December 2, 2025

Michelle Goldberg calls Olivia Nuzzi's book "a grandiose postmodern pastiche that attempts to situate her personal catastrophe in the context of our collective one."

"Interspersed with Nuzzi’s stream-of-consciousness musings are facts about drone strikes, gun deaths and wild fires; long chunks of Q&A dialogue, including with Donald Trump; a court document detailing the assault on Nancy Pelosi’s husband; an F.B.I. report on the man who wrote the children’s book 'Harold and the Purple Crayon'; and quotes from figures including Friedrich Nietzsche, Carl Jung and Jane Birkin. It’s a pretentious mess, but an audacious one. It seems less an attempt to justify herself to the Beltway world she once inhabited than to catapult over it, into the more congenial realms of art and literary celebrity."


I read the excerpt from Nuzzi's book when Vanity Fair published it a couple weeks ago, and I too made fun of the florid, pretentious writing. But "grandiose postmodern pastiche" — in the New York Times — makes me feel a twinge of empathy. What if Nuzzi is genuinely literary? What she did is perhaps what I would have done in the same circumstances — tossed out of my ongoing career with nothing but raw material, raw emotion, a publisher's advance enough to cover living expenses, and whatever true writing gift I could find inside myself. They thought I was a journalist, that I would write a fast-moving, funny, fact-filled account of my interaction with RFK Jr., but they don't know, they don't know what I am....

Here's the book, "American Canto" (commission earned).

41 comments:

john mosby said...

When I see the word canto, I think Dante and Ezra Pound. So which is Nuzzi: a religious visionary or a crazed Nazi? CC, JSM

Mike (MJB Wolf) said...

Best promo I saw for the book was a satirical one: How I Found Out My Journalist Side Piece Was Cheating on Me With Her Fiancé Again

Mike (MJB Wolf) said...

Read the article while listening to Livvy's hot single she cut when she was sixteen called "Jailbait." I'm sensing a pattern in her life.

Dave Begley said...

“ As of its initial release, the book is ranked #17,754 in general books on Amazon.com.”

Temujin said...

There isn't a universe where I find myself interested in the thoughts of Olivia...(checks notes) Nuzzi. Not slamming you for writing on this, or giving it time to ponder. It's just not for me. But...the reason I'm even bothering to post a comment is that in reading your post, my thought was...why doesn't Ann write her own artistic and literary treatise on her past decades as a blogger?
It might be very interesting to see your views on the entire thing: The world of blogging from the beginning days into today's social media world. The commenters, that entire universe of personalities, both brilliant and deranged. The relationship that develops between the blogger and those commenters that you never meet but feel like you know. The topics and why some hit you, and some don't. Why you love delving into word origins and why other topics bore you to tears.

I dunno. As one of the early and few remaining successful bloggers, your view on this 'art form' might be interesting to some. Throw in some dirt on Meade and you might have a best seller.

Money Manger said...

I too read the Goldberg column (on Webpage Archive--I would never pay money for the NYT), and wondered why anyone would buy Nuzzi's book, or why Goldberg would write a column on it (save the opportunity to take a few potshots at Trump's cabinet). People and things not to care about 2x.

Don't count on much from the Amazon link commission.

Bob Boyd said...

Collaboration horizontale! Shave her head!

Dave Begley said...

Agree that Ann should write a book about blogging. Self-publish and sell it on Amazon.

rehajm said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
boatbuilder said...

Goldberg writing about Nuzzi.
I'll take a pass.

rehajm said...

Oh- I got to read this one and find it delicious. So much pyric leftie woman drivel. Let’s unpack-

the implosion of America. If you find yourself empathizing with her thoughts let me gently reveal a shocker- you do not live in a monarchy- no kings they say. Translation- sometimes people you don’t like will be in charge. I hear the cotswolds are fabu if the zoloft isn’t enough to cope.

the story of her baffling affair with Robert F. Kennedy Jr- there is nothing baffling about it. When RFKJ was bouncing around the Back Bay and Scituate every middle aged leftie lady in my orbit had a chronic case of the drippy thigh sweats. To call it baffling exposes your embarrassment for lusting after a political turncoat

She lives in Malibu now- wtf is it with lefties on the dole and Malibu? You can hate on The Yellowstone Club since there’s conservatives there, too but for chrissakes Santa Barbara is waaay nicer than that little strip of torched sand.

and Jane Birkin …speaking of drippy thigh sweats dreams of the Hermes tote are never far from the leftie female prefrontal cortex

is that Nuzzi doesn’t seem to recognize that her collaboration with Kennedy was a grave professional betrayal- I get her job was commentary but can’t help but think they all would believe this about any of their ‘journalists’ as well

Eric the Fruit Bat said...

It doesn't seem like much of a selling point to say you can read a book all the way through and end up no smarter.

rehajm said...

“American Canto” wants to capture the atmosphere of paranoid, ambient menace that’s been choking this country for the last decade- yah, we’ve been trying to eradicate the cause of that (see: end government funding of NGOs)

FormerLawClerk said...

Nobody gives a fuck what these idiots are doing or what the NYT thinks of it, especially Michelle Goldberg. NOBODY CARES.

rehajm said...

None of the infants who died of pertussis in Kentucky over the past 12 months had been vaccinated, nor had their mothers- this tale is more hillbilly elegy poverty than part of the political war on sensible vaccination. Anyone recalling Malibu and the Brikin bag in the same stanza should refrain from exposing their elitism and zip it…

William said...

I'm definitely not her target audience, but she's inspired a NYT column and a commentary from Altthouse. She'll definitely sell some books. I guess if you want to write a bodice ripper for the high end market you've got to throw in some stream of consciousness and Nietzsche quotes. I see Sydney Sweeney in the movie role with lots of tasteful nudity. I see Sydney Sweeney in a lot of roles like that.

wendybar said...

Olivia Nuzzi is a Carolyn Bessette Kennedy wannabe....

rhhardin said...

Harold and the Purple Crayon (book) was written by Crockett Johnson, author of the excellent Barnaby strip in WWII. Beats Peanuts and Doonesbury.

rehajm said...

Together, Lizza and Nuzzi are keeping the fire of their incinerated reputations going. Rarely has scandal looked so much like performance art- Long ago the Thomason’s instructed the Clinton’s to never apologize. No matter the hot mess, so long as they don’t switch sides and just keep plugging along they’ll be fine…

rehajm said...

…I don’t know these people so I had to look- she’s surprisingly short waisted and chunky for a risky side piece…

narciso said...

Shes an average bleach blonde who makes up with enthusiasm i suppose

narciso said...

But mark sanford good grief she needs to more discriminating

Eva Marie said...

“Olivia Nuzzi first gained widespread media attention in 2013 as a 20-year-old undergraduate intern for Anthony Weiner’s New York City mayoral campaign. After her brief stint, she wrote a critical tell-all piece for the New York Daily News (which ended up on the front page) detailing chaotic campaign dynamics, including Weiner’s habit of calling interns “Monica” (a reference to Monica Lewinsky) and suggesting staff joined primarily to network with his wife, Huma Abedin. In response, Weiner’s communications director, Barbara Morgan, unleashed an expletive-laced tirade during an interview with Talking Points Memo (TPM). Morgan called Nuzzi a ‘slutbag,’ ‘twat,’ ‘cunt,’ and ‘bitch,’ accused her of being fame-hungry and incompetent . . .”
They just might both be right.

narciso said...

Now laura logan the really life patsy kensit

narciso said...

Who was betrayed by cbs nearly died in south africa of ebola

Curious George said...

"rehajm said...
…I don’t know these people so I had to look- she’s surprisingly short waisted and chunky for a risky side piece…"

"narciso said...
Shes an average bleach blonde who makes up with enthusiasm i suppose"

Now do Michelle Goldberg. Ugh. And that stupid bob hairstyle.

Humperdink said...

Nuzzi volunteered for the Anthony Weiner mayoral campaign while a junior at Fordham. Weiner labeled her and a fellow intern Monica. (Wiki)

Ann Althouse said...

"Agree that Ann should write a book about blogging. Self-publish and sell it on Amazon."

Just putting it that way makes it obvious why I wouldn't do that. It would be easy to list at least 5 good reasons.

I could see using AI to extract and shape a "book" out of the material that's already in the archive, but just to say that is to be done with it.

boatbuilder said...

Althouse--without a lot of tawdry adultery and catfighting involving pseudo-celebrities, I don't see much of a market.

Aggie said...

"...It’s a pretentious mess, but an audacious one....."

Reminds me of: 'The food there is terrible, but the portions are large.'

Ann Althouse said...

"“Olivia Nuzzi first gained widespread media attention in 2013 as a 20-year-old undergraduate intern for Anthony Weiner’s New York City mayoral campaign...."

I blogged that at the time: https://althouse.blogspot.com/2013/07/dickmanship-part-2-women-in-politics.html

Excerpt:

"3 of yesterday's 14 posts had substantial Weiner content. But I passed on the Olivia Nuzzi story in yesterday's Daily News... It just looked like another woman trying to horn in on the Weiner action. Who is she? Who does she think she is? Yeah, campaigns have interns. She asserts that Weiner interns are hot to get to Huma and through Huma to Hillary, but that's not surprising or disturbing. Ambitious people seek to network and climb. Why is this even in the newspaper? To my eye, it looked like Nuzzi's selling point was her ability to look somewhat pretty posing with tilted head; long, flowy, bleached-blonde hair; lips pursed just short of duck face; and a tight, sleeveless navy blue dress.... I'd kicked the sext-crazed man around enough, and Nuzzi was such an unsubtle attention whore, so the best thing to blog is nothing. But that was yesterday. Why am I writing about Nuzzi today? Because there's another woman stepping out onto the stage of The Anthony Weiner Clown Show, and her I find amusing, and she's not an attention whore. She didn't realize she was on stage. She thought/claims she was giving an off-the-record interview. It's Weiner’s communications director Barbara Morgan...."

Kakistocracy said...

Nuzzi is like Trump in this sense: the worst thing about America is not that someone that awful exists, the worst thing is that much of the press promotes and normalizes it for clicks.

Anyway, Nuzzi is going to milk this latest set of gross revelations for all it’s worth, parlaying it into more insipid fawning coverage on her I’m-not-sorry-but-this-is-a-redemption-tour gig.

She’s basically a less charming George Santos.

john mosby said...

Prof: “ substantial Weiner content”

I really should put that as a warning banner on all my comments. CC, JSM

narciso said...

Shes a terribly shallow woman thats why new yawk magazine hired her

Mike (MJB Wolf) said...

I too have been criticized for too much weiner content and I am unapologetic. But I'm certain that the new bun-length ones from Oscar-Mayer are what we always needed, even if they hang out of certain buns.

rehajm said...

Reminds me of: 'The food there is terrible, but the portions are large.'

Well done. As I said- delicious!

narciso said...

He was a beard for brotherhood operative name escapes me now

Lucien said...

FLC said it for me.

rehajm said...

And that stupid bob hairstyle

I envision that moment, propped in the A-list stylist's chair, contemplating the strategy: Can you cut it like Moe?

narciso said...

Well there nothing under that hair

narciso said...

https://m.imdb.com/name/nm1022561/

Post a Comment

Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 2 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith.