Tweeted NPR, quoted in "NPR mocked for tweet warning tampon shortage a problem for 'people who menstruate'
Twitter users blasted NPR for avoiding use of the word 'women' in the tweet" (Fox News).
It's yet another supply chain problem where women are bearing the brunt of the cost, as mothers struggle to feed their babies during the baby formula shortage.https://t.co/p5mAPlSwPM
— NPR (@NPR) June 13, 2022
পোস্টগুলি
১২৩টি মন্তব্য:
The shortage was caused by men buying tampons. Demand doubled!
The feminine care aisle has to be renamed too.
Aren't we embarrassed by ourselves yet?
Can't we just call them "menstruators"? We don't call them "people who fight fires." We say "firefighter."
Call em whatever you want. Not my problem.
Using the terms interchangeably is the worst of both worlds. It’s like a gesture towards being woke with a head-fake, to use a NBA term. I’m left marveling at NPR’s confusion instead of wondering why tampons are in short supply. Is it Putin? Did he cause this disruption too?
Maybe you haven’t heard but we have a severe shortage of Newcastle Brown Ale. First it was in short supply and now it is impossible to find in SoCal. Which is weird because it’s brewed in Petaluma (northern) California now instead of imported from England. Even Bass ale is out of stock now. Damn it!
NPR, putting the “men” in menstruate.
"Menstruate" is too hard to say. Half the time people say "menstrate." It makes you sound dumb. We should say "period people."
"People who menstruate"
Good one.
Why feminists seem fine that women are being written out of America is baffling to me.
NPR: "There you go, Cons. Do you like that one better? We can do this all day."
“Period people”? Too confusing; might refer to punctuation sticklers.
We should say "period people."
Makes it sound like a costume drama...
I'm not gonna say it.
Merriam-Webster-Webster has it pronounced both ways:
ˈmen(t)-strü-ˌwāt , ˈmen-ˌstrāt
But what’s the new euphemism for men, people who ejaculate?
"People who menstruate"
When first we practice to deceive...
Haw-haw! Those people at NPR are rubes.
But that is true of a lot of our "elites". "Elite" is becoming a disparaging term for "people who will believe anything," and "NPR listener" is becoming another term for "sucker".
Tampons are not a necessity.
"But what’s the new euphemism for men, people who ejaculate?"
How about "sperm donors"? Oh, wait...our elites say women can have sperm.
Haw-haw!
For NPR, covering the supply chain issue, is about advancing the social justice narrative. They don't want people to come together over shared difficulties. They want to divide us over it. They aren't good people. They really aren't. But their ability to twist absolutely anything into another reason to think well of themselves is fucking bulletproof. I think that's the primary thing they impart to their students at elite colleges these days.
Has anyone tried to buy windows lately? There's a 12 to 16 week wait. People who look outside are bearing the brunt of the cost once again, naturally.
The democrats who host all the democrat party "news" shows on all the alphabet channels - assure us it's Mitt Romney's fault... oh and Putin.
Maybe they should take them out of the mens rooms in colleges across the country then. https://thelibertarianrepublic.com/colleges-putting-tampons-mens-bathrooms-men-can-vaginas
The best part of the NPR story is that it will become a self fulfilling prophesy. What is now hard to find will be impossible to find when consumers and profiteers hoard the existing supplies. We can look to White House news conferences announcing that Biden is laser focused on solving the problem using the Defense Production Act and dedicated C-17 fights airlifting tampons. Soon they will need to prioritize C-17s between airlifting tampons, baby formula and Ukrainian military supplies.
Hahah, Left Bank:0)
It’ll be a war, all right.
The Menstruators vs the Ejaculators!
Left Bank of the Charles said...what’s the new euphemism for men, people who ejaculate?
Woke is about erasing women, not men. Not sure why. It's an odd direction to go in given how long they've been demonizing men for.
Dear @Ann,
With respect, I suggest you add the tag "dysphemism" to posts of this sort. You began considering the concept (at least, within the blog) I think here:
https://althouse.blogspot.com/2009/08/death-panel-rhetoric-and-other.html
"Death Panel" as Sarah Palin highlighted decision makers under Obamacare. A much more recent example is the "Don't Say Gay" label opponents effectively stuck on Florida's attempts to insulate young students in state schools from what the legislature considered intrusive and premature sexuality instruction. We see the technique of taking a complex issue, hammering it into a small lump, and attaching a label to the worst feature (real or imputed). So in this case the intended inclusvie kindness complexity of "women and incompletely transitioned male-towards-female pseudo-women" is mocked by the dysphemism "MENstruators".
Oops. Quite obviously I've mistakenly indicated the direction of transition.
"MENstruators" is the shorthand for those more fully, kindly and inclusively called "women and incompletely transitioned female -towards- male pseudo-men"
I apologize to @Ann and to other commentors. I will attempt to be more careful.
It would be so much easier to just refer to persons in transition, who have voluntarily taken on the burdens of both sexes, and carry around some partial set of the anatomy of both, as herms .
Which is another kind of dysphemism, I suppose.
Althouse has applied the wrong tag.
People who menstruate is no more a euphemism for women than Bolshevik subhuman is for Jew.
"Merriam-Webster-Webster has it pronounced both ways: ˈmen(t)-strü-ˌwāt , ˈmen-ˌstrāt But what’s the new euphemism for men, people who ejaculate?"
Does Merriam-Webster — or Merriam-Webster-Webster if that really really is its name — have both e-jac-u-lāt and e-jac-a-lāt?
Does Merriam-Webster-Webster accept "li-berry" and "feb-u-ary"?
At this point, the "u" is silent. Or you can pretend to be "mispronouncing" it knowingly and ironically. Like "liberry."
It's clear that the trans/nonbinary issue is behind this, but also there's an ongoing effort to "normalize" menstruation/menstration and make it something "bleeding people" aren't ashamed to talk about. Cable TV is coming up with a special about this later this year or next. I'm not sure which channel.
"At this point, the "u" is silent."
Also silent is the judgment that people who speak like that are dumb.
As NPR demonstrates, the problem with eliminating the term women from our discourse is that it makes it far more difficult to say “women, minorities hardest hit” about any trend story.
Schrodinger's tampon
Sometimes its in a woman
Sometimes its in people who menstruate
nuke-u-lar - Baby Bush
Amadeus 48 writes, "Haw-haw! Those people at NPR are rubes."
For a typically laconic spade caller, you are being uncharacteristically generous. A rube is a country bumpkin, a thoughtless dupe. Rube is the wrong word, collaborator is more on target.
That's odd. There are plenty in the new dispenser in the men's room...
Alice Cooper has said it... Only WOMEN Bleed
How can something that was completely understood and normal for millennia (that we have 2 sexes in our species just like every other mammal) have now become so incredibly complicated and worthy of endless discussion?
It is almost unbelievable. There is so much wrong with this movement that it is beyond description - and almost all of it damages women.
I THOUGHT progressives were all about 'following the science' in other matters, but in this one, they seem determined to IGNORE the actual science, which is really quite clear and easy to understand.
Quaestor--I'll go with thoughtless dupe, which is what I meant. Country bumpkin doesn't fit, as you say.
But when the carnival wheels into town, NPR is always lined up at the Freaks and Curiosities Show. They are enthralled by the bearded ladies.
Fathers don't feed babies or don't struggle with finding formula?
Earnest Prole: "As NPR demonstrates, the problem with eliminating the term women from our discourse is that it makes it far more difficult to say “women, minorities hardest hit” about any trend story"
Good catch. I'll be stealing that one.
Prof A @ 8:14: You say to-MAY-to, I say to-MAH-to. Etc.
"Dysphemism" is a handy word but it does sound like a blood disorder or something.
"as mothers struggle to feed their babies during the baby formula shortage"
Now that's a really special line.
If it was breast feeding, then "mothers would be struggling".
But to say that only mother care about feeding their kids at all?
That's a really special claim.
We need to completely end funding for NPR, and for every other institution controlled by the Left.
If a useful institution is controlled by the left, then destroy it, and create a new one where no one who worked at the previous one can get a job.
But it's time to knock down everything they control that's on the taxpayer's dime, and sow the ground with salt
It should be mxnstruate.
Kevin said...
NPR, putting the “men” in menstruate.
Thank you Kevin, I needed that laugh
"We should say "period people.""
Better: People of Periods, AKA PoPs.
Do average lefties think this kind of language is normal?
Chest-feeding, pregnant people?
It goes against the grain of the entirety of human history.
If you want people on your side, you can only go so far left.
After that you lose even the crazies...
tim maguire said...
Left Bank of the Charles said...what’s the new euphemism for men, people who ejaculate?
Woke is about erasing women, not men. Not sure why.
"Woke" is about competition among people who believe in a victim hierarchy
"Women" are above "men" in the victim hierarchy
So if you're a left wing male who wants to win in the woke wars, your primary goal is to come up with ways that you can leapfrog women.
The trans craze is perfect for that.
Now, why it is that women are so desperately eager to help lower their status? That I can't figure out.
I think that part of it is that feminism has been run by women who absolutely hated being women. Which is why they so consistently denigrated "women's work", and any women who were happy doing traditionally female things.
But that's not nearly enough explanation
Why do we accept the patriarchal use of the term MENstrauting? Shouldn't it be "People who period". MayBee has a good option too.
'"Menstruate" is too hard to say. Half the time people say "menstrate."'
Like Feb-u-ary or Libary or (God forbid) Nuke-u-lar?
I am always careful to pronounce the R in the name for our second month....
"Blogger Ann Althouse said...
"At this point, the "u" is silent."
Also silent is the judgment that people who speak like that are dumb."
As one who has never had reason to write the word menstruate before, I had to double check how it is spelled because I have never heard the second "u" pronounced in my 60+ years. I think it reflects more on how the person who judges people on what is a common (or in my circles, the normal) pronunciation. Some closed-minded people might judge the person who pronounces the "u" as pretentious.
Temujin said...
Aren't we embarrassed by ourselves yet?
The people who should be embarrassed are called "them".
The Biden administration has been particularly hard on women and children.
Actually NPR botches it twice. The follow-up focuses on "women" and "mothers" despite the fact that FATHERS are also raising children and feeding them, especially when formula is involved.
Semicolon people.
As per CBS News, "Grocery shoppers have likely noticed an empty shelf of late where household staples like baby formula or sunflower oil are normally on display. Many online buyers are also coming up empty on everything from packaged goods to clothes and tools.
About 31% of grocery products consumers browsed were out of stock in the first week of April, according to Datasembly, a research firm that tracks grocery and retail pricing. That's up from 11% at the end of November 2021. Out-of-stock notices were even more common in Connecticut, Delaware, Montana, New Jersey, Rhode Island, Texas and Washington, where they surpassed 40%."
Why does NPR focus on tampons? Was it solely so they could use the "people who menstruate" phrase?
If you are an outdoorsman, shotgun shells have been in short to nonexistent supply for more than a year, and this week Cabellas was almost completely out of leaders for fly fishing. Where is NPR on this?
I had a friend whose commune had a heated argument over whether tampons should be paid for by the group or only by the women. He defused the situation by developing a new use for them which became quite popular: Christmas tree angel decorations. You pull the cotton most of the way out of the tube and fluff it out to be a skirt etc.
Prince Charles wished he was a tampon in Camilla. Long life to Queen Elizabeth.
Fellas, I recommend distanciation when it comes to menstruation.
If you find yourself in a situation where you can see you're going to have to enunciate the M-word, excuse yourself and get the hell out of there. If you're cornered, change the subject.
Think of it like Fight Club. For guys, the first rule of menstruation is, you don't talk about menstruation.
I guess we need to pronounce the "u" because "menstration" is Bidenese for "my administration."
It's Putin's fault- before the invasion, Ukraine was the world's largest producer of tampons.
People with testicles! They're disappearing our women!
Also, there are apparently no fathers anywhere in the US feeding their babies.
It's a CONSPIRACY... Men are buying up all the Tampons cause they have a feminine side (or so they say)! Just another example of male dominance!!!
“The bloody scene is bloody sad
The bloody news is bloody bad
The bloody weed is bloody turf
The bloody speed is bloody surf
The bloody folks are bloody daft
Don't make me bloody laugh
It bloody hurts to look around
Everywhere in chicken town
The bloody train is bloody late
You bloody wait you bloody wait
You're bloody lost and bloody found
Stuck in fucking chicken town.”
Funny how there was never a shortage of tampons when only women could menstruate.
Supply chain
I'm far more concerned at the misattribution of the shortage to 'supply chain', it is inflation that is causing these issues and has been for the last year!
Welcome to the religious fervor of the "secular" left. We are watching a new religion form in real-time.
Does Merriam-Webster-Webster accept "li-berry"...?
Hmmm...
This calls for immediate stopgap measures.
If the Administration doesn't address this quickly, I'm predicting a red wave this election.
Left Bank of the Charles said...
what’s the new euphemism for men, people who ejaculate?
The appropriate term on this blog is "Splooge Stooge."
Well...there are women who do not menstruate. In fact, all women who live long enough will become women who do not menstruate.
The solution: "Women who menstruate...."
This phrase does not specify between women born physically as women who no longer menstruate and women who became physically women later in life who never have menstruated and never will.
If you are looking for tampons, check your local high school. I bet you can find some in the boys restroom.
Ann, you missed your favorite one!
NPR
@NPR
Existing stigmas and taboos around menstruation make it difficult to garner national attention and action needed to solve the scarcity problem, Marlowe said.
cassandra lite said...
"Funny how there was never a shortage of tampons when only women could menstruate."
Which begs the question. What the hell are the men who are pretending to be women use them for?
AS part of this whole war, I think that you would find this article interesting, Prof Althouse:
https://theintercept.com/2022/06/13/progressive-organizing-infighting-callout-culture/
Tampons are also very useful for polishing shoes to a high gloss, cleaning firearms with good old Hoppes #9, and stanching the flow of blood from a wound. But I am just about certain without a lick of effort to seek details, that these uses of tampons have negligible effect on the availability of the product for their more common use.
No matter what sex change you attempt, XY can never menstruate or get pregnant. But let's continue with the make believe...
C'mon, man. Let's not go nucular about how to pernounce menstrate, liberry, Febuary, etc.
Why don't we go back to 'that-time-of-the-month'?
If young woman would simply feed their brats breast milk like they did in the good old days, they wouldn't be menstruating so much. Elimination of the need for inferior formula and toxic shock Tampax. That's the actual supply chain shortcomings.
It used to be that we all understood our shortcut terms and did not make it a personal affront when we were not part of the group being referred to.
Why is it we have to specify that tampons are for people of the period. (Periodicals?)
All my life regarding feminine hygiene, we would just say women, everyone would know that we were not talking about pre pubescents, pregnant, post menopausals nor Klinger. IT was not necessary to qualify the statement and no one got up in arms about it. No one was confused.
But now with our national narcissism we all have to be special and make sure that we are included or excluded as the case may be. How tedious. Get over yourself, also quit being overconcerned about pushing advocacy by proxy.
Library: where you find books
Lie Barry: One who tells you that you can keep your doctor.
Soon the only real women will have once been men. To imply a transgender is not a complete woman will be called hate speech.
Baby formula shortage is not a women problem. One of the main reasons for using formula is that fathers can feed babies.
Howard said...
If young woman would simply feed their brats breast milk like they did in the good old days, they wouldn't be menstruating so much. Elimination of the need for inferior formula and toxic shock Tampax. That's the actual supply chain shortcomings.
Yeah, it has nothing to do with the Regime you support.
Howard thinks those women with kids need to take responsibility for their circumstances.
But Howard will never take responsibility for his actions or the Regime he supports.
Ever.
It is part of being a total piece of shit.
Let he/she who hath pronounced "err" correctly cast the first stone.
Welcome to the religious fervor of the "secular" left. We are watching a new religion form in real-time.
An ancient religion (i.e. behavioral protocol).
A Twilight faith. An "ethical" (i.e. relativistic) religion. A progressive (i.e. monotonically) liberal (i.e. divergent) ideology. In Mortal Gods and Goddesses They Trust... and Stork to deliver at the time of coincidence.
Speciest. Do canines need tampons?
Do Dogs Have Periods?
Female dogs typically reach sexual maturity around six months old and that’s when have their first “heat” or estrus cycle.
...
When your dog is in heat, there are both physical and behavioral signs. For example, she’ll typically urinate more than usual, and there will be a blood-tinged discharge and swollen vulva.
Someone needs to send Achilles a binky and some tampons.
Howard: "If young woman would simply feed their brats breast milk like they did in the good old days, they wouldn't be menstruating so much. Elimination of the need for inferior formula and toxic shock Tampax. That's the actual supply chain shortcomings."
Please let this be the next democratical spin on the reality the dem foot soldiers spent months denying even existed at all.
It actually makes a good deal of sense. There are lots of women who don't menstruate, and it seems unlikely that many of them are inconvenienced by the shortage of tampons. "People who menstruate" are, precisely, the people who find a tampon shortage inconvenient.
Here in Oregon, you can always find a tampon in the boys' restroom at a public school. The law requires it. Which is kind of weird, really. We have all heard about the guys who like to dress up like women and go in the girls' restroom so they can rape girls. No surprise there. Of course Democrats are in favor of that! Of course! But who ever heard of a girl who likes to dress like a boy so she can go in the boys' restroom and try to pee standing up? I don't think there's a lot of that around.
"It is part of being a total piece of shit."
In Howard's defense, I don't think he has achieved totality. He's around 70-80%. But like the squirrel, he occasionally finds a nut.
I've long thought that home pregnancy tests could be marketed to men who want to share the pregnancy experience with their partner, or who just enjoy peeing on things.
With all this talk about "people who menstruate" how about some love for people who mensurate?
Mostly non-adjectival men (born with a penis, not pretending to be women) the mensurate 20 and more days every month. Not 3-4.
They don't need cheap tampons. Mensuration burden them with expensive and heavy necessities.
So let's give a shout out to all the male and female mensurators out there.
John LGBTQ Henry
To Jason:
Well done!!!
Baby formula, tampons.
DEF fluid is next. You think the supply chain is bad now. Cut truck transport in half and see where that gets you.
My granddaughter, who is a student in a very PC college in the US, tells me the girls were encouraged to use vaginal cups instead of tampons because they are reusable and better for the environment.
So is this a plot by the evil (/s) ecology minded folk to encourage the use of these?
In the Bible, the euphemism is 'the way of women.' Rachel is sitting in her tent on a saddle where she has hidden items stolen from her father Laban. When he comes into the tent to search for them, she says, "Forgive me, my lord, from not standing up, but the way of women is upon me."
In the Gospels, there is also the woman with the flow of blood who comes up behind Jesus in a crowd and touches the edge of his cloak. She is immediately healed. Jesus affirms her faith and calls her Daughter.
It actually makes a good deal of sense. There are lots of women who don't menstruate,
It's true that not all women menstruate, but only women menstruate. Presumably, people... persons refers to all humans from the Grand Coincidence ("birth") or shortly thereafter, less granny (e.g. planned parent/hood), and other deplorables/disposables in Times of Opportunity.
Blogger pacwest said...
Baby formula, tampons.
DEF fluid is next. You think the supply chain is bad now. Cut truck transport in half and see where that gets you.
The DEF shortage could be solved by the EPA allowing diesel trucks to run without DEF, which is supposed to reduce emissions or something.
Another crisis by design. This stuff is all in the plan.
Menstrate for menstruate is incorrect, but I don't think it sounds any dumber than saying Febuary for February.
Bleeders and breeders hardest hit.
Makes me happy to have reached the crone stage.
Michael
Just got finished reading a good explanation of the Def shortage by Donald sensing.
https://sensingonline.blogspot.com/2022/06/get-ready-for-catastrophic-def-shortage.html?m=1
Union pacific rr is refusing to ship it. Cf industries is refusing to make it.
Both are controlled by Black Rock & Vanguard funds.
4 people named donilin control black rock and vanguard And hold positions in Brandon's administration
The whole article doe a great job of connecting the dots.
John LGBTQ Henry
You know what else needs Def? Tractors, combines, cultivators and most other farm equipment.
I said a month or two ago that Brandon is engineering a famine. I don't think it is too paranoid to say that millions of Americans will die.
Many literally starved to death. As in holodomor, for a Ukraine connection.
Many others will die in the accompanying violence
John LGBTQ Henry
Easy "BIPOC and people who menstruate hardest hit."
Close your eyes, take a deep breath, and imagine having an ideology for which it perfect makes sense to say "people who menstruate."
Men, women, and "our Posterity" are from Earth. Feminists are from Venus. Masculinists are from Mars. Social progressives are from Uranus.
Kate,
Tampons are not a necessity.
Of course they aren't. I spent the entire period (no puns intended) from menarche to menopause w/o using a single tampon. Pads for me.
I did, though, once buy one. I was at the Juilliard School, between classes, and wandered down to the second floor and checked out the bathroom. There I found a dispenser labeled "sanitary napkins," and I thought that they must be like the hand-wipes you got in restaurants and such, so I put in the required coin. Only what popped out wasn't anything like that, but what I described to my mom as like a little paper caterpillar. Mom, of course, laughed her head off.
I should add to "lie-berry," "nukular," Feboo-ary," &c., "relaty" for "realty." My Mom uses that, though she would be ashamed to be caught using any of the others.
It's part of the Biden plan to transition to renewables.
You ladies are just gonna have to stuff a dishrag down there.
And throw it in with the rest of the laundry.
After posting the comment abut Union Pacific Railway cutting DEF shipment, I remembered something from a couple months ago:
U.S. fertilizer manufacturer CF Industries (CFI) is advising customers it serves, via Union Pacific rail lines, that railroad-mandated shipping reductions will result in nitrogen fertilizer shipment delays during spring planting season.
Union Pacific informed CFI, without advance notice, that it was mandating approximately 30 shippers, including CFI, to reduce the volume of private cars on its railroad effective immediately. CFI was told to reduce its shipments by nearly 20%.
Non-compliance, according to CFI, will result in the embargo of its facilities by Union Pacific. That means CFI will be unable to accept new rail sales involving Union Pacific customers for the foreseeable future.
https://www.michiganfarmnews.com/union-pacific-restricts-fertilizer-shipments-will-not-accept-new-orders
So not being able to run tractors and other farm machinery may not be as bad as I thought since farmers will not be able to get the fertilizer they need anyway. No crops, no need for equipment. DEF problem solved. (Yeah, right)
I had looked for answers about why UP was cutting back DEF shipments and could not find any. But, looking for the story about the fertilizer, I found this:
BlackRock CEO Larry Fink says he believes in “forcing behaviors.” "Behaviors are going to have to change and this is one thing we are asking companies, you have to force behaviors and at Blackrock, we are forcing behaviors."
https://ragnarforseti.substack.com/p/watch-blackrock-ceo-larry-fink-says?s=r
Video at the link of Fink saying this at NYT Deal Book (From the backdrop) The Tweet was from March 23,2022 and I have the impression that the video was from a day or two before but it doesn't say when.
Black Rock owns 12-15% of Union Pacific. Vanguard Capital owns another 10-15% and the two companies seem closely twined.
John LGBTQ Henry
NPR--deserves to fail--for a long time now, actually.
I leave the U out of menstruate but compensate by adding an R in Warshington DC
So, alphabetical parity overall.
John LGBTQ Henry
BlackRock CEO Larry Fink says he believes in “forcing behaviors.” "Behaviors are going to have to change and this is one thing we are asking companies, you have to force behaviors and at Blackrock, we are forcing behaviors."
Maybe BlackRock execs will breathe a colllectivist sigh of relief when they bring on holodormor-scale famine. After that, they'll insist we all get with the pogrom.
Do dogs have periods?
Dogs (and other mammals) have estrous cycles, but only primates menstruate per se.
I had a client who went to engineering school in Romania in the late 70s.
At that time, tampons were illegal in Romania. He and his wife went on vacation somewhere and, as a gift, brought back some tampons to a friend.
The friend's husband complained to my client that "We appreciate the contraceptives you brought us. But they do make sex somewhat painful." (Quote approximate)
John LGBTQ Henry
In this particular situation, this actually is only relevant to people who menstruate, and only a subset of them, as many do not use tampons. I'm far more offended by the suggestion that the desire to feed your babies is an issue only for women.
একটি মন্তব্য পোস্ট করুন
Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 2 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith.