I just saw "Inside Llewyn Davis" and I don't get it. Will someone please explain this movie to me? Is there really anything going on here or is this just another instance of the Coens goofing on cinastes?
P.S. I am 64 years old and well familiar with the Greenwich Village folk scene of the early 60s. I also know about the real-life people upon whom the characters were based. And I know that the movie was sort of inspired by Dave van Ronk's autobiography. I still don't get it.
And now this other parallel, this symmetry inside for everything on the outside, the writer in winter at his desk, caught in the light, beneath the window, bringing together the last and the first, the middle and the edge, the near and the far, and all the troubled lives calling for the one line and the one life, for creation come together in a central unspoken wish, to be held and made one like a god’s blessing out of nowhere, the pen put down so the open palm, warm and full, can touch a wound that heals them all.
@Roughcoat - Just saw it as well. Part of it is a pure goof on modern screenwriting conventions - in particular, the book, "Save The Cat." It's also about the tension between authenticity, entertainment, and commercial success. (Maybe in film making as well as music, given that they are made a movie with a deliberately unlikable protagonist who doesn't evolve. He isn't redeemed or degraded. He just stays an asshole.)
I think the connection to Van Ronk is an act of charity. They didn't use his book in any important way, but they still funneled some money to his heirs.
I believe we have within our midst those who reject the idea things happen for a reason.
This rejects all understanding of physics.
These unlucky few who don't believe in or acknowledge cause and effect are effective in causing effects, daily, which makes this observation of mine Ironic and hence hip/cool/down with it.
I suggest we think about the action/reaction concept and how there could be a reaction without an action.
At the risk of talking past each other, saying words in a cargo-cult manner with the expectation that word salad is Shakespeare, my first inclination is to ask if any thing has a reason for existing.
Next, assuming we can agree that some things happen for a reason, I would like examples of things happening without a reason.
My guess is, limited though I may be in all areas, I could still brainstorm reasons for whatever thing you claim has happened without any reason.
Some people become enraged at the suggestion things happen for a reason.
They make "posters" or graphics on the computer (the royal "the"?) that say Everything happens for a reason? SLAP! And then some throwaway joke.
But the point is contained within the slapping reaction to the action of conveying the attitude everything happens for a reason. It is a self-refuting graphic if your theory is things happen without reason(s).
Ok, as I fashion myself something of a hotel hallway connoisseur, I'll play. . .
Let's start with the obvious. It's not a Hyatt and almost certainly not a Marriott. It's been recently redone in the neo-engergy conservation style. The pallet is late-ought mono with just a hint of acidic hued irony. The starkly scalloped lighting plan bespeaks a recent architecture grad from a southern public university as does the utilitarian (at best) treatment of the door jambs.
I'm going to say it's one of those new "Hey, we're not that uncool" Holiday Inns in southern Indiana or maybe northern Kentucky.
The big mom fad had been food. This food, that food, special diets, etc.
The new fad that's coming on fast is "essential oil." Actually oils. They're mentioned all the time in the social media mom chatter. "Put this on the baby's feet," "Put this in the child's bath," "Put this in a diffuser." Many comments open with, "I don't know if you do essential oils or not, but..."
Support the Althouse blog by doing your Amazon shopping going in through the Althouse Amazon link.
Amazon
I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
Support this blog with PayPal
Make a 1-time donation or set up a monthly donation of any amount you choose:
17 comments:
Is that supposed to be magic carpet?
The carpet crawlers heed their callers
I've had "Dry the Rain" running through my head since before I woke up this morning. The usual cure is to listen to or play the song. Hasn't worked.
That must be fun coming back after a few drinks.
I just saw "Inside Llewyn Davis" and I don't get it. Will someone please explain this movie to me? Is there really anything going on here or is this just another instance of the Coens goofing on cinastes?
P.S. I am 64 years old and well familiar with the Greenwich Village folk scene of the early 60s. I also know about the real-life people upon whom the characters were based. And I know that the movie was sort of inspired by Dave van Ronk's autobiography. I still don't get it.
Sorry, "cineastes."
THIS OTHER PARALLEL
And now this
other parallel,
this symmetry
inside
for everything
on the outside,
the writer in winter
at his desk,
caught in the light,
beneath the window,
bringing together
the last and the first,
the middle and the edge,
the near and the far,
and all the troubled lives
calling for the one line
and the one life,
for creation come together
in a central
unspoken wish,
to be held
and made one
like
a god’s blessing
out of nowhere,
the pen put down
so the open palm,
warm and full,
can touch a wound
that heals them all.
© David Whyte
@Roughcoat - Just saw it as well. Part of it is a pure goof on modern screenwriting conventions - in particular, the book, "Save The Cat." It's also about the tension between authenticity, entertainment, and commercial success. (Maybe in film making as well as music, given that they are made a movie with a deliberately unlikable protagonist who doesn't evolve. He isn't redeemed or degraded. He just stays an asshole.)
I think the connection to Van Ronk is an act of charity. They didn't use his book in any important way, but they still funneled some money to his heirs.
I believe we have within our midst those who reject the idea things happen for a reason.
This rejects all understanding of physics.
These unlucky few who don't believe in or acknowledge cause and effect are effective in causing effects, daily, which makes this observation of mine Ironic and hence hip/cool/down with it.
I suggest we think about the action/reaction concept and how there could be a reaction without an action.
Where does the "re" factor in?
At the risk of talking past each other, saying words in a cargo-cult manner with the expectation that word salad is Shakespeare, my first inclination is to ask if any thing has a reason for existing.
Next, assuming we can agree that some things happen for a reason, I would like examples of things happening without a reason.
My guess is, limited though I may be in all areas, I could still brainstorm reasons for whatever thing you claim has happened without any reason.
Some people become enraged at the suggestion things happen for a reason.
They make "posters" or graphics on the computer (the royal "the"?) that say Everything happens for a reason? SLAP! And then some throwaway joke.
But the point is contained within the slapping reaction to the action of conveying the attitude everything happens for a reason. It is a self-refuting graphic if your theory is things happen without reason(s).
Are there any vending machines around here?
Ok, as I fashion myself something of a hotel hallway connoisseur, I'll play. . .
Let's start with the obvious. It's not a Hyatt and almost certainly not a Marriott. It's been recently redone in the neo-engergy conservation style. The pallet is late-ought mono with just a hint of acidic hued irony. The starkly scalloped lighting plan bespeaks a recent architecture grad from a southern public university as does the utilitarian (at best) treatment of the door jambs.
I'm going to say it's one of those new "Hey, we're not that uncool" Holiday Inns in southern Indiana or maybe northern Kentucky.
The big mom fad had been food. This food, that food, special diets, etc.
The new fad that's coming on fast is "essential oil." Actually oils. They're mentioned all the time in the social media mom chatter. "Put this on the baby's feet," "Put this in the child's bath," "Put this in a diffuser." Many comments open with, "I don't know if you do essential oils or not, but..."
Jay, I don't think that hallway would seem strange in a Hyatt Place. But then, maybe I don't pay much attention to the hallways.
First snake of spring.
. . . Freeman Hunt said... But then, maybe I don't pay much attention to the hallways.
It's never too late start.
Post a Comment