' a lot now. There’s a good reason for that: A lot of janky internet content is being churned out with A.I., and slop..."

"... is a handy name for this. But there’s another phenomenon—not unconnected, but a little different—that I also think it’s worth getting a handle on. I’ve been thinking about it as 'slurry.' In the non-metaphorical world, slurry means an unresolved mix of liquid and solid; in agriculture, a thin mixture of manure and water. The word comes to mind with this very pervasive kind of content that’s gunking up my feed, where different content types are running together into one, half-resolved substance. Where everything assumes the qualities of everything else. It’s painters having to perform incongruously as influencers to get some attention for their work. It’s audio interviews, auto-transcribed and posted without any editing so that you get not only weird errors but also all the 'you knows' and 'uhms.' It’s long video essays chopped up into little incoherent bits and posted with gibbering subtitles. What these have in common is a feeling of clunkiness that comes when something originated in one medium and hasn’t quite been thought through for another...."

Writes Ben Davis, in "The Great Enslurrification of Culture/Rosalind Krauss's 'post-medium condition' comes for writing, and everything" (ArtNet).

32 comments:

Enigma said...

The lesson of the last 20 years: "Truthy" Wikipedia was first, and it cannot be beaten by AI.

Achilles said...

The people who can proofread the slop will be fine.

I am teaching my kids how to use these tools. “Edit for clarity and grammar” is a great prompt.

It is the ability to compose you need to build. If you have an understanding of how to compose and organize your thoughts into words you can use LLMs to massively speed up the writing process.

It will generate material and you will need to edit it to keep it on track.

Editing the generated material is mostly deleting extra words I find. The LLMs like to add too much explanation and filler.

Wince said...

"Loves it. Eats it up. Eats the slop. Born to slop."

Iman said...

‘She said, "Sloppy"
She said, "Sloppy"
She said, "Sloppy, I think I missed the hole, hole, hole" ‘

Lazarus said...

He's not wrong, but he takes a while to get to the point, and seems like someone one would avoid talking to at parties. Outside of the art world, more people are probably familiar with what a "slurry" is before reading the article than have a firm grasp on what he means after reading it.

When everything comes to you in bits and bytes maybe the concept of "medium" itself has been superseded or sublated (a word I am using to appear more intelligent than I am).

Mr. D said...

Can you slurry, can you picnic, whoa?
Can you slurry, can you picnic?
Come on, come on and slurry down to a stoned soul picnic

rhhardin said...

It's not mixes but ai scripting and voicing. amusing though.

Tattycoram said...

I'm finding this unnerving--I just used the word "slurry" to describe the writing in a lousy new book filled with undigested factoids, thinking I was original.

Jaq said...

"Enshitification" was a fine word, no need to tweak it.

Achilles said...

Really all the LLMs are doing right now is allowing people who were plagiarizing before to have a new way to not do work.

The fundamentals of writing won’t change. It will just make increase the volume that both writers and plagarizers can produce material.

Jaq said...

Slop, slurry, mush, whatever. What is missing is the crystalizing power of human intelligence.

Jupiter said...

"gunking up my feed".
He has a feed?

Jaq said...

On the other hand, AI just read the manual for my car, and scanned the forums, and told me how to stop an annoying behavior by holding the off button down for three full seconds, instead of just pressing it, which only temporarily muted the radio, lying in wait, ready to spring at you at full volume, like Cato.

Aggie said...

Nothing's worse than slurrifying your words, especially during field sobriety tests.

Aggie said...

Who was it that made a career out of that kind of thing, was it Norm Crosby? He used to brag about his prodigious vocabulary and grasp of 'eight-cylinder words'.

rehajm said...

That’s not a slurry tanker that’s a honey wagon…

n.n said...

Generated, recycled slop or spam?

Temujin said...

Two quotes from the article stick out to me:

"As opposed to film, video felt so immediate and cheap and fluid that it tended to create art that was shapeless, deskilled,...".

"...the reality is that writing is in such a vulnerable state because it has already been so degraded by the wretched demands of the digital economy, which has primed the audience to treat it in such an expedient way."

I love that word, "deskilled". I think it nails the moment.

To my view the column author is right on target. We are awash in crap presented as 'must know, must have, must watch, must read'. And it's not just that much of it is crap, is that even the good stuff has mostly been infected with some of the crap. And all of it is cranked out at high volumes. It has altered what I read, the way I read, the way I write, and the way I think. All of it is so mixed up together and presented all at once that it gets exhausting just trying to pore through it all to get to anything you can grab hold of and have an 'Ah-ha!' moment where you think, at last...I'm learning something new and useful.
And I'm aware of it happening. Imagine entire generations unaware and growing up not knowing anything else?

Today I'm just at the point of considering pulling back from all of the online madness. Just considering it, mind you. That's how much it's become a part of my life. But seriously thinking about simply going back to spending my time reading all of the classics I had not yet read. Books I told my 20 year old self I would get to over the years. Which got put off during my hard working years, then became a goal to tackle once I retired.
Well...it's now or never time. So, yeah, I concur with what this guy is saying and I'm ready to pull the plug on all of it. I would say that 90% of what I now spend my time combing through is crap. I've become addicted to crap. And we're talking the supposedly high minded stuff. It's still crap. And it's time sucking crap.

john mosby said...

When I take you out in the slurry with the cringe on top....RR, JSM

boatbuilder said...

Who was it that made a career out of that kind of thing, was it Norm Crosby? He used to brag about his prodigious vocabulary and grasp of 'eight-cylinder words'.

"I resemble that remark!"

Howard said...

In actual practice, slurries increases communication by transporting solids via liquid conveyance. Construction and industry couldn't thrive without slurries.

wsw said...

Putting publishing (nearly all forms) into the hands of the user has led us into the golden age of amateur talent.

Enigma said...

@Howard: "In actual practice, slurries increases communication by transporting solids via liquid conveyance."

My question is whether AI generates non-Newtonian slurries such as oobleck. How does Newtonian AI differ from non-Newtonian AI?

Nancy said...

I'm surprised Althouse didn't wander off in search of the word "janky".

narciso said...

well there are a lot of ridiculous premises, many that are recycled here, but thats not the fault of AI, thats the fault of bad source code, when you have plenty of material, and yet
you some how manage to create something unlike the source (honestly how do you screw up the Smurfs) Charlton Heston raises fists,

Smilin' Jack said...

“The word comes to mind with this very pervasive kind of content that’s gunking up my feed, where different content types are running together into one, half-resolved substance.”

I don’t have a “feed”, whatever that is, but maybe I should get one. Sounds yummy.

narciso said...

after Jurassic World I gave up on that Franchise, this last iteration seems to be beating Marvel and DC properties but only in relative terms,

narciso said...

take Joel and Ethan Coen's latest product, Honey Don't it seems to have all the nihilism but none of the whimsy of their other offering, and yes much more nihilist then Fargo,

narciso said...

there a whole host of clever podcasts and others that are not,

Lazarus said...

I would love to read the two great poems Norm Crosby spoke about, "The Idiot" and "The Ostrich". Maybe AI will finally commit those epics to paper.

Joe R. said...

Books I told my 20 year old self I would get to over the years. Yeah, I've been signing up for online groups to read classics I've not read. It makes for a better time than focusing on all the slop and even things not produced by AI are served up by an algorithm meant to keep you enraged and stupid. On the other hand, ChatGPT and the like are wonderful for comedic effect -- "Re-write this email in the style of Marcel Proust and include a hint of repressed homosexuality." I used AI to clarify what I was communicating. I don't know why it produced that.

Biff said...

@Temujin - Excellent comment that captures my own thoughts, as well!

Post a Comment

Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 2 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith.