February 7, 2020

"I spent a great deal of time as a child on a tiny, uninhabited island off the west coast of Scotland. The island had no roads, houses or electricity..."

"... just a storm-blown, windy wilderness of sea birds and heather. My family and I would be dropped off like castaways on the island by a local boatman for the summer holidays and picked up again weeks later. While we were staying on the island, we had no way of contacting the outside world. Because there wasn’t any electricity, the house was lit by candlelight.... In the evenings, my father told me and my siblings tales of the Vikings who invaded the island 1,200 years before, of the quarrelsome ancient British tribes who fought each other and of dragons who were supposed to live in the caves in the cliffs of the island. That was when I first started writing stories about dragons and Vikings, way back when I was nine years old, by candlelight on that little island. These were the stories that later turned into 'How to Train Your Dragon.'"

From "To Save the Earth, We Should Teach Children the Magic of Nature/We must give children the opportunity to interact with the wilderness, so that they learn to preserve the natural world" by Cressida Cowell (NYT).

81 comments:

gilbar said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Kevin said...

White privilege.

JohnAnnArbor said...

Not many are able or could afford to do that.

mccullough said...

The earth is fine. We just need to save society from douchebags.

Bushman of the Kohlrabi said...

The house on the island that had no houses was lit by candlelight

mccullough said...

The candle factory was powered by electricity.

CJinPA said...

I spent a great deal of time as a child on a tiny, uninhabited island off the west coast of Scotland.

So did I! How come you never said Hi?

mccullough said...

How many trees were chopped down so that Yet-Another-Dragon Story Book could be manufactured?

MadisonMan said...

The house on the island that had no houses was lit by candlelight

My reaction also. Sounded like a pretty cheap vacation to me.

Paul Snively said...

It's true: the only way you can sell the modern environmental movement is to romanticize the loss of modernity.

Limited blogger said...

sweet story

Qwinn said...

"We must give children the opportunity to interact with the wilderness, so that they learn to preserve the natural world"

We had a great organization that did that. It was called the Boy Scouts of America. But because it (for a while, until it crumbled) attempted to "preserve the natural world" of heterosexual normalization, it had to be demonized and effectively destroyed.

Lewis Wetzel said...

But she isn't talking about the natural world, she is talking about her romantic vision of the natural world. That vision of the natural world is a human creation. People made it out of the vicious chaos of the natural world. It would not exist without us.
There is a BBC reality series called "1900 Island." Five families try their hand at living as welsh fishermen a little more than a hundred years ago. They labor very hard at dangerous work and are very poor, always on the edge of starvation.

FleetUSA said...

"a great deal of time"....odd weekends in the summer???

Yancey Ward said...

Yeah, I can see today's kids just loving a Summer without i-Phones and i-Pads.

rhhardin said...

Interacting with the wilderness gets old very fast as a kid.

Paddy O said...

One of my favorite places to camp, to get away, is the Channel Islands National Park. Five islands off the coast of Los Angeles up to Santa Barbara (there are more islands farther south, but they're Navy, and there's also Catalina, but that's its own thing).

Exactly what she is describing. Take a boat, get dropped off. A few of the Islands don't have any water on them, so you have to pack in your own. The other larger islands do, but there's no electricity to be sure, except for the research and ranger stations.

Really amazing.

Ranching took over most of these, almost completely decimating some. But they're recovering now. Some of the early ranchers talk about the struggle of these islands, they weren't made for ranching really. So I was going to mention that, but if you read stories about the families that grew up on Santa Rosa, or the experiences of the Chumash, they're really amazing.

The key, of course, is that they support a very, very limited human population at best. Which is not the rest of civilization.

Still an amazing place to visit, both in being there and in the journey out and back.

stlcdr said...

"To Save the Earth, We Should Teach Children the Magic of Nature/We must give children the opportunity to interact with the wilderness,..."

File this under 'No shit, Sherlock."

mikee said...

An appreciation of nature can be romantic or realistic, or even nihilist, but seeing a wild creature, feeling the sun, smelling the juices of a plant, realizing that some things bite and sting, embiggens the heart and makes cromulent the human appetites.

exhelodrvr1 said...

I'm guessing the family isn't "living off the land" for their summers, but bring three months of food with them. So it's not really experiencing nature.

Paddy O said...

My picture icon is from San Miguel island, a path in the middle of giant coreopsis plants

exhelodrvr1 said...

Paddy,
I spent a lot of time on San Clemente Island in the mid-90s on Navy dets, and did a lot of flying around the other Channel Islands. They are really neat.

Krumhorn said...

Great story. Terrible message and messenger.

It never fails to impress me when the lefties so smugly posture with their moral superiority....arms akimbo, jaw slightly elevated and angled off-center, and their beady eyes squinting into the distance with disdain.

- Krumhorn

Hagar said...

Around the coast of Norway there are quite a few islands like that, where the owners of the last houses remaining live in the summers and perhaps still do some farming and fishing, etc., but move ashore in the winters.

rcocean said...

NOtice she said "Weeks" not "Months" and "Summer" not "winter". And "no houses" does not mean "No permanent wooden shelter" with a raised floor to keep the rain out.

rcocean said...

It had A house, but not houses.

gspencer said...

When she and her family were living there, how could the island be considered uninhabited?

Earnest Prole said...

Since everything today leads to Trump, here’s an interesting piece on the tiny Scottish island of Tong, birthplace of Trump’s mother.

“Trump’s great-great grandfather (and Alexander’s father), Alasdair MacLeod, a fisherman born around 1810, was known by everyone as ‘Ruadh,’ or ‘Red,’ on account of his hair—perhaps the source of Trump’s own infamous mop (which was more reddish-brown than cornmeal yellow in his younger days). He explained that Lewis was part of Norway until the 13th century. ‘Red hair is very common on the islands,’ Lawson said. ‘Almost everyone in the island, you trace back their DNA [and] you come to a Viking.’

Dave said...

And you'd think the Sierra Club and the NRA would be natural allies. But, no, because so many organizations aren't about what they claim to be about. See Feminism Inc., for example.

Fernandinande said...

Here is some of the same text, plus pictures which make it look a bit civilized.

The 217 acre island is "Little Colonsay".

Skeptical Voter said...

Well if you are the daughter of a Viscount who owns the island, I guess you can stay there in the summer.

Paddy O said...

exhelodrvr1, that's so great! San Clemente is the one with a lot of Chumash history (Island of the Blue Dolphin). I think they even have resident archaeologists, and such, to help with the island history. I didn't quite get to joining the Navy for the experience, and now I'm too old (though I have a friend a bit older who signed on as a chaplain...). I bet they were great to see flying over them. I don't really have a big picture sense of what they're like.

The other islands have really recovered since the mid-90s, and really are a great place even for a day trip.

stevew said...

"We must give children the opportunity to interact with the wilderness, so that they learn to preserve the natural world"

Christopher McCandless did that, didn't work out so well for him. But what's stopping her?

Are these people displaying arrogance or hubris when they express their goal of saving the world?

Over several summers, late 60's to early 70's, my Boy Scout troop spent two weeks each year camping in NH. We had a base camp in Campton alongside the Pemigewasset river. The younger scouts would do day hikes and activities, the older scouts would do a couple of multi-day trips, usually in the mountains along the Presidential Range, through Franconia and the Flume, and other areas along the Kancamagus and AMC trails. We learned about the natural world, but also about teamwork, social skill, order & discipline (and its importance in survival), and various and sundry Scout skills.

Appreciating the natural world was a side benefit. I can still recall a sunrise from the top of Madison, just outside the hut there that is slightly below the summit. My buddy and I snuck out of bed early to see it.

HoodlumDoodlum said...

Bushman of the Kohlrabi said...The house on the island that had no houses was lit by candlelight

Beat me to it!

But: No Homer*s* Club

hstad said...

"Cressida Colwell" what you are advocating for is that human beings should go back to living in 'Caves' - LOL! You do know that the modern conveniences are the primary cause of a longer life span. If you try to take on 'Mother Nature' you will lose in the end. Just another B.S. story from the 'Climate' and 'Race Hustlers' of the NY Times.

Nonapod said...

I guess the island she's talking about is Little Colonsay and was fully owned by her father, a hereditary peer. Seems like she had an extrodinarily priviledged childhood.

Seeing Red said...

Institute what the green whackos want, most of we fodder/great unwashed Campbell Soup-eating proles will be using candles.

PM said...

When my kids were 7 and 4, we started an annual summer backpack in the Sierra Nevada to thin the trout population. Kids didn't like it at first, but they soon got it. They're outdoorsy adults. Made a lot of dumbass mistakes as a dad - that wasn't one.

Churchy LaFemme: said...

WP: In the early 20th century the island was farmed by John MacColum, known as "Johnny Colonsay", but he and his family were forced out by a plague of rats.

Sounds like my kind of vacation..

Mark O said...

There is no greater gift than to grow up in nature.

George Grady said...

If every child did that, those little islands would soon all be like Coney Island. Lots of people can't go to the wilderness, because if a lot of people go there, it's not the wilderness.

Steve from Wyo said...

It's called "Nature Deficit Disorder". See the writings of Richard Louv.

Narayanan said...

Hunting Party by Elizabeth Moon in Serrano series.

Bubbles Brun becoming a grown up.

William said...

I wonder what the sheep looked like. Those merino sheep have a soft, luxurious coat, but many men consider them kind of stuck up and standoffish.

Megthered said...

We took our grandchildren hiking and camping in Montana and Wyoming last summer. Along with their parents, we explained that we would be far from wifi, so no electronics. They didn't believe it, and were outraged when it turned out to be true. After a day or so it didn't matter to them. They were having too much fun to think of what they might be missing.

n.n said...

Conservation. Three is no need for empathetic appeals.

Nonapod said...

It seems to me that while that sort of experience may seem extremely wonderous for a kid at first blush, I know that as a kid I would have been bored to tears after a couple of days. I can say this because I experienced something not too disimilar to this when I was about 9 years old, although in my case it wasn't quite as isolated and for not quite as long.

And as an adult I have a healthy appreciation for nature. I certainly wouldn't want it corrupted by hoards of well intentioned eco tourists who are attempting to educate their brood on the wonders of the natural world.

AZ Bob said...

Good investigation, Nonapod.

Seeing Red said...

Wait. This is tourism and we’re supposed to stay put for the good of the earth.

Big Mike said...

No way to call for help if Someone was injured or very ill? Luckier than they deserved.

traditionalguy said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
traditionalguy said...

That sounds like one of the many Isles off the coast of NW Scotland that were long contested between the Norwegians and the Scottish Picts. Clan Donald was the longest reigning as Lord of the Isles. The Macdonald name is better know, but they started as branch of clan Donald. And our President is a McLean from the outer Hebides that were Viking settled.

chuck said...

I know that as a kid I would have been bored to tears after a couple of days.

Boats, rifles, tents, and kerosene lamps. What's not to like?

Nonapod said...

AZ Bob said...
Good investigation, Nonapod.


In fairness, my investigation consisted of going to her Wikipedia page, scaning the article and clicking on the link to her father, scanning that article and clicking on the link to the island. It took about 35 seconds for a confirmed Wikipedia addict like myself.

Ralph L said...

You wouldn't need many candles in the summer up there.

Leland said...

Do you think the NYT will do a story on the Boy Scouts and the opportunities to attend the High Adventure Camps?

AZ Bob said...

Nonapod, you did the work that the NY Times refused to do.

jimbino said...

The idea of letting kids out of the house to commune with Nature won't work with parents who don't let their kids out of the house to walk to the neighborhood park, probably because they'll be charged with child neglect or abuse. Because "Stranger Danger"!

BUMBLE BEE said...

Some friends of mine went wilderness back in the 70s. Dropped off in the wild they encountered clouds of mosquitoes and the bloodthirsty "deer flies"for the full time up there. They were set on toughing it out until the axe accident. Not much fun waiting out until their pickup. A theoretical was proposed on a blog awhile back. If you could transport a pioneer woodsman to today's environs do you think he would want to go back?

Howard said...

This is essentially John Muir's message at the dawn of the 20th century. We are all great beneficiaries of what transpired after his dream was realized.

Biff said...

I still remember my hardcore Sierra Club / NOLS college roommate ridiculing the Boy Scouts as Nazis until he started leafing through my old copy of the Boy Scout Fieldbook. He said, "Wow! This stuff is legit! I had no idea!" The cognitive dissonance was impressive.

BUMBLE BEE said...

While waiting in the marsh for the next flight of ducks I got a first hand look at "nature" from a unique perspective. I was up to my crotch in frigid waters, and all around me were creatures eating and being eaten. It carried on as we pulled up the decoys and headed to shore. I can't look at any "placid" image of nature without understanding the struggle of life taking place there.

tcrosse said...

Meadehouse is not too far from the spot of woods where John Muir used to camp out:
Muir Knoll, Madison

BUMBLE BEE said...

Of course the onshore breeze would suppress flying insects for the little darlings.

chuck said...

I can't look at any "placid" image of nature without understanding the struggle of life taking place there.

I have the same thought whenever I watch insects and spiders. Civilization disappears somewhere below a scale of one foot and nature red in tooth and claw prevails.

tcrosse said...

On the west coast of Scotland the kids would learn all the various and wondrous types of rain. Every damn day.

D 2 said...

-Nature is wonderful. Everyone deserves the chance to experience Nature in all her glory - some uncivilized “unmanaged” Wild Place that is off the grid and is moderately inaccessible and has an extremely low population density so you aren’t bumping into other people.
-Everyone has a right to affordable housing and universal education, in the geography of their choice, near to all the other government based services that are also positive rights, including mass communication devices and birth control.
-Diversity is strength. We must recognize the wide spectrum of human culture and gender and suchlike, and ensure that society is truly inclusive of us all, if not purposefully enabling of identified marginalized populations, so that we can see real human progress after centuries of institutionalize exploitation and degradation.
-There are too many of us and we are ruining this planet.
-From each according to ability, To each according to their need.
-Universal basic income.

After awhile, you might wonder how the prescriptions are all supposed to come together. But you do see what the common denominator is.

Left Bank of the Charles said...

"When she and her family were living there, how could the island be considered uninhabited?"

They were tourists.

n.n said...

Nature is wonderful and worth conserving, not preserving.

Planned Population (i.e. Pro-Choice/one-child and selective-child), or wicked solution, including reproductive rites, clinical cannibalism (e.g. redistributive parts), has been a progressive secular religious ambition since the early 20th century normalized by contemporary sects.

Diversity is a color judgment and affirmative discrimination that denies individual dignity, including racism, sexism, and other classes of bigotry.

There are too many high density population centers established through immigration rites and reform that are first-order forcing of catastrophic anthropogenic local climate change.

From each according... the people living in mansions near the ocean should share, right?

Universal basic income could work if it does not normalize progressive corruption of managers and recipients a la redistributive change. Perhaps they are contemplating a juxtaposition of public and private smoothing functions.

you might wonder how the prescriptions are all supposed to come together.

The Pro-Choice religion enables them to avoid reconciliation.

Marc in Eugene said...

Did you know, for example, that trees can communicate with each other through their roots, even when they are many miles apart?

Anyone know, off the top of his head, what she is going on about with that assertion?

tcrosse said...

Presumably if one of the kids get sick they can call in a helicopter for medevac, carbon be damned.

AllenS said...

I've been on many a trip to Canada fishing, where a plane will take you to a lake that only has one cabin on it. Every place has a large plywood triangle painted bright red. If you have an emergency place the triangle where it can be seen from afar. All pilots know where all of these cabins are, and if they see that triangle, even if it isn't their lake place, they will land to see what is wrong.

I would imagine they have the same setup at the uninhabitated island.

Joan said...

I'm just popping in - sorry! - to say I completely agree with the headline. I tried as hard as I could to provide that for my own children. I wish it were possible for everyone!

It's surprising and sad how many young people are afraid of nature and being out in the wild. It inhibits their understanding of the natural world and makes my job as a science teacher that much more challenging.

Beloved Commenter AReasonableMan said...

Joan said...
I'm just popping in - sorry! - to say I completely agree with the headline. I tried as hard as I could to provide that for my own children. I wish it were possible for everyone!
It's surprising and sad how many young people are afraid of nature and being out in the wild. It inhibits their understanding of the natural world and makes my job as a science teacher that much more challenging.


After all the odd hostility to the benign message of this post good to hear someone make the sensible case, even if I do personally believe that the only good spider is a dead spider.


n.n said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
n.n said...

"trees can communicate with each other through their roots"... Anyone know, off the top of his head, what she is going on about with that assertion?

Plants are people... persons, too. Vegans threaten the diversity and viability of flora, and consequently natural carbon sequestration. For the sake of the privileged minority, we need to mitigate the progress of climate change and save a tree. Plan ahead, abort.

Swede said...

There are lots of people who I feel should be dropped off on a deserted Scottish island with no electricity.

Tomcc said...

Marc @ 5:03: Anyone know, off the top of his head, what she is going on about with that assertion?

Well, it could be a sly reference to Scooter Libby's letter to Judith Miller (Aspens).

No, I don't have any idea. But it is an interesting factoid.

Josephbleau said...

I think Marianne said she lived on an uninhabited island, but the professor set her straight. When I was a small kid we had a 1 acre lot next to a small calf operation, a horse farm and a lumber warehouse. Every day an adventure. We dug a shaft 8 foot deep with lateral tunnels and never got caught.

Josephbleau said...

hit rock or it would have been deeper.

Kirk Parker said...

Seeing Red,

Actually, implement what they want and most of us proles will die. Live with a 1500s level of technology, expect to be able to support a 1500s level of population. You can expect a 95% die off.