"Getting mad at the tweets is what Freud called displacement."
It would be reasonable for anyone, including ourselves, to "get mad at the tweets," since they are after all disgusting. Even if she is feeling anger at her father, she can very easily be "mad at the tweets" without committing "displacement."
She may be feeling anger at her father, or she may have seen his struggles with depression up close and personal and knew it was just a matter of time. It's even possible, although perhaps unlikely at this point, that she accepts the fact that he isn't suffering any more. I only knew Robin Williams from his personna and from his work. She knew him all her life up close and personal. I don't presume to project emotions onto other people.
Support the Althouse blog by doing your Amazon shopping going in through the Althouse Amazon link.
Amazon
I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
Support this blog with PayPal
Make a 1-time donation or set up a monthly donation of any amount you choose:
১২টি মন্তব্য:
Not too bright, going on Twitter now,...
The tweets are nothing compared to what her dad did to her.
But the tweets are indeed horrible.
Another way that shows how people forget there are other real people out there. Or maybe don't forget. Just get to the point they don't care.
Althouse is much more gentle with this suicide than other self-murders.
The tweets are nothing compared to what her dad did to her.
Why not let her be the judge of that.
"Althouse is much more gentle with this suicide than other self-murders."
You might have missed yesterday's post.
This post is about the daughter.
And this post is on the day's theme: social media problems.
"Why not let her be the judge of that."
Because I'm not in charge of letting or not letting her do anything.
But it seems pretty clear that her dad's suicide is more emotionally traumatic than two tweets about it.
Would she have responded to those tweets in the same way had her dad not first committed the initial self-violence?
"The tweets are nothing compared to what her dad did to her."
Getting mad at the tweets is what Freud called displacement.
"Getting mad at the tweets is what Freud called displacement."
It would be reasonable for anyone, including ourselves, to "get mad at the tweets," since they are after all disgusting. Even if she is feeling anger at her father, she can very easily be "mad at the tweets" without committing "displacement."
Even if she is feeling anger at her father
She may be feeling anger at her father, or she may have seen his struggles with depression up close and personal and knew it was just a matter of time. It's even possible, although perhaps unlikely at this point, that she accepts the fact that he isn't suffering any more. I only knew Robin Williams from his personna and from his work. She knew him all her life up close and personal. I don't presume to project emotions onto other people.
Larry J,
Agreed on every point.
Paddy O - by putting different values onto her grief, you're making assumptions about her that you can't back up.
একটি মন্তব্য পোস্ট করুন